New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT--Plumbing question

Posts

OT--Plumbing question

#1

OT--Plumbing question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

I have a simple plumbing repair to make. Looks simple. But the plumbing is several decades old, and so there is always a chance to break something, and turn a simple repair into a big mess.

I need to replace the water supply valve to a toilet. The plumbing is all 1/2" nominal (1/2" ID galvanized). There is a nipple vertically up through the floor a few inches, then a female/male elbow, then an angle-stop valve screwed onto the male side of the elbow. It's that angle stop I need to replace.

It's a simple job in concept: Depressurize, dewater, unscrew the existing valve, and screw on the new one. But. Maybe that 70-year old valve is frozen on--who knows? The innards of it have already failed. I will get a wrench on the hub of the angle stop, and a second wrench (vise grip or big channellock) on the short shank of the elbow to counter the torque of unscrewing the valve. Is there any other precaution I should take to loosen up that joint before putting the muscle on that valve? Would heat help loosen things up? I really don't want to crack that elbow fitting trying to unscrew the valve.

All suggestions most appreciated!!

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#2

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Kem

Wiley, is repairing the valve out of the question? That would be my first choice. Sounds like you have the right plan for replacing it; I would use a large wrench on the valve and a pipe wrench on the pipe. Heat applied carefully to the valve only would certainly help to loosen things up, but usually they come off without having to do that. Maybe have some extra fittings on hand (like the elbow and some pipe) in case you damage the pipes getting the valve off...might save a trip to the hardware store.

Kemil

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Jesper, Denmark

You have the right plan. �" galvanized is pretty sturdy, and as there must be some sealant between the valve and the elbow, it should come off OK, unless it wa some Gorilla that tightened it in the first place.

The worst potential for trouble seems to be if the valve is corrodet and breaks - but then you can replace the elbow.

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#4

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You don't mention which way the elbow turns. What tools you use will depend somewhat on that.

If it turns right (looking at the angle stop, it's to the right of the vertical pipe), you can't get a pipe wrench on it properly, because the pipe wrench would have to be in the wall. In that case, I'd recommend either a crescent wrench or, if you have them and they'll fit, your largest (12" or up) channellock type pliers; or big vise grips, applied carefully.

If it turns out or left, and if you can fit a pipe wrench on the elbow, I'd recommend that.

Even old pipe was usually assembled with pipe dope, which, besides preventing leaks, serves to reduce the chance that the two sections will have rusted together; but old joints will be very reluctant to turn at first.

The problem, from what you describe, is less the elbow you can see than the next joint back - you need to keep the pipe from moving side to side and up and down at least as much as you need to keep the elbow from moving.

Get a ball-type (also known as a "quarter-turn") angle stop. You'll never need to rebuild it, and, when you have to work on the toilet, you can be confident that the water will be OFF when you turn it off.

Bill, far more knowledgeable about old house plumbing than I ever, ever wanted to be

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#5

Re: OT--Plumbing question

steve mackay

I KNOW I'm being stupid and I'm REALLY not trying to imply you are BUT . . . for goodness sake PLEASE make sure the fitting IS indeed threaded and the excisting plumbing is beefy enough to handle the torque (including the plumbing you can't see inside walls & floors). In my early days of home ownership I ASSUMED both of the above. I was wrong more than a couple times.

Heres wishing you a "two-tripper" !

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#6

Re: OT--Plumbing question

R Payne

I don't have anything to add to the plumbing discussion. However you mentioned galvanized pipe and the potential for heating. If you do heat the galvanized pipe be careful. If you start burning the galvanization off, the fumes are toxic. (Zinc is a heavy metal and breathing the fumes can lead to heavy metal fever.)

ron

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#7

By the way

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In my experience, cracking of galvanized plumbing elbows in the situation you describe isn't common. The angle stop is usually weaker than the elbow, and connectors - elbows, couplings, etc. - seem usually to be heftier than the pipe itself; which makes sense, when you think about the strains they're under.

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#8

Re: By the way

ThomD

Ah, this brings back memories of a similar copper repair I did. Horrible corner, no room to solder, the supply pipe ran over the top of the fuse box. Eventually I just ripped it back to a safe distance and rebuilt it with PEX.

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#9

ah, yes: the "what were they THINKING?" cases

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've never quite seen that one, but I've seen other "solutions" that leave me wondering what brilliant idea was going through the previous owner/builder/mechanic's mind at the time s/he did it.

And also reminding myself that Darwinian evolution works on statistics, not individual cases - people can do things that stupid and still survive long enough to have children.

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#10

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Kem,

I'd like to rebuild the valve also, cause it's got a great old spoked knob on it, and you can't even get a modern look-alike shipped to California. However, I have to depressurize everything in the house to work on this valve, so want to get in and out ASAP.

Great idea about having the 'just in case' fittings right on hand to avoid those back-to-the-hardware trips that Steve was talking about. I'll have an elbow on hand for sure.

Thanks!

Wiley

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#11

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Jesper. I think you're right--that elbow looks very stout. And our water supply is more alkaline than corrosive, so I doubt it's hollowed out. As mentioned above, I'll make sure I have a new elbow 'just in case'.

Wiley

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#12

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill, you're very perceptive as usual! I don't think I can get a big pipe wrench over top of the elbow. My plan at this point is to get big channelocks onto the spout of the elbow, right next to the big crescent wrench on the valve. [Am reminded of the general (which one was it?) who said that all those beautiful plans go out the window as soon as the first shot is fired.] My thought is to go slow, start with the two wrenches about an inch separated, and then pull them together, so that the torque stays balanced. This should also keep from bending that nipple coming up through the floor--if I break that thing, it's all over.

Indeed, I did get a quarter turn replacement valve. After I found out that the really nice vintage-looking ones with the spoked-wheel stems couldn't be shipped to California.

Wiley

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#13

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

Words of experience, for sure! Am trying to avoid that second trip this time, but I've made three trips before whilst yelling over my shoulder trying to explain to a steely eyed wife why I need to go back again.

I hear ya about 'what's behind the wall and under the floor'. I guess I would summarize my plumbing experience as follows: The riskiest tool in the toolbox is one pipe wrench.

Wiley

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#14

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Ron, that's very helpful about the galvanized giving off fumes. Didn't know that.

Wiley

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#15

Re: OT--Plumbing question

Jerry Nicholson

Have you seen the Cosby episode where Cliff decides to fix a tile that has come loose in the shower? Then he finds a leak. Then more tile come off. Then he breaks into the wall. etc etc etc

Not suggesting that will happen to you, of course. :D

Jerry

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#16

Mushroom factor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

not for what you find when you open the wall (though that can be part of it), but for the tendency of small repairs to mushroom into major projects.

Actually, with some of the stuff I've run into on This Auld Haus, it feels more like a mushroom cloud.

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#17

So right, so right !

steve mackay

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#18

Bathroom Remodel (Long)

Jerry Nicholson

About 25-26 years ago, my wife complained about the wallpaper peeling in the main bath. I, of course, ignored her. Then she complained about the cheap plastic tiles falling off the wall around the tub. A little silicone fixed that. Then one day she says "why is the bathroom floor bulged up in front of the door. Oops! Found out floor is wet under the tile. Found out water has been trapped in shower track and gone into the wall (remember, loose tile?) and from there into the floor. OK - now time for some work. Finish on cast iron tub has worn through so I decide to do a minimal remodel, with a replacement tub. Budgeted $1000. Turns out my old tub was 32 inches wide and 16 inches high, requiring a special order from Kohler ($600). Got new tub, pulled out old one, and found that the floor and the sub floor were both damaged. Had to send wife and son across town in the truck to get more plywood (late in the evening, before the days of a home center on every corner). Had to cut off bottom of walls at ends of tub so I could rip up the floor and subfloor. Nailed in new plywood. Put new tub in place. Then I decided it would look better to tear out the end walls entirely, eliminating shower so wife and daughters wouldn't plug up the drain holes in the shower door track because they never cleaned out the tracks after then washed their hair. New tub made old BR sink and toilet look out of date so I bought new ones from Kohler to match tub. Found that new Kohler sink would only work with Kohler ($$$) faucet set. Old Formica counter top wouldn't do of course so I bought a big piece of Corian (24 x 120 inches). Needed all new bigger mirrors to take full advantage of new fixtures and Corian. Paper and plastic tile no longer looked good on walls so I needed new (real ceramic) tile. And new floor covering, of course. A year later my $1000 project was done and I quit counting at $6000. Oh yeah - I had to refinish the ceiling after I tore out the tub end walls. It looked really good after it was all done and the guy I sold the house to 10 years ago was properly impressed. But talk about mushrooming!!!!!

Jerry

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#19

Jesper, Denmark

So, Wiley, did ya fix it????

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#20

Still circling.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Re: OT--Plumbing question

#21

scott grandstaff

Re: OT--Plumbing question

scott grandstaff

Plumbing is like cabinetmaking, ........ More tools!

People don't make tools because they are stupid. There is always a reason a tool is made.

Straight and angle pipe wrenches in all the sizes, faucet wrench and drain wrench (can't remember the name offhand, but its a crescent that starts at 1 1/4 and opens to 2 1/2"), strap wrenches in at least 3 sizes. Crescents, visegrips, seat dressers, seat wrench................washers galore, packing in several sizes and types..........

and a metal lathe and mill in reserve comes in handy too. heh

Oh one major tip hardly anyone else is going to tell you.

Seat wrenches come in stepped square/hex at each end to correspond with the seats. They also sell one that looks odd with a tapering oval at each end.

The stepped hex and square wrench seems obvious as they actually fit the holes in the seats? And the oval seems to fit nothing??

Get the funny looking oval, trust me.

Or don't trust me and get the stepped, but get the oval too, just in case.

You'll find out.

Personally I hate replacing if I can possibly repair. You can open most valves, dress or replace the seat, put on a new washer (which you sometimes have to fit) and repack the bonnet nut lots faster and with less risk than replacing.

Old plumbing doesn't like to come apart easy. You can innocently start in the bathroom and end digging up the street!

Old time hardware stores sell valve seats for 32 cents and dozens of sizes/kinds of washers. Box stores sell nothing but faucets because the profit margin is enormous. They don't care how much grief they are selling.

The real secret to plumbing is Neverseize. Always use neverseize anywhere you can. Then, the next time its all so easy.

The first time I rebuilt my tub/shower faucet..... I could have broken out walls and pipes and not had water for a week replacing it.

Instead I rebuilt and it took me a full day of high risk stress breaking everything down!

Last time? It was 20 minutes all in, start to finish. It was just a joy.

Every locknut, every setscrew, bonnet nut threads, everywhere but pipe threads.............. Neverseize!!!!

Available at every auto parts store if the hardware doesn't stock it.

yours Scott