New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT - Bath surround

Posts

OT - Bath surround

#1

OT - Bath surround

ThomD

I am doing a new bath surround for the parents' cottage. The old one was some stuff called Barkertile. A vinyl paper backed material that got soggy. Ripped that out and some soggy drywall, and installed a wall that is needed for the new surround. The new surround is a MAXX acrylic product. I am at a stage where I could buttom up the waterproof drywall, or keep ripping it out and replace all of it. The leftovers are pretty good condition, the only problem being some kind of mastic used to hold the "tile" on. This stuff seems hard, and as if the PL premium would bond to it. It will really make a huge mess to tear out more drywall since what remains is all tied into more labour intensive stuff, like corners. So what is the betting as to whether I can get away with not renewing the drywall? I probably wouldn't tile over old mastic, but PL premium sticks to just about anything...

Other question is that the first paragraph of the install instruction is to not install the material where temps might fall below freezing. The sentence is ambigious as to whether this is about install temp or whether the product itself should not to be used in a place that will get cold. The sentence just before says to install it at 60F, which is kinda odd, but plays to the idea the stuff may expand/contract in bad ways. Anyone deal with this before. I will probably have to call the company on this one.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#2

As a general principle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have learned not to do it halfway in high-stress environments like bathrooms.

I would also never, anymore, back much of anything around a bath with waterproof drywall - it's got very little strength. Tile backerboard is stiffer. If the plastic surround you're putting up is stiff in itself, this may not be an issue, but if it's got any flex to it, a stiffer backboard would work better.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#3

Temp probably application related...

John in NM

Seems like that's a common instruction with a lot of tube adhesives, probably has to do with drying time and getting the right viscosity. But good to call and double check.

The trouble I've seen with cement boards (to wander OT a bit) is that they transmit moisture to the studs, encouraging dry rot. May have been a bad installation, but I ended up having to rebuild a lot of walls where they were used. Personally, the best substrate I've seen is plain old plaster and lath. Gypsum plastered walls actually breath pretty well, so if any moisture gets through the grout it doesn't stay trapped in the wall. Last shower I built, I put up OSB (other reasons for that), then 30# felt, then green board. If you go to an actual drywall supplier, or better yet a manufacturer, there's also blue board which is supposedly ok for limited exterior use. Anyhow, then tiled over the green board. I figure I'd rather re-tile in 20 years than have to rebuild walls :D

Re: OT - Bath surround

#4

Re: Temp probably application related...

ThomD

Turns out to be accademic since apparently you can't use this plastic system in places that may become unheated. Like all of Canada... :)

Not sure what the replacement is going to be, but probably tile over concrete backer board. So the next question is what is the correct way to install concrete backer board. I am thinking about what kind of compond, I am thinking durabond90 setting compound. The guy at HD said all purpose which is high performance water soluble, :) so I am not going to do that. Or does it need cement. The other thing is how does it go over the flange. I am thinking there should be some kind of "flashing" think I saw that once. A membrane from the flange up a bit to stop water transfer to the studs when the caulking fails.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#5

The one I ripped apart...

John in NM

Had silicone and screws holding the backer board to what was left of the studs, that's what I'd use if I wanted adhesive as it was stuck good to what was left after 20 years. I believe most installers do use some kind of adhesive, though I'd say a moisture barrier is more important. There is undoubtedly something in the IRC about it if that applies up in Canada.

For the deck seal, you get 5' wide thick PVC material, its this flexible grey membrane that they sell on a roll at HD or sometimes pre-cut 3'x5' I think. You put down a thick layer of deck mud (very dry mortar with no lime in it) and slope it. The bottom half of your flange goes in at this point. Then put down the membrane and lap it up the walls a foot or so (there's glue for it if you need to do a lap joint to get enough width). The membrane laps over the bottom half of the flange, and the top half is threaded in and pinches the membrane. I think you tile right over the membrane, but you may put another 1/2" thick layer of deck mud over it, can't remember now. When I did mine I gleaned all I needed to know from an archive search at the John Bridge tile forum, its one of those questions that's been asked often.

Good luck with the project :D

Re: OT - Bath surround

#6

Re: Temp probably application related...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Fine Homebuilding's authors always suggest covering cement board joints with thinset.

As John says, there are various membranes you can buy. There's also a paint-on membrane, the name of which I now forget, that our tilesetter used when he did the shower on our bath remodel this last Fall.

What you can find in your local stores - don't know. So many of these products seem not to cross national borders from one country to the next.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#7

Re: Temp probably application related...

ThomD

Thanks for all the ideas! Is that kind of membrane for a shower pan? I'm just transitioning the wall to the lip of the tub. I know from tearing stuff out that it gets wet and moldy there, and I seem to remember the guys on TOH doing something relatively massive in the way of membranes etc... It just seems crazy that anything like drywall should ever get near to a bathtub. :)

I'm pretty much going for the tile. 33 bucks rather than 300 for the thing I am returning. The MAXX kit looks easy, but it virtually turns the bathroom into a tear-out job to get the walls around the bath where they need to be. That said, anyone know a solid institutional way to do this. Problem with cottages is that I am supposed to be having fun, and I do like reno, but it blows up one summer in every 20 tearing out the bath, and there are other things for the other 19 summers. Something one could plaster over the cement board, solid plastics,... ? I would do it boat style in plywood and glassfiber.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#8

If you're going to do tile, *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

one huge lesson I got from the tilesetter was that the tile WILL leak, regardless of how well you do the grout, seal the grout, etc.

And that your membrane is thus critical, because it's what actually keeps the water out.

You're correct that what you want is a membrane that will lead to the tub lip, so that water can drain back to the tub.

Schluter makes a membrane that the place we got our tile from (and that I wish we'd used to install the tile) swears by. You might check that out.


http://www.schluter.com/

Re: OT - Bath surround

#9

Re: If you're going to do tile,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That orange stuff looks like the membrane that Mike Holmes uses on every tile project.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#10

Re: If you're going to do tile,

ThomD

It is, really adds to the cost, which is tough in this case since my parents have been predicting their iminent demise for about 30 years. Of course the odds are with them. I guess the Dietra is a good thing, but it kinda bugs me. An uncoupling membrane. I don't so much see the point in hanging tile on a curtail. If attaching tile to something solid is a bad idea, maybe we need a somewhat more complete rething. :)

So far the funnest sounding project is from some green site , where a lady skim coated in mortar, waited for it to crack, then filled the cracks with coloured grout. Had a marble effect and she won a prize.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#11

Solid surface

Bob Hackett

I redid the bath for my mother and went from a tub to a large walk in shower with a bench for her to sit on.

I went with a base and wall system we ordered from Lowe`s,Dura-stone or something similar.It was stone dust in resin and could be cut rather easily by carbide tipped WWing power tools.

The solid surface product can be bonded directly to the studs but I cut back the studs to accept 1/2" exterior ply and left a gap between the ply and the shower base.I then put ice and water shield on over the flange and onto the studs/ply to seal the gap and make the connection from base flange to wall.I did the same thing up the 2 corners for about 6" on either side.

I used silicone to glue the walls up and braced them with 2Xs and wedges onto stiff backs till the silicone had set then caulked the base and corners and install the cap and was done.

The material was slightly less than 1/4" thick and handled like ply(it will bend/flex some) except it was much heavier in weight.Each wall went up as a solid piece and caulked around the edges.It has a satin finish that still looks good after 5 years of scrubbing with abrasive cleaners(hard water w/lots of iron).It`s guaranteed for life,whatever that means.

The contractor who measured and installed the glass door/shower wall said it made his part of the job a real pleasure as it required no special tools or adhesives.The fact that I took my time and squared and plumbed everything from the framing on out made things easier for both of us too.

Re: OT - Bath surround

#12

Re: If you're going to do tile,

John in NM

"An uncoupling membrane. I don't so much see the point in hanging tile on a curtain"

exactly. now putting the moisture barrier under the backer makes sense, as the backer is screwed to the studs and completely waterproof - as in un-damaged by water. I sometimes wonder what the various building industries are thinking... Well, showers and tub surrounds are difficult to know what will last, no matter how you cut it.

Thom, the membrane I was referring to earlier is a pan liner, I got a little confused as to what you're up to. Strips of it cemented together would work for the transition you're talking about though. Not sure how one would prevent seeping under the flange though.

Neat idea for the faux marble, but why did it crack I wonder? I didn't think most mortars would crack much if applied as a plaster. You could do the same with lime plaster (now that stuff cracks!) and stucco tinting.