New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

choosing sharpening stone grits

Posts

choosing sharpening stone grits

#1

choosing sharpening stone grits

les winter

I sharpen my plane irons and chisels with 800 and 1200 grit King stones, and finish off with an 8000 grit ceramic I got from Japan Woodworker. Is there a purpose to adding a stone between the 1200 and 8000?

Say a 2000 or a 4000?

thanks

Les

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

Moses Yoder

I was told that using a 4000 grit stone would save wear on the expensive 8000 grit stone and it turns out to be true. I use a 1000, 4000, and 8000 and honing really just requires a little bit of time on the 4000 to remove the 1000 scratches and then a final polish on the 8000 does not take long at all.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#3

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

David Weaver

There may be some merit to it, but what moses said is probably that merit.

For quite a while, I sharpened only with a shapton 1,000 and 15,000 (pros, I haven't found the glasstones to do well with stuff tougher than A2). It didn't take as long as you'd think to sharpen with that regimen as long as I didn't let the flats on a hollow grind get too thick. Actually, I think it took less time, mostly because the shaptons are aggressive and a lot more forgiving for skipping grits, and it prevents dealing with and lapping a third stone. The remedy for thick flats is quicker than sharpening them on several grits of stones, anyway, and I've never had great luck getting a good edge quickly with wide flats that I see some others take their hollow grinds to (to the point where the hollow has just about disappeared).

If you aren't the most enthusaistic of hobbyists, it's likely you won't wear out the 8k stone, anyway.

More merit may be there if you start sharpening exotic steels and it gets much more difficult to remove the last stone's scratches.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#4

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

ThomD

The exact numbers depend on the exact stones, but the jump from 1500 to 8000 is far too large. The more steps the better. I use 2 800 stones a 1500 a 6000 and an 8000 for many years, all King except the 1500. It speeds up your shapening a lot, not just wear. If you look at it through a microscope you would see it takes probably far longer than you are willing to take to work out the scratch pattern from the 1500 with an 8000. The blade may feel sharp because you have pointed up facets, but not gotten rid of the scratches.

But as mentioned the specifics will depend on your stones, and on your tools also. If you are sharpening cheese, the 8000 may make rapid progress, but with harder steel it could take a very long time, like hours.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#5

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

Dean J from MN

Les,

Let me ask something no one else did: Are you happy with your results today? Are your tools sharp enough to do the work you do? If so, there is no benefit to adding stones to your kit.

If not, it may help to add a step between your two stones. But, it may not, that all depends on your technique, perhaps you aren't getting your tools as sharp as you can on your existing stones? Is there an identifiable problem with your existing setup? Just takes too long to hone the final edge? Just not sharp enough (perhaps due to leaving old scratch patterns), etc.

For me, I have med. india and a hard arkansas, and am more than happy with my edges.

-Dean

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#6

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

les winter

Thanks Dean.

It seems I spend too much time on the microbevel, it gets too big to quickly. If I spend less time, then the edge isn't sharp enough. That is the problem that I want to solve.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#7

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

Steve Schoene

I'm confused. The way I was taught, the microbevel was worked only with the final grit anyway. I't purpose is only to strengthen the edge since you will already have honed the main bevel to "sharp" before raising the angle to create the microbevel.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#8

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

les winter

We agree. But because of the big jump from 1200 to 8000, it takes more passes to get the job done on the micro bevel. The bevel forms, but it takes a while to get it to sharp.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#9

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

Bob Hackett

I may be a little confused here but let me run thru this quickly;

You are using your finest grit stone and you have achieved the desired level of sharpness at this level.

You raise the angle in order to produce a micro-bevel to add strength to the edge.

You are having problems honing that micro bevel to the desired level of sharpness in a reasonable amount of time.

Is all that correct?

If it is then I would suggest the problem is in your technique.

I would examine the edge under magnification(I use a geologist`s field lens as it folds into it`s own case,thanks Bill) at the end of each phase of your procedure to see if the previous scratches have been completely removed and to also understand why once the edge is sharp at the primary bevel it`s taking so long to hone a micro-bevel.

If the primary bevel is sharp and honing the micro bevel is the bottleneck then backing up to an intermediate grit is counterproductive.

Regardless,the magnified view at the end of each step will tell you where to look for the solution.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#10

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

ThomD

With a microbevel, particularly a 1 degree tip up, you should be fine.

Re: choosing sharpening stone grits

#11

Moses is right

roninkokomo