New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

Posts

Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#1

Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

James Watriss

Recalling that thread a month or two ago, I was in Woodcraft the other day, and picked up a cloth buffing wheel and a medium hardness felt wheel for my wee 6" grinder. It's been used as a dust collector for years, since I also have an 8" slow speed, a Jet wet wheel Tormek knock-off, and various other things. So putting a still functional tool back into rotation felt good. I also have a disc/belt grinder, which seems to be the other half of the buffing wheel equation.

I did have to spin up some bushings to center the 5/8" hole on my 1/2" arbor, but that didn't take too long. I also had to spin the grinder guards around, since the motor needs to be running backwards to do this sort of thing safely.

Currently, the belt grinder is running 100 grit, which is way too coarse for this kind of setup. I think I'll move to a 32 if I can find one, or even 400. But I can already see why Tage Frid used to do it this way. Holy crap this is easy. It's not that I hate honing and sharpening, but this is like moving from a chef's knife to a food processor... sharpening is so much more likely to happen now if I'm in the middle of a project that I need to get done.

Pointers or suggestions from experienced parties?

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#2

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

Bob Hackett

One question Jim;Do you have a wood lathe?

You`ll see why in a later post.

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#3

I like to

David Miller from Iowa

Flatten the back and polish it before I grind the bevel in the front - helps prevent round over. Once I have ground the front bevel down to 4000 on a stone, I swipe both the front and back ONCE on the buffer to make a miniscule secondary bevel.

Everyone has there onw way, but this works for me.

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#4

Sharp and fast...

John in NM

Gotta love a buffing wheel. I have a hand cranker with a hardish wheel. Mostly use it for smoothing plane blades, its really nice to be able to do a quick touch up when planing difficult woods. Use it some on chisels, but I'm not that picky about the edges on my chisels so often I just use a soft arkansas and call it good.

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#5

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

James Watriss

I do, but the wheels are mounted to a bench grinder right now.


img

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#7

I've never buffed straight edges like plane blades

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and chisels, mostly because I don't want to dub the flat backs. However, I keep a hard felt wheel in my 6" grinder along with a fine white wheel and use it to keep turning gouges razor sharp, especially in the middle of turning something.

I recall an article of FWW by Rude Osolnik in which he described his sharpening process: he used a belt sander and a hard felt wheel, and he didn't even turn off his lathe.

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#8

Need something wider

James Watriss

I'm using a 6" wide belt grinder

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#9

Re: Need something wider

David Weaver

Supergrit (google it) has cork polishing belts that you could put a honing compound on.

I'm waiting until the next time I visit my parents to go to their store and look at them to see if they're worth having on my belt sander. I generally use the belt sander only for two things - grinding convex irons and making tools. Belt switching is fast enough it might be nice to leave a cork belt with compound on the thing to touch up chisels and carving tools.

I don't usually strop chisels and plane irons, but if I do, it's usually on MDF, which I like better than leather.

I strop carving tools on a leather wheel, especially incannel gouges since they're a bigger pain to sharpen with stones if you let them get away.

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#10

Alternatives to the wheel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

For me the best strop is a one that requires the minimum of setup time.

Strops may be manual or motorised.

I prefer the simplicity of hard leather glued to hardwood. The horse butt leather sold by Joel at TFWW is really the best available. It is very, very hard (almost like hardwood), which aids in resisting dubbing. So the obvious question is why not just use hardwood? Well hardwood is also a good choice, but I find that rouge will sit on top and not inbed itself into the medium. Leather is preferred because it holds rouge better.

Horse butt with Veritas honing compound:


For an article comparing green honing compound and diamond paste on leather: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Stroppingwithgreenrougeversesdiamondpaste.html

When it comes to motorised strops, the choice is round or flat.

The round strops are used either freehand or with a guide.

In the freehand corner we have simple felt wheels. I have used these for some years and can get a good edge from one. However, I find them unreliable. For the novice it is as easy to dub an edge as get a sharp one. Freehanding on a felt wheel requires more concentration. It can work very well - however it has a smaller margin for error, which makes it risky to use.

Better is the Tormek leather wheel when it is used with the integral tool rest. The Tormek system is really designed to take a freshly ground blade to the leather wheel. However, if one simply wishes to strop an existing edge, then you would need to set up the blade at a desired angle, which can take more time than I have patience.


The best motorised strop, in my experience, is the one I built into a disk sander. This has a piece of chamois leather glued to a sanding disk, which is held with velcro to the disk sander face.


http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/BeltSanderBladeGrinderMK%20II.html

There is much less chance to dub the edge. With the flat disk, the blade is placed down heel-first, then rotated onto the bevel end. A 2-second burst and you are done.

Stropping is done with the rotation of the disk. Demonstration below is taken from Mk I Belt Sander Grinder ( http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/BeltSanderGrinderMkI.html ).


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#11

Re: Alternatives to the wheel

James Watriss

I really dig the chamois on the wheel...

I've also been playing with using the side of the felt wheel on my grinder. I know it's not the same thing as *flat*, but it's flatter than the edge of the wheel, and it occurred to me that I don't need to worry too much about keeping the side guards on the grinder, since a felt wheel is going to be a lot safer than a stone with regards to loading up and side wear.

In my escapades the other day, I think I did manage to dub a couple of tools, hence the need for this thread. But the potential benefits more than outweigh the hassles of a the learning curve. Thanks for sharing your ideas Derek... as always, you're a fount of creative juices. : )

Re: Revisiting the buffing wheel thing

#12

Re: Need something wider

James Watriss

Sounds like a pretty cool idea...

I'll get into that sometime soon, I think. In the meantime, I was just looking for a finer grit that would leave a finish that I could take directly to the felt wheel if I wanted to.

I'm headed off to the shop, I have a few more ideas I need to tinker with around this whole operation. That, in between coats of varnish on a refinishing job. I'll post more as it comes in, but this has been a pretty cool thread so far. There's always been a lot of conversation about sharpening in here, but not much that stuck in my head around power sharpening.