Low tech heat treating - for discussion
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
OK, I would like some comments on the most low tech method I know of heat treating a blade. Let's call this a learning experience and I will takes the lumps and criticism.
Low tech in that it requires the least amount of time and equipment. The big advantage is that it can be done in about 10 minutes.
Here is the situation ...
I made a chisel yesterday for a woodworking friend. The basis of the chisel was the blade out of a black, plastic handled Stanley I have had for 10 or more years. The steel is reasonable, but on the too soft side to hold an edge for long, and the black handle is just plain Horrible.
I wanted to turn this into a nice looking chisel that could be used for paring dovetails. First thing I did was to wack off the handle (easily done with a hammer), and then ground the shoulder of the blade until they were narrow (there is a pictorial on my website). This was the result. You can see the interesting tang ...

Incidentally, the Marples/Irwin blue handle chisels look the same.
The heat treating was done with two butane torches (if I was working with a large blade I would work with the blade on a brick to increase heat) ...

Alongside is a tin of peanut oil for part-quenching. Why "part-quenching"? Because I have no idea what the steel is. I suspect it is a O1 type rather than a W1 type. So I plan to quench in oil (which can be too slow for W1) and then re-quench in water. I have done this before successfully - any comments?
I do not heat the steel to cherry with the lights on. It is difficult to judge colour in the light, so the lights go off and I am left with a gloom.

I did not think to take a picture of the cherry (partly because it was difficult, but mainly because I only thought of pictures after this stage!). So just imagine cherry red for the first 2" of the blade. Then dunked in peanut oil until still warm, and then under cool water.
A file slides off the steel (i.e. the steel is harder than the file), so I consider it ready for the next stage.
First I clean off the blackened steel with fine sandpaper, getting back to a bright surface (all the better to see the colours in the next stage). So it is time for tempering.
Back to the torch - this is what I meant by low tech. I start about 2" back, get the steel hot and watch the colour changing as it moves along the blade towards the bevel end. As it get the palest of yellow I immediately quench it in the oil and again the water.
Here is a picture. The flash has made the yellow a little whiter than it actually was, but the steel was a faint yellow ("straw") at the tip.

The blade is now cleaned, lapped on 400 grit diamond stone, 1000/5000/12000 Shaptons - however I must point out that only the last 1" behind the bevel was lapped to 12000.

The final chilsel looks like so ..


The proof of the pudding lies in the eating. Paring endgrain Radiata Pine (Truly Horrible Stuff). Blade needs to be sharp for this ...

It held up well in very hard wood as well. This is Wandoo endgrain - one of the hardest woods in the world.

Open for discussion ..
Regards from Perth
Derek





