New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Finally, justification for collecting

Posts

Finally, justification for collecting

#1

Moses Yoder

Finally, justification for collecting

Moses Yoder

I have just realized the best justification for owning a collection of tools that I have ever thought of. In the thread below, conversation was started about the horrendous things that people do with tools. This is the reason why we need a collection of tools. If we have thousands of tools when we die, this will attract serious collectors to the auction and they won't be the type of people who abuse tools. If we have only a few good tools, the auction will only attract the sort of men that grandpas talk about on the road alot, and the tools will end up in the hands of people who will use a damascus steel chisel to open their paint cans.

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#2

That's one hopeful senario, however,

Marv

Moses,

Lets hope that's what will happen. It will depend to a large extent on how the sale is advertised and who is managing the sale or auction.

Too often, some family member jumps in to help an elderly spouse who has little energy or ambition to organize what happens. The family member usually has no clue as to purpose or value when it comes to tools. They will have much more to do than just sell the tools. In most cases, they would much rather be doing something else and will hurry things along and get it done as fast as possible and sell valuable tools for pennies on the dollar.

I have a couple eBay seller friends who take advantage of estate sales because they know they can find great bargains, then turn a healthy profit on eBay. Both are mainly tool sellers.

There are services that will contract to handle the sale of collections of all kinds. They will manage auctions and or contact potential buyers who will pay closer to what the items are worth. I haven't done it, but I'm sure if one was to google it, various services advertise on the internet.

My wife looks at all the tools I have setting and hanging around and refers to me as a "tool whore". I justify my collections by saying, hey, better than whoring around in the bars. :D

Marv

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#3

My Thought

roninkokomo

I have really been out of the woodworking loop for several years due to some massive changes in my life. I will retire, Lord willing, in a couple of years and fully intend to immerse myself once again in this wonderful craft for fun and perhaps even some profit.

I have always thought that I would identify some young guy in the craft and give him a tool or two that I have accumulated that may be a little too salty for him to buy.

For the rest of the stuff, I intend to have the best area tool auctioneer handle it.

SWMBO would not have a clue and would probably sell the whole mess in a garage sale for $100.

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

I totally agree

Jack Guzman from Maine

That had never occured to me before. We should all make sure our loved ones don't have small change auctions to deal with. Of course that means that now I have to catalog everything so my heirs will know what I have left them.---Jack

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#5

No Justification Needed

David Miller from Iowa

Everyone has their thing, ours is old tools.

It isn't the "having" of the tools (once you have enough to do most stuff). The possession of the tools is just an interesting way to keep score and relive the exhilaration of the acquisition

It is the QUEST that keeps me going. It makes the trip to the auction or flea market exhilarating, it keeps me going to the declining antique stores and enjoying it. It makes that next auction or garage sale filled with wonder and excitement. It ads adrenaline to a dreary March day. In short, it makes me feel alive.

I find that I have been giving a lot of my best stuff, things I have had for years, to my kids (3 grown boys). They may not appreciate it for the mechanical triumph or rarity, but 50 years from now they will be saying "this belonged to my Dad and he cherished it".

I guess I am saying that collecting is its own reward.

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#6

He/she with the most tools wins!

Marv

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#7

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

BrianA from Monument

There is another good reason to catalog our tools; That is for insurance reasons.

Or as a list of what was there if there is a theft.

But the best one is to give the estate a good idea of what we thought our tools are worth when we cataloged them. This could keep family members from "giving them away".

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#8

I've found . . .

steve mackay

that more tools (Galoot tools, that is) make me smarter and better looking. And Lord knows I need the help.

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#9

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

ThomD

I still think serious collectors are to us, as the dancing Arnold is to Fred Astair. This isn't boasting, collectors probably hate us for using tools.

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#10

Thinner too.

Bob Hackett

All that rust chasing has to burn calories right? :)

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#11

Perfectly Expressed

Jay Samuels

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#12

Can't take it with you

James Watriss

Can't really control what happens to it when you go, either.

There's always the hope that my valued tools would survive in the hands of good friends, or get passed on to worthy others. But the truth is that they may get sold off piecemeal to other folks who may or may not like them as much as I do. And a modified Lie-Nielsen #4, even if it performs better than it did when I got it, will still typically sell for less, because it's in other than stock condition. It might get lucky. It might get melted down for the Bronze. Who knows.

Get what you can while the getting's good. :)

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#13

Re: Can't take it with you

steve mackay

Maybe, if we're good boys and girls, we ALL get issued Studley tool chests at the Pearly Gates. :D So we'll forget about the stuff we left behind.

But, I wonder, if we're BAD do we wind up in Ol' Norm's "RouterFest" work shop for eternity ? :(

" Bet-ter chaaaaaaaange your eve-vil ways . . . baby !"

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#14

Re: Can't take it with you

Ron in Sterling, CT

As Jim has said, "you can't take em with you". I have bought my tools/collections for ME. I have bought them for me to be happy with, and to use. Neither my son, or daughter, are interested in them, and that is fine with me. My son knows which few (my $10 605, & a couple of others) have some value, but other than those it will be a free for all when I head for the great workshop in the sky.

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#15

I Am

Todd Hughes

Few years ago I flew out west and got to thinking I might die in a plane crash so wrote up a detailed will.

...One part of it was what I wanted be dressed in when buried and what I wanted to take with me in my coffin which my friend Joe was supposed to build. Besides some guns and knives I had the list of a couple of my favorite tools. Plus I want to use my big 300 lb. Fisher anvil for my head stone. I looked down on it for many years as I worked over it so figure I can look up at it for a good many more..

Since then I have talked to a friend up in WV that has some property with caves about the possibilty of being interned in one. If so I can take alot more stuff with me !

Other then what I would like to be buried with I don't really care much about what happens to my stuff after I shuffle off. I sort of like an idea of a big auction though I wouldn't want strangers poking around my place. I sure wouldn't worry about the "Right" people getting tools or that things would sell to cheap etc.

Hopefully I will be in heaven buying more...I once asked my old friend and big time tool collector and accumulater Mr. R who was 95 and still buying rusty saws what he thought heaven would be like

Thought a bit and said ..." Auction prices will be a bit lower then you expect and the heavy stuff will always be close to your truck".....Todd

Re: Finally, justification for collecting

#16

Turning anthropology on it`s ear

Bob Hackett

I can imagine centuries from now some professor being brought to your newly opened cave/burial chamber and having a look around the place and going into a full blown seizure.

You would be the anthropological equivalent of the Piltdown Man.

Our man Todd still aggravating folks and raising hell while thumbing his nose at the established community minds long after he`s dead and gone.

Gotta love it!!! :D