New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

marketing is so intriguing

Posts

marketing is so intriguing

#1

marketing is so intriguing

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Lie-Nielsen's selling a "Maine Granite Sharpening Station," $1295 plus truck freight shipping, 24" by 30" by 1-3/4" thick granite on wooden legs.

Grizzly sells a 24" by 36" surface plate for $160, and a metal stand for another $80, plus a fixed shipping charge of $90.

Not counting shipping, Grizzly's sharpening station is less than 20% of Lie-Nielsen's...an awfully big premium for the name.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#2

David Barnett

That's a polite way to put it

David Barnett

Grizzly's is accurate to +-2 tenths across the entire surface, too. I also prefer black to the headstone grey, but to each his own. My two 18x24x3s cost around $34 each when I got 'em and they're good to +- 1 tenth.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#3

Re: marketing is so intriguing

David Weaver

You guys are way ahead of me if you have yours on a stand. I have mine on the top of an old workbench.

I'll bet you that most of the ancillary tools and accessories LN makes arise from their tool demostrations where they would've made a one-off for themselves to do sharpening. Then, they use it at a show, and everyone with lots of money and no creativity or interest in a little due diligence probably says "if you made a table like that, I'd buy it".

Sort of a combination of no background and things they'd read on different forums, like "you must have a dedicated sharpening station".

At any rate, I'll bet they don't sell too many of them, but I'll also bet they'll sell enough of them to make it worth keeping them listed. In my mind, a $1200 or $1300 reference table with a wooden frame is aimed at the people who view spending $1200 or $1300 the same as they'd view spending $200 - i.e., where either of those numbers doesn't put a dent in the budget.

They probably also build the frame in house where they build benches, which isn't exactly going to be the cheapest way to do it. I am struggling a little to figure out why they didn't at least use a tool room grade granite plate, though. I'd expect something with a Starrett stamp on it. Maybe they thought that was prohibitive cost-wise.

My sharpening station is twice or three times that size, though, and the grinder's not even on it.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#4

Re: a follow-up comment

David Weaver

I have to admit that I am a lot less offended by things that I think are expensive from Lie-Nielsen knowing who they are and how they operate, as compared to when a woodworking retailer replaces high quality good with china-made goods that are 1/10th the cost and then tries to sell them for nearly the same price.

While I'm not the kind of guy who would buy a $1,300 sharpening station, I have yet to buy anything from LN that I feel like I'll outlast what I bought - if you know what I mean.

When I first started in the hobby four years ago, I bought plenty of things from woodworking retailers that were touted with happy smiles and turned out to be nearly worthless junk.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#5

Re: a follow-up comment

Bob Hackett

For those who haven`t visited the WWing mecca that is Maine this sort of thing may be hard to understand.Not surprising as it`s very hard for the local crowd to understand it.

You work your way up the coast from Portland and it`s galleries to Bar Harbor and the coastal national park and you of course HAVE to stop at the LN showroom as it is on the scenic coastal route and on the way to the week long class you have signed up for at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in nearby Rockport.

While at LN you see world class demonstrators or those folks trained by them using all sorts of tools and jigs with huge amounts of mystique attached to them.The showroom just screams "Maine made is best made",to paraphrase a motto from a shipyard down the coast.

This is to be expected.

It only seems natural that LN would use native Maine granite as a base for their sharpening stations rather than importing something from down the coast in Mass. with a Starrett label on it,regardless of quality.

This is Maine we`re talking about here,and all things from this WWing mecca are bound to be as high quality as those stalwart craftsmen who can trace their craft back counting in generations rather than years.

Are you getting the picture?

Needless to say,very few of these granite tools are being used by the locals unless they are high profile celebrities who were selected to receive deep discounts(or donations of said tools) in order to boost sales.

I picked up my granite at $25 a pallet load from a counter top manufacturer and cut enough with a $20 diamond blade on an old Skillsaw to distribute to my buddies who helped me lug it home and cut it before the BBQ.

It came pre-polished and dead flat.

That same diamond bladed saw cut a little more volume of cast iron table saw tables into diamond sharpening plates that day too.

Gotta have something impressive to stack on that highly polished granite slab and nothing impresses the girls like diamonds. :D

What amazes us locals is the very large chasm between the perception of all that is Maine and the reality of living here.I`m sure the year round residents of the Virgin Islands,Jamaica,Barbados and the other winter destinations understand it as little as we do.

That lack of understanding doesn`t keep them from taking the excess visiting money though I`ll bet.It hasn`t stopped us from harvesting it every summer.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#6

Follow up

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I think part of what struck me about this particular one is that Lie-Nielsen has established a sound reputation as a maker of extremely well-made tools that meet real needs. Although I'm very unlikely ever to own any LN tools, my bottom-feeding budget being what it is, I respect what they've done. This feels like the Woodworker's Sharper Image direction that Bridge City Tools inclines - a useful tool, fancied up, at gasp-inducing prices.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#7

Re: a follow-up comment

David Weaver

I've never been to the LN store, but I do own quite a bit of LN stuff (mostly planes and a few chisels).

Coming from a background in a tourist town (Gettysburg), and having spent two weeks going through maine with the wife four years ago, I fully "get" what you mean with the "maine made" thing. It was a little offputting and I didn't buy much up there (just a coffee mug and a wooden bowl - both were very cheap), same as i never bought any of the doofy trinkets in gettysburg. A lot of people buying lobster socks and moose mugs, though, for sure.

I was also dumbfounded by the lack of businesses. I think the unum building was the only thing I saw that wasn't defiantly small business.

The B&B owner at the one place came from out of town and sort of "rescued" a dilapidated property. He said it was 8 years before his neighbor would talk to him (he moved there from new york, though, that may not have helped). Neighbor was a lobsterman and said outsiders did nothing other than raise the price of gas and groceries for everyone else.

of course, the other thing that I couldn't understand is why there would ever be that many red sox and patriot fans.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#8

Re: a follow-up comment

Bob Hackett

We Mainers don`t get why anybody would ever admit that they are a Yankee`s fan so we`re even on that score. :D

No figurin` the mind of folks from away,there chummy.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#9

Re: a follow-up comment

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you spent 10 months out of the year wondering when the snow would melt, you'd be just about tough enough to be a Red Sox fan, too.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#10

Re: a follow-up comment

wilbur

"of course, the other thing that I couldn't understand is why there would ever be that many red sox and patriot fans."

The population of Maine is about 1.3 million total for the state. That's the same as just my county and the next one over here in NJ (Middlesex and Monmouth). That's not that many Red Sox/Patriot fans, if you look at it that way. ;)

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#11

I just guess their too close to Canada ?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Red's & Patriots, Sounds like the Hippie drug culture never left...

BOOM, Ooooo, Ahhhh, Onhhh :D

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#12

Re: marketing is so intriguing

Dean Lapinel

I really like the LN company and they have been good to me. That granite thing however, is an abberrantly priced beast in a company of fine tools and good people.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#13

When I lived there...

John in NM

Population was right around 1 million, and around half were in the southern and coastal counties. Moving from Ashland, Orono and the Bangor area seemed excessively crowded, and the coast was a madhouse. Moving away to go to college I forgot all about it :D

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#14

plus or minus 1/10th of what?

Marv

1/10th of an inch?

Are we talking flatness or overall dimensions?

Did you mean 1/10th of a thousand or .0001?

How did you check it?

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#15

David Barnett

My bad, Marv. A spoken abbr.

David Barnett

When jewelers, watchmakers, gunsmiths, engineers, machinists say, for example, 5 tenths, it means 5 ten-thousandths (0.0005") of an inch.

These plates are certified B-grade, which means a total surface (overall flatness) runout of 1 tenth (there it is again). In fact, mine arrived with certificates showing each plate within spec. An A-grade plate allows only 0.000050� and the AA just half of that.

To check frequently-used plates for wear, one employs a beam-type repeat reading gauge with manual indicator (I don't own one). These metrics are usually done by re-certification technicians with exquisitely calibrated gauges that are themselves routinely re-certified.

L-N's plates are allowed TEN tenths runout in 6". My benchstones are better than that.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#16

Re: My bad, Marv. A spoken abbr.

ThomD

They aren't anything like thick enough to retain any meaningful accuracy either, or correctly supported. Despite the hype surface plates aren't permanent unless they are properly maintained and regularly checked.

The way I look at it is A) What would it cost a kitchen company of note, to provide a high end kitchen with a trestle and granite surface. I've seen what it costs to get counter tops made at HD, let alone anywhere fancy. B) what should they charge so as not to undercut their average customer. I mean sure, you can get granite for less, but their customers are mostly either rich people who pay these prices for everything already, or people making stuff for rich people. They probably all get the pricing.

A few years back I bought a surface plate from a guy who also was selling a Starrett 6'x4' granite 10" thick highest grade plate. He wanted about what LN wants for their station. At that point the only interest was from a guy who wanted it for his woodstove. :(

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#17

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: marketing is so intriguing

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Mentioned it - and the price - to the wife. She asked "Can the granite be engraved?"

I said "Huh?"

She said "Well, if you spend that much money on a piece of rock, you're gonna be buried under it, so it might as well be engraved as your tombstone."

Guess I'll pass on this one...

Jim D.

Re: marketing is so intriguing

#19

A woman with a way with words

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and far more diplomatic - I guess - than "absolutely hell no what are you thinking?"