New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

Posts

glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#1

glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

ThomD

Are these the same thing? I have to make a window, which will require me to set the pane. The local hardware store no longer sells glazier's putty, but I have some plumber's putty. Can I use the plumber's putty instead?

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#2

Re: glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

It's been a long time and I may be wrong but I think glaziers putty gets hard. Like plastic type hard. It takes a while though. Plumbers putty has to stay pliable. I would keep looking for the glaziers putty.

Please feel free to correct me if I gave incorrect information since it was years ago I worked in the hardware store... :)

Joe

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#3

You nailed it Joe.

Bob Hackett

I would be concerned that plumbers putty wouldn`t accept water based paint also.

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#4

Yes, Joe nailed it. But...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

As said Plumbers putty never hardens. They are not interchangeable.

Every glazing compound I've used (and I've used a lot) wants a oil based primer followed by a oil based top coat.

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#5

Re: glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

Marv

There are a million different kind of caulking compounds at your local HD. Seems there should be one that would work well for holding and sealing a window pane.

Marv

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#6

Re: Yes, Joe nailed it. But...

Bob Hackett

I believe DAP makes a glazer`s putty that accepts water based paint.I recently redid a couple of windows and went to Loew`s to get the putty.It worked just fine with water based paint.

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

Jack Guzman from Maine

I read in an old book on how to do things that the sediment in the bottom of a can of house paint makes a good window putty. Paints are different these days so I don't know if this is still true.---Jack

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#8

Stephen Shepherd

You can make your own

Stephen Shepherd

Mix some Whiting [calcium carbonate, chalk (available at paint stores)] with some boiled linseed oil to the consistency of paste or putty. It takes a while to dry but is the traditional method.

Stephen

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#10

Re: You can make your own

ThomD

Thanks, the two online recipes I found for GP and PP were both whiting and linseed oil, so... There was also limestone in the PP. Maybe mixing in something with dryers would make the PP kick. It comes in a plastic tub so I am not sure it will stay soft in the air. Must try air drying it.

Thanks for all the great info!

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#11

Plumber's putty does harden

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

even in the little plastic tub, if you keep a little tub of it for, say, ten years. I can testify to that.

It seems to have gone out of fashion around here - the instructions that come with sink tailpieces and so on all suggest silicone caulk, probably NOT a classic method, though it works pretty well if you're diligent about immediate cleanup of the caulk squeezeout.

Not that I'm on topic anymore here...

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#12

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

Jim in Burlington On

http://www.ehow.com/how_2126973_make-glaziers-putty.html

Home hardware in Canada still glaziers putty as do most stained glass supply places.

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#13

I bought some at Benjamin Moore...

John in NM

A high end paint store should have proper putty... I like it better than any other window sealing compound, but then look where I'm hanging around :D

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#14

Re: glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

ChrisF

The two are not interchangeable.

The stuff available at big box home centers is usually Dap 33...it's generally considered the lowest quality of all glazing compounds though. Only lasts 7-8 years.

Sherwin-Williams sells their own "66" glazing compound...it seems to be quite a bit better than Dap 33, and is what I use. I think UGL sells a compound as well, and there are specialty compounds like Sarco that are generally only sold in very large containers to professional glaziers.

The thing with glazing compound is that you need to let it skin over before priming and painting it. If you glaze the window then let it sit outside, it'll take 3-4 weeks. What I do when reglazing a window in my old house is to remove all the glass, strip/sand the window to bare wood, prime the glass rabbets with OIL primer and the rest of the wood with LATEX primer, glaze the window, then put a coat of LATEX paint on the WOOD. Let the compound skin over outside then prime it with LATEX, apply a coat of LATEX paint to the glazing, then apply a second coat of LATEX paint to the WHOLE window to unify everything.

There's lots of good info over at the Old House Web website too. As you can imaging, glazing windows is pretty common for us old house owners. ;)

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#15

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: glazier's putty vs.  plumbing putty

Jack Guzman from Maine

Chris,

Is there any reason not to use latex primer for the rabbet behind the glass?Your post was a revelation to me. I had no idea there was an alternative to DAP. That's all I've ever seen. I'm going to visit my local sherwin williams and stock up.---Jack

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#16

I'm not Chris, but I have an idea

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The classic glazing compound (aka putty) is oil-based - so oil-based primer would provide a better bonding surface for an oil-based compound (in fact, if I recall correctly, it was considered OK to start puttying while the paint was still soft, not yet altogether cured).

I seem to recall one book I read years back recommending a good slather of boiled linseed oil on the glass rabbet, instead of primer, followed more or less immediately by puttying. I seem also to recall trying that once, and trying to keep putty in place when it was acting like a greased pig. On the other hand, my wife contends I remember things that never happened, so take those memories for what they're worth (about a ha'penny).

I've never used anything but traditional putty, so I don't know if the same issue exists with the newer glazing compounds.

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: I'm not Chris, but I have an idea

Jack Guzman from Maine

I knew all about that bonding part. All the old timers around here say to use linseed oil first but that was a different day. Different materials.What I want to know is if latex primer will work with the putties we have today. Chris sounds like he does alot of this. Noone around here putties windows anymore. They're all vinyl. I have become sort of a caretaker for alot of old homes in my area. I putty alot of windows. I have used BLO ,oil based primer and latex primer and haven't noticed a problem yet. They all seem to work fine.---Jack

Re: glazier's putty vs. plumbing putty

#18

Re: I'm not Chris, but I have an idea

ChrisF

Well, I haven't done exhaustive studies as to what works best, but I'll tell you what I know. :)

Some people like to apply a coat of BLO to a window they're reglazing instead of primer. The reasoning is that the old dry wood acts like a sponge, and if left untreated, will suck the oil out of the glazing compound. So, oil up the wood, then glaze. Problem is that mold and stuff like linseed oil too, and I've personally found that glazing doesn't last as long if you only apply BLO. The first few windows I reglazed ~8 years ago were done only with BLO, and take a wild guess what's sitting in my workshop, awaiting some reglazing this weekend.

I just use oil primer on the rabbet when reglazing to refresh the old wood a bit without feeding anything that might be living in it. It also helps the compound adhere to the wood. If you look at the instructions on the can, you'll also see that they recommend primer.

When I'm building new windows, I use an oil-modified latex primer made by my favorite paint company, Muralo (a regional brand here in the northeastern US). Sounds odd, but it's really good stuff.