New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT... Smart meters

Posts

OT... Smart meters

#1

OT... Smart meters

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

PG&E (local power and gas supplier) is going to start installing these so called smart meters for power and gas in our area starting soon.

I heard some bad things about these and some cities in the bay area are putting a ban on installing them.

Does anybody have these installed? Have you noticed any differences in your bills?

Re: OT... Smart meters

#2

Re: OT... Smart meters

glh17

I'd like to know more about this also. I've read a little about smart meters and they seem to be a good idea. As I understand it, a smart meter is simply an indoors monitor of electricity use. The idea is if the homeowner is aware of how much is being used, the owner will economize in the same way some drivers who have those miles per gallon monitors do. Of course not everyone would be influenced by the monitor. Personally, I see some advantages to the things, but I can't form an opinion till I know more about accuracy and costs.

Are there other concerns?

Re: OT... Smart meters

#3

Re: OT... Smart meters

BilWil

We had a smart meter in our previous house. It told us when the price of electricity was high, low, or standard. We would use that info to decide when we would do high use activities that could be timed, ie wash, dishes, etc. We experienced lower electric bills.

Re: OT... Smart meters

#4

Re: OT... Smart meters

glh17

BilWil,

Did the meter indicate your current consumption of power? Ideally, I would like an estimate of what my electric bill would be at my current consumption level. That would involve knowing my current consumption and the price of the power. I might be able to rearrange my usage in a way that reduces my bill. At least, I'd know what it is costing me.

Re: OT... Smart meters

#5

Re: OT... Smart meters

Phil Joines

From what I've read the electric companies are using them so they can charge more for peak usage times.

Re: OT... Smart meters

#6

Re: OT... Smart meters

BilWil

No, it did not.

Re: OT... Smart meters

#7

Re: OT... Smart meters

ThomD

It is probably a good idea. I do have several concerns. One is anything digital is a privacy and fraud concern. With a mechanical meter it is sorta chugging along, nobody can game the system at a central location. Like electronic voting machines, someone could tamper with it. There is also the Goldman factor, the moment these people get some more numbers to play with there is bound to be some screwing going on.

Also, at the retro grouch level, while making a market decision out of everything means more efficient markets, that isn't the only human value. We get to spend our time calculating when we should use our lights. My mother, on the other hand, among her many achievements, has a near photographic memory for literature. So what you wire your mind to do shouldn't necessarily be left up to the electrical utility. Maybe we should spend less time worrying about when to turn the lights on and more time reading, etc...

Re: OT... Smart meters

#8

Yes, that's the point

Neal in San Jose

It doesn't cost the same to generate all electricity. The power company uses it's cheapest source first, then progresses up to more expensive sources as the demand increases. Thus, it makes sense for them to be able to charge based on their actual cost structure rather than just average or worst case costs, which is what it has been up till now. That's what essentially all successful businesses do - charge based on actual costs. Theoretically, it will be less expensive for the average user since we are usually away from home during the peak hours - usually early thru late afternoon. It also makes it possible to defer some tasks based on time of day as others have mentioned like running the dishwasher after dinner instead of after lunch and programming thermostats to let the A/C coast in the afternoon.

However, having said all that, here in the land of Pacific Graft and Extortion (Pacific Gas and Electric) there have been more than a few complaints that the meters are not accurate and are causing huge increases for some people. P.G. & E. was also less than honest when the initial conplaints started surfacing, claiming that the meters were absolutely reliable. Independent studies proved that to be false and they are now back-peddling like crazy. So, when they called and left a message that they wanted to install one on my home, I somehow "forgot" to call them back. I'll wait a while for them to get the bugs worked out.

Re: OT... Smart meters

#9

If you mean . . .

steve mackay

the ones with the transmiter, yes, we have them. Meter Reader Dude just walks down the street with a receiver (transmiter, receiver, voo-doo . . . I don't know). And, yes they work fine. In fact I was noticing the Dude walking past my house every month without going around back to look at the meter. Being the conspiracy basket case I am I started reading it and comparing it with the bill. I'll be if it wasn't on-the-money ! BIL works for EP Electric and I asked him about this mystery. THAT is when I discoved the new meter was back there. Neat stuff. Wish the gas company would get them so their Dudes are'nt tramping through my yard.

Re: OT... Smart meters

#10

Water

Tony - Memphis

Our water meters are wireless now. I talked to the reader lady one day when I was, ironically, filling the hole after repairing our main line from the street. She said her handheld device would loko at my usage and compare it and beep at her if there was a big delta. She got no beep so assumed that the leak wasn't too bad. Our bill didn't reflect a leak, so I guess she and the device were correct. Yep, pretty neat stuff. Our company has around 100k handheld devices out there. Amazing what can be done with a computer in your hand these days. MUCH more power than my first several pc's. And of course with wireless too.

Our power company is just starting to look at the smart meter stuff. Seems liek I saw a story about that recently. They were looking for volunteers. The system they talked about will allow you to monitor useage. As an engineer geek, I'd love to have one. I have lokoed at the Google stuff and some other products that you can use to monitor your energy useage. Not sure what the heck I'd do with all that data, but it'd be fun to see anyway. I just recently got hold of a really nice temp and humidity sensor (really really nice) and I've been monitoring our temp/RH in the shop and in the house. Interesting to see what happens. Especially with these 100+�F days we are having. The poor ac just can't keep it where we would prefer. After a certain time of day, the unit stays on until night time. We havea programmable thermostat to keep it a little warmer when we aren't there though.

Sorry to ramble.

Tony

Re: OT... Smart meters

#11

Re: OT... Smart meters

Aspen

Scott:

The issues with bad data from the meters are being addresses so it's not as big a concern as it was a year ago. however the real issue that has NOT been addressed and is something that should stop installation until it's dealt with is security.

google: Smart Meter Worm Could Spread Like A Virus

Re: OT... Smart meters

#12

Re: OT... Smart meters

glh17

That is a real problem. Surprised at the industry's attitude. They should hire the guy to test the vulnerabilities. A virus in my computer is one thing, but one in my electricity/gas meter is another.