New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Squaring chisels

Posts

Squaring chisels

#1

Squaring chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

These have to be the easiest chisels to make. Everyone should have a couple.

I was at the Perth Wood Show all day yesterday on Chris Vesper's stand. We had a lot of fun competing with each other cutting dovetails, trying to produce something fancy for all who passed by. The fanciest we managed were Houndstooth dovetails (off the saw). Chris is better than I am - faster - and so he should be as a professional tool maker. He is good. Hopefully I should have some photos to upload when he sends me copies (he had the camera).

After a day of this I was wandering around some of the stands, and picked up a couple of cheap Chinese HSS short blanks that I thought would make great chisels. One was 1/4" wide and 5/16" deep, and the other was 5/16"wide x 5/16" deep. I imagine that these are easily available to most. The two lengths of HSS must have cost about $10 together.

I was thinking about some recent posts about someone who wanted a corner chisels, and how I had written that I considered them an absolute waste of money. The chisels I have made are what I would use in place of a corner chisel. They are for squaring the end of a mortice (such as one made by a power router of just paring the end of a mortice from a mortice chisel) or the stopped end of a groove.

While this can be done by a multitude of chisels - and indeed I have tended to use a oval bolstered mortice chisel - what is ideally needed is a chisel with parallel sides and deep enough to register with the sides of the groove. My mortice chisels have tapered sides, and my paring chisels are too thin to register in the way I described.

The chisels both took under 1 hour to make.

Here is a length of 1/4" HSS ...


Grind the end into a round tenon freehand on the high speed grinder (an advantage of HSS is that you cannot damage the temper with the heat generated, so go mad!). Turn a handle and drill it out for the tenon. Add a brass ferrule to the mix.


Stirr together, lap the blades on Shaptons (the Pros work well), hollow grind a 30 degree bevel, hone to 1 micron, and ...

Two squaring chisels, one 1/4" and the other 5/16". Both with Sheoak handles (tough as old boots). Blades are 2 3/4" long. Short for control (deep is not needed).




Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Squaring chisels

#2

Re: Squaring chisels

Patrick Gibbons

Those blanks are used for metal lathes and are readily available. Look in the MSC or Grizzly catalogs. I use them with my Sherline lathe.

Re: Squaring chisels

#3

Re: Squaring chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Patrick

That is the point I wanted to make. These HSS sections are intended for lathe chisels. The parts for these chisels are easily available (Chinese HSS is excellent for this purpose, and the ferrules came from the plumbing section of my local Borg), and require minimum preparation (other than turning a handle) to create an excellent tool. So far they exceed my expectations, both in their comfort and edge holding. This HSS gets really sharp and holds it very well after being pounded through some very hard wood. They actually make pretty decent mortice chisels as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Squaring chisels

#4

Gotta admit, Derek,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that I haven't considered using those very basic tools to make other tools that more suit my needs. It is surely easier than starting from scratch.

Thanks for the inspiration.

Re: Squaring chisels

#5

David Barnett

Good tip, Derek *LINK*

David Barnett

The most useful sizes, say, 3/16", 1/4" and 5/16" also come as extra-long 6" square bits that make really useful medium-length chisels. It's M2, so just grind a bevel, hone and stick a handle on it. And, like you said, they're cheap.


5/16" x 6" M2 Extra Long Square Tool Bit

Re: Squaring chisels

#6

Re: Good tip, Derek

ThomD

I made a small Osage rebate plane with one of those. So far haven't had to sharpen it!

Also, being HSS you can silver braze an extention to it, and make any length you want. The HSS doesn't care about 800-1200 degrees F.

Re: Squaring chisels

#7

Ellis Walentine

Question on handle interface

Ellis Walentine

Nice looking chisels, Derek. When I saw how you ground the round tang, I noticed that the shoulder is a taper to the rectangular section of the chisel shank. I'm trying to figure out how the pounding forces are transmitted from the shank to the handle with this arrangement. I imagine the tapered transition simply wedges the wood tightly against the ferrule, and that's okay, but I wonder if it is the ideal way to transmit pounding from the handle to the blade. Should the tang bottom out in the handle? Would a square shoulder provide a more direct transmission of pounding force?

I'm trying to compare your configuration to various styles of tang- or socket chisels that I've owned over the years.

Ellis

Re: Squaring chisels

#8

Re: Question on handle interface

Bob Hackett

I would think it would be of benefit to drop a heavy washer over the round tang to absorb some of that pounding and act as a forger collar would act on a oval handled traditional mortice chisel.

As Thom mentioned,brazing does not seriously effect HSS,so brazing the washer to the shaft would be even better.

Re: Squaring chisels

#9

Re: Question on handle interface

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

The hole is drilled so that the bottom of the mortice is against the rear of the steel shaft. Impact is against the rear of the shaft and not the shoulder of the blade. To make this happen more precisely, use epoxy as a gap filler. I certainly would not use this method without a ferrule!

No doubt one could increase the ability of the handle to withstand impact by squaring off the shoulders as well. Although this design actually makes a decent mortice chisel (I have chopped a few in hard Jarrah with both chisels), it was designed really as a tool to square off the ends of mortices or grooves, so has a fraction of the work to do that a true mortice chisel is called on to do.

Good question. (And my logic may not be as good).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Squaring chisels

#10

Leo Cuellar

Re: Squaring chisels

Leo Cuellar

Great idea, Derek. Thanks for posting!

Re: Squaring chisels

#11

Re: Question on handle interface

ThomD

A hole with a lot of epoxy will transition anything, problem on projects this size is making it look good, sometimes. If one is plunge cutting the shoulder on a grinder, it can be made to come out square, very beginner thing for knife grinders.

Re: Squaring chisels

#12

Ellis Walentine

Another question RE: Epoxy

Ellis Walentine

I've used a lot of epoxy in my day, and it is great for adhesion and gap filling, but I've never thought of it as appropriate for transmitting forces. Even fully cured, epoxy is softer than dense hardwood and certainly softer than steel, so when it gets in the middle of a pounding instrument like this chisel, it would seem subject to compression and somewhat impaired transmission of forces. I guess my question comes down to the importance of a solid and direct interface between wood and steel, so that mallet strikes are transmitted with full benefit of whatever restitution coefficients the wood and steel and mallet may have in combination and absent the cushioning of an epoxy buffer.

Inquiring minds...

Ellis

Re: Squaring chisels

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Good Question......

Jesper, Denmark

Intuitively, one would expect that the tranmission of the rapid rise impact of the hammer or mallet is better transferred to the tool steel in a handle filled with something that completely fills any voids between steel and hole.

Now, is the epoxy a non-compressible fuid at this point? Or a plastic which can be compressed? I suspect a bit of both, particularly when the epoxy is thickened with high density fillers. As it is fully confined wiuthin the handle, it probably does not compress much and the hysteresis (delay in transmission of force) should be quite low compared to the wood.

as the steel is probably bottoming out in the hole, there is not much epoxy between it and the wood of the handle, so the stabilization of the steel in the handle is of more importance than the flexibility of the epoxy.

The question is academic. if the steel went all the way through the handle and is struck by a steel hammer, the rate of rise in force is much faster than a wooden handle struck with a wooden mallet. Yet, we all use wooden mallets to strike chisels with and it seems t work OK, right?

A high peak force in a short time is important for some things. It is easy to get a taper to release with a quick tap of a steel hammer, but u can pound on it with a mallet and get nowhere. The total force transmitted should be about the same if the hammer and mallets weigh the same. Does it matter in chisseling? In some ways it must, as pushing the chisel by hand does not work as well as hitting it with a mallet.

Re: Squaring chisels

#14

Re: Another question RE: Epoxy

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

In the actual situation here, the steel tenon should bottom out on the wooden mortice. The epoxy is squeezed along the sides of the mortice, not at the bottom. Consequently we should be talking abour the shear forces rather than compression alone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Squaring chisels

#15

Re: Another question RE: Epoxy

ThomD

Jesper pretty much has it right. One thing I would add is to be careful about the meaning of some of this stuff. What does it mean when we say that the metal should be in contact with the wood at the bottom? How much of it and how. It is far from easy to guarantee a quality fit between wood and steel. So is a tiny point of contact on one edge of the tang better than perfect contact over the whole area of the base of the tang via epoxy. Another related point is that a large epoxy region can pass the loads between the steel and a much larger area in the wood. The dissimilar properties of wood and steel can be aligned by simple spreading the point loads that steel can transmit to a much larger area in the wood. This is probably more significant in the case of loads into sidegrain where there is greater area to exploit, and the wood is less strong. But it would apply in the case where something like a 1/2"x1/4" tang was inserted into a 1/2" hole filled with epoxy.

I like sockets best in chisels, but tangs are much easier for produce, and solid joints can offset any advantage to sockets.