New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Dovetails on long boards?

Posts

Dovetails on long boards?

#1

Dovetails on long boards?

Denny

I'm planning on dovetailing a cabinet, but it's 6' long x about 2' high. I've done plenty of drawers, but I'm not sure about how to handle a piece this long. Stand on a ladder? Lay the board flat on the bench and kneel on top of it? Neither sounds ideal...

Any other ideas?

Thanks,

Denny

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#2

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

Adam Cherubini

Are you putting the tails on the 6' piece? I've done this sort of thing a couple times, but not many. Yeah, you can cut these with the board horizontal. I have knelt and cut joints from the underside. You can also hold the saw vertically and cut from above.

I'm really not a proponent of sawing dts by eye, using muscle memory, etc etc. I think you need to saw to the line wherever it is.

Adam

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#3

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

chuckbeck

I like kneeling on boards and sawing. You will not chatter a cut, but good light can be trickier.

chuckbeck

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#5

scott grandstaff

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

scott grandstaff

So, what am I missing?

6' long check.

2' high, ok.

presumably it has some depth? 16" , 22"?

Long blanket chest, books or entertainment center or thereabouts??

So, you aren't just laying down the long planks/panels overhanging the end of your bench and using a coping or jewelers saw more or less vertically as they always are used?

Then mark the tails or the pins against that, and saw/pare those out the same way?

I must have the wrong idea.

yours Scott

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#6

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

ThomD

I have a deck on the rear of the house, and a second floor shop. Both of these allow me to set up to saw at normal orientation.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

Moses Yoder

Typically the board would be clamped to the bench with the end you are cutting overhanging the end of the bench. Mark out your dovetails then start cutting at an angle with the handle below the board, hitting the top line and the line on the end of the board. You can either kneel at the end of the board or just bend over. After you have cut to the line at the bottom of the dovetail start tilting the saw upright as you cut. I use a back saw filed rip to cut dovetails, not a coping saw as I find it easier to cut a straight line with a back saw.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#8

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

Dean J from MN

Denny,

I just did this on a stepback cupboard. I just put the long sides on the bench and started the cuts kneeling (so I could see the lines on the end grain) and finished by sitting on the board. You'll be a pro at it by the fourth end.

-Dean

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#9

Do you have a bandsaw?

Marv

I know, I know, BLASPHEMY!! ;)

Tilt the table on your band saw and make all the cuts on one side then tilt the table the other way and make the other cuts.

The waste can be cut out with your coping saw with the boards clamped on edge.

Another option would be to bore a deep hole in your floor.

Still another option would be to go up on the roof of your house.

And another option would be, clamp the boards to a six foot step ladder. I kinda like this option.

Marv

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#10

Re: Do you have a bandsaw?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Have you actually done this? I'm having trouble imagining holding a board that is six feet long and carefully feeding the end into a band saw.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#11

Re: Do you have a bandsaw?

Marv

Warren,

The easiest way to do it on a bandsaw would be to have a second person to hold up the back end of the board. But if the board isn't too heavy, it could be done by yourself. I would clamp a stop behind the blade so I wouldn't cut too deep and so all the cuts would be exactly the same depth.

Marv

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#12

Since we're discussing sinful use of electrons,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

would one of the better sabre saws (aka jigsaws, although that term originally referred to a stationary tool), like the Bosch saws, work? I know those are not as precise as a bandsaw, but with good blades and careful feeding, they can be pretty good.

Myself, I think the advice about kneeling below the work is probably best; with some practice first.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#13

Re: Since we're discussing sinful use of electrons

Marv

The kneeling part, in theory sounds pretty good until one considers the condition of a lot of old woodworking knees. I for one try to never allow my knees to touch the ground. ;)

Yes, a hand held reciprocating saw could do the job, but for me, I don't like how they usually vibrate and bounce around. Also, the woodcutting blades are usually quite thick. I don't like em for an accurate cut.

Marv

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#14

Thanks for all the creative replies...

Denny

I think I like Dean's approach best, start out kneeling in front of the board and finish up sitting on it. This is all easier if you cut tails first in the long board. I'm sure doubling up on the rubber mats will help my knees a lot too...

Thanks!!!

Denny

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#15

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

Paul Dzioba

Just lay the board across two low sawhorses or even spackle buckets. Put one knee on the board near the end and lean forward so that you can see the lines at the top and endgrain of the board.

This is also the ideal situation ergonomically for a Japanese pull type saw. Lay the board so that it overhangs the end of your bench and saw away from that end.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#16

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

David Weaver

A ryoba was my thought, too, because it'll be easier mechanically if the piece is lateral. A combination dozuki might be better, though, since it would start a lot easier and still cut fairly fast. One thine that would be difficult with that method if you go tails first would be finding a perpendicular cut - just let the saw hang free.

It seems like it'll be tedious, though, and difficult to get the kind of accuracy you'd expect working at the bench. On something 6 feet long, that'll be frustrating.

I've learned something from this thread...

... i'm going to stay away from anything that has dovetails on the end of something 6 feet long. :b

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#17

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

markb

OK, but assuming you cut tails first (doesn't really matter which goes first), and the pins board is, let's say, 4' or 5' long, how do you mark the pins from the tails other than by raising the tails board 2'+ off the bench and standing on a ladder?

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#18

Planning the work

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Staying away from the pins-vs-tails-first differences of opinion here,

it would seem that this is an argument for planning the work so that the short piece is the first one done. Depending on the dovetail design, this could be easy or difficult; but if difficult, then maybe the design needs rethinking.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#19

Re: Planning the work

markb

But what if both pieces are long? I'm planning to build a cabinet that is 4' tall by 5' wide. Pins or tails first, it doesn't much matter.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#20

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

Denny

Actually not a problem for me, the 2nd piece is about 2' long, so I can clamp it to the bench and lay the long board down to mark the pins.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#21

Same principle applies

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Although you may need to think creatively about where to place your work while doing the second-piece marking out, how to hold the pieces, etc.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#22

Re: Same principle applies

markb

Ok, thanks. That's what I figured. Just thought (hoped, actually) there might be some brilliant solution I couldn't think of to make things a bit easier.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#23

Moses Yoder

Re: Same principle applies

Moses Yoder

Actually if you cut the pins first on a long piece then you can set your tail board flat on the bench and set the pin board on its end on top of the tail board to mark the tails. So long as your ceiling is high enough that the pin board will set on end on top of the bench.

Re: Dovetails on long boards?

#24

Re: Same principle applies

markb

There you go. An obvious approach that I was missing. Thanks.