New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

Posts

Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#1

Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I picked up a Millers-Falls No. 70 eggbeater drill today, although I wasn't sure what I had until I cleaned the rust off (also watched one of the local dealers score a rusty long plane, looked like a No. 7 Stanley, for about $15 - I was maybe three minutes behind him, doggone it).

It got me thinking. It's about 2" shorter than a No. 2, which was in production before and after the No. 70, and the throw on the crank is maybe 1" less; but it's really pretty close in size.

I looked on Randy Roeder's Millers-Falls site, and, dang! That company produced all kinds of drills of similar sizes, with similar features, concurrently. The same seems to be true of Goodell-Pratt, before their acquisition by M-F; and no doubt of other companies too.

I can see significantly different sizes of eggbeaters being useful. The M-F No. 2 and other drills of that size can be pretty awkward for small bits, while a small drill often lacks the leverage for, say, a 3/16" bit in hardwood. But why so many models so close in features? Was it the General Motors principle: dominate the market by turning out so many different makes and models that people can find one that just exactly fits their taste? Or is there some subtlety that I'm missing?

I'd noticed, but never thought about, the fact that the same seems to be true of braces; Stanley, M-F, et al produced a phenomenal number of braces with very small differences between them.


http://oldtoolheaven.com/hand_drills/drill.htm

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#2

Good question

Marv

Bill,

Thats a good question. When you think about it though, eggbeater and breast drills are no different than so many other tools. Hammers for example, or pliers, screwdrivers, wrenches, the list goes on and on. Theres a million different planes by many different makers. Handsaws is another example. Even table ware.

Anything that was or is that people perceive as something they need, will sell. Anything that will easily sell will become a competitive item and will attract all the various makers that make such items. During the late 1800, early 1900,s there were about 75 different handsaw makers in the northeastern states alone, plus a few on the west coast. Disston being the biggest fish at the time started gobbling up as many of the smaller fish as he could in an effort to cut down on the competition. All those companies made a tool that cut wood. Lots of subtle differences. Many of those differences were even patented. Seems that anything and everything was patentable in those days. And so it was with the eggbeater and breast drills.

However, with eggbeater and breast drills, the differences were not so subtle. I have some drills that have an enclosed gear box. The crank handle is removed and attached to the opposite side in order to change from one speed to a second speed. I even have one that was made in Russia thats about 18" long. I have one made by Stanely that I found on eBay that is new in it's original box. I call them "gear box" drills. They are all robust, very well made hand operated little machines.

Below is a picture of some of them. The one in the forefront is Millers Falls version. The tomatoes are from our garden. :) The silver and black one on the left is the Stanley. The smaller one just to the right of it was made in Germany. The Russian one was purchased after this picture was taken. I have a total of seven gear box drills.


Here's a closeup of the inside of a typical gear box. It's the major differences in design and the fact that so many of the larger drills were built like a tank that fasinates me with these old drills.


Take care,

Marv

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: stands

Moses Yoder

I think your drill stands would look better if you removed the labels from the wheels ;) Actually only 2 drills are necessary. Yankee made a drill, I think a 1026 and 1076, that has an adjustable transmission in it that can be adjusted so the drill turns clockwise whether the handle is turned forward or backward. If you have one of these in a small size and large size you have all the eggbeaters you need.

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#4

Re: stands

Marv

You are right about the labels. I was trying to be clever by using a grinding wheel for a stand and purposely left the labels on so it would be obvious that I used grinding wheels. The labels were originally well attached and was bothersome to remove, however, after several years, some of them are coming off on their own. At first I tried removing the labels and spray painting the wheels, but the wheels tend to soak up so much paint, I abandoned that idea. I thought John Deere green would be attractive. At the time I decided on the grinding wheels, I was attempting to come up with a stand that required a minimum of time, cost and effort. I bought them on eBay, 25 at a time really cheap. Like about $1.25 each. The bolt, nut and two fender washers cost me about half that.

I hope you don't think that I have all these drills because I think I need them. :) It's kind of a hobby thing. A friend of mine, well up in years, told me that people of our age shouldn't be collecting anything. I'm 72, going on 38, so it's pretty much of a moot point for me.

As for NEEDING only two drills if they have the type of transmission you described, I agree. Yankee did in fact make a drill with the constant forward rotation of the chuck when the crank is turned in either direction. I have a small Yankee eggbeater, one of my favorites, a No.1530 that has that type transmission. I'm not familiar with the two model numbers you mention. Some of their larger breast drills, their No.1555 has that kind of transmission. Millers Falls made breast drills like that also, the No.97 as one example. I'm not aware of an MF eggbeater of that kind.

Marv

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#5

scott grandstaff

Re: stands

scott grandstaff

Marv

The Yankee 1555 came in two distinct models too.

I accidentally have them both.

The first I got is the normal one. Sturdy enough, good transmission, nice drill.

But the second......... It's the same length and chuck but the entire drill weighs twice as much as the first one I got it. Its massive!

Has to weigh 8 or 10 pounds.

yours Scott

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#6

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces?

Patrick Gibbons

Bill, a look at the prices also explains a lot. Having similar sizes in economy, standard and premium models and then multiplying that by many sizes and the next thing you know you have a few drills. Throw in the Goodell Pratt drills that were retained and marked MF and you start having some overlap. Don't forget to give some multi speeds, others get bits included in the hollow handle and a host of other features to differentiate the drills. It was easy then to make product for different markets and also make so many that a retailer didn't need to buy other brands to be fully stocked. I would imagine that competitors, like Stanley, made drills just to have them and justify to a retailer why he didn't have to stock Millers Falls, or anyone else for that matter. Buying North Bros made a lot of sense if you wanted to gain instant market share and not have to prove a new product. Electric hand tools today are similar though not to the extent it use to be. A buyer today is more likely to buy way more tool than his use justifies. My father's generation tended to buy according to what they were willing to spend for a tool. Otherwise, how do you explain handyman-grade-tools?

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#7

Re: stands

Marv

Hi scott,

I have two 1555,s and one similar one with the model No.555AA. This one has a different mainframe.

Would love to see a picture of your bigger one.

Marv

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#8

scott grandstaff

Re: stands

scott grandstaff

Hey Marv

You were absolutely right. I cleaned up the heavy one enough to read, and it is marked simply marked 555 (no letters or anything).

The lighter weight one is a 1550.

The 555, heavy one, is available for parts (sniff).

That's why it wasn't cleaned up much.

Two of the pinion gears have bad broken teeth.

Otherwise its complete in not bad shape at all, and has a good strong transmission on the main shaft and the other one on the big gear wheel.

Or.............. I am looking for a 555 with some other defect besides the pinion gears on the main shaft??

Either way

yours Scott

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#9

Re: stands

Marv

Hi Scott,

My 555AA has a round shaft from the cast mainframe up to the breast plate, while the 1555 is all one casting.

My 555 is in perfect shape. Found it on eBay. I don't know what the "AA" on the end of the number signifies. Maybe it's the difference in frame design. Does yours have the round rod between the mainframe and the breast plate?

I don't have a 1550....I'll need to watch for one of those.

I'll keep an eye out for a 555 for you as I snoop around on eBay.

The shifting mechanism on these Yankees are interesting. Surprisingly small metal fingers or splines that slide into place determine what the crank does to the chuck. When those slim fingers wear out, the chuck begins to slip and not turn. A true test of the shifting mechanism is to put the maximum size drill in it and drill a hole in something. Just turning the crank might work just fine, but with a load, it might slip if worn too much.

The transmission on an MF-97 is much more substantially made, using cogs that slip in and out, but turning the shifting wheel is not always easy like the Yankees are.

Marv

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#10

scott grandstaff

Re: stands

scott grandstaff

Does yours have the round rod between the mainframe and the breast plate?

Nope, my 555 has a solid casting all the way up to the breastplate.

It is in an X or a cross shape.

The 1550 is a lightweight version without the shifter on the main bull gear.

Just a plain large gear. Surprisingly, it has a solid cast frame up to the breastplate too.

If you find a broken 555 that has good pinion gears, or get one that's really nice but needs parts, let me know.

yours Scott

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#11

Re: stands

Marv

I'll keep you in mind as I scroll the tools on eBay. I do it about once a week.

Marv

Re: Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*

#12

Just had a thought...

Marv

Scott,

Some of the different drills such as Yankees, used the same size pinion gears. If you can measure the diameter and thickness, I will check your measurements against the drills I have to determine if there is interchangeability. If there is, we have more options.

Marv