Why all the models of drills and braces? *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I picked up a Millers-Falls No. 70 eggbeater drill today, although I wasn't sure what I had until I cleaned the rust off (also watched one of the local dealers score a rusty long plane, looked like a No. 7 Stanley, for about $15 - I was maybe three minutes behind him, doggone it).
It got me thinking. It's about 2" shorter than a No. 2, which was in production before and after the No. 70, and the throw on the crank is maybe 1" less; but it's really pretty close in size.
I looked on Randy Roeder's Millers-Falls site, and, dang! That company produced all kinds of drills of similar sizes, with similar features, concurrently. The same seems to be true of Goodell-Pratt, before their acquisition by M-F; and no doubt of other companies too.
I can see significantly different sizes of eggbeaters being useful. The M-F No. 2 and other drills of that size can be pretty awkward for small bits, while a small drill often lacks the leverage for, say, a 3/16" bit in hardwood. But why so many models so close in features? Was it the General Motors principle: dominate the market by turning out so many different makes and models that people can find one that just exactly fits their taste? Or is there some subtlety that I'm missing?
I'd noticed, but never thought about, the fact that the same seems to be true of braces; Stanley, M-F, et al produced a phenomenal number of braces with very small differences between them.
http://oldtoolheaven.com/hand_drills/drill.htm
The silver and black one on the left is the Stanley. The smaller one just to the right of it was made in Germany. The Russian one was purchased after this picture was taken. I have a total of seven gear box drills.

Actually only 2 drills are necessary. Yankee made a drill, I think a 1026 and 1076, that has an adjustable transmission in it that can be adjusted so the drill turns clockwise whether the handle is turned forward or backward. If you have one of these in a small size and large size you have all the eggbeaters you need.


