New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

Posts

If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#1

If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

charlie belden

you could only have back those tools you could list, from memory - how long would your list be? And how many tools do you think you'd probably not get back.

I've got a wall hanging tool cabinet, with storage space in the two doors, that holds about 100 tools - iron and wooden planes, handsaws, squares and the like - along with marking knives, nail sets and punches, smal C-clamps, small hammers, etc. I can find anything in that cabinet - i the dark - while blindfolded. And I can probably do the same with the drawers under my bench, the drawers under the drill press and under the mortising machine. But the stuff in other drawers and cabinets and boxes stashed on and under things in the shop? They'd probably all be goners.

Now I'm not a tool collector - I'm a non-descriminating collector - of stuff. But for those of you who DO collect tools, how would you make out if you could only have back those tools in your collection you could recall in sufficient detail to get back?

(This question was inspired by a TV show called Hoarders - folks whose lives have been taken over by the urge to get - and keep - stuff.)

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#2

Ellis Walentine

First-hand experience

Ellis Walentine

When my shop burned down 11 years ago, I had to get a list together for the insurance company, from memory. They said to take as long as I needed (so they could make money on the payout in the meantime, of course), and, two months later, I submitted a huge Excel spreadsheet of everything I could remember and their approximate values. To this day, I'm still recalling things that I forgot to include on the list. The most painful loss was the couple thousand original shop drawings -- my entire woodworking career's worth.

Ellis

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

Moses Yoder

My memory is not what it was when I was younger. I would get back a #604-1/2 smoothing plane, a 1/2" chisel, and 14" back saw filed rip. That is all I would need to build anything I want to.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#4

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

steve mackay

I started with a 5 1/4 I found in a dumpster. I found WC trying to figure out what it was and how to use it. Thats when my afliction started. WC helped me identify it. By the time I noticed that "The Slope" was "slicker than snot on a doorknob" I already made the rule that I could buy all the tools I wanted as long as I used them so I could probably list 90-some percent.

The "House Tools" might be another matter though.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#5

Using tools

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm in the middle of yet another house project, and was thinking today about the tools (sshhh! the ones I was thinking of burn electrons; but the point's the same) that I use only now and again, but, when I do, am sure grateful for.

I've heard people say that, if you haven't needed it in a year, you don't need it, or words to that effect; but for someone who, like a lot of us including me, does this and that on the house, in the shop, in the garage (cars), under the house (plumbing/electrical/mechanical), around the estate, I'm not sure how that rule plays out.

I have decided that, when it comes to planes, a good general rule (for me - YMMV) is not more than two examples of any given size, so if I drop one on the floor, I'm still operable.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#6

Stephen Shepherd

I would be thankful that...

Stephen Shepherd

I don't have to keep track of the hundreds and hundreds of tools I currently own and remember the hundreds and hundreds of tools that I use to own. I would be free of all that stuff and would move to the Netherlands.

Stephen

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#7

What's the matter with hoarding?

James Watriss

Oh, man... what a can of worms. Most of the woodworkers... professional and otherwise... that I've met are hoarders by nature. So are bicycle mechanics, and anyone else who understands that "I can make that work... I can make it into something that's useful."

It's astonishing, kind of, to realize just how averse people are to using the landfill, once they understand how things work, and that not everything is trash. Interesting thought.

I've been doing shop audits lately, to weed out the things I want, don't want, need, don't need, and so forth.

I think the belt-drive Reed machine lathe that was half-restored and repainted before I bought it would have to go. I still haven't actually connected it to a running motor yet. Kills me, it's such a gorgeous machine with (my perception) vast, untapped potential.

The mini Walker-turner lathe might go, too. Hard to gauge. It does still have all the original HC steel turning tools.

The new Bosch router I haven't used in 3 years, out of loyalty to my Festool routers, would doubtlessly have to go.

I can proudly say that I'm down to only half a gallon of unused Irwin and Pfeil chisels, and maybe a quart of good chisels that I do use.

But then again there's also about a quart of thick plane irons from Hock and L-N that were supposed to go into the fleet of wooden planes that I thought I'd build someday.

The couple of spare bedrock #4 planes would have to go. And probably the old mathieson infill plane that never quite locked up right.

I'll probably never forget, and probably never get around to, that shepherd heavy smoother kit, with the added norris adjuster that I scored on ebay.

And the CMT cove cutting wheel that's meant to go on a table saw, but won't work on the sawstop due to compatibility issues.

Oh, forgotten tools? Yeah, can't say I quite recall.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#8

Whoops... Sorry Stephen.

James Watriss

Meant to post that as a regular response to the original thread, not to your post... not at all trying to accuse you of hoarding.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#9

If Someone Took ALL Your unfinished projects away?

James Watriss

So, leaving tools to one side... question changes to "How many unfinished projects do you have lying around the shop that you haven't touched in a while."

I bet there's a similar discussion.

From memory, I have:

-A half finished bookcase with split sides. (Sides split during glue-up, but carcase is still stable enough to be usable.

-2 molding planes from a 2 day Larry Williams crash course I took in 2005.

-An unfinished wooden razee jack plane I was making out of purpleheart. Or did I throw that one out?

-A Greene and Greene inspired desk that I started in the summer of 2005 that got interrupted by class resuming that fall at NBSS. Just have to finish up a drawer and then put a finish on it... I think.

-The same machine lathe I mentioned in my tool post.

-2 maple logs. Need I say more?

-12 bending forms for some chairs I was going to make before I moved to a new shop in 2008.

-Prototype of a folding desk for apartment dwellers.

-A federal dining set that belonged to my grandparents that I've been meaning to rebuild. (rickety chairs, table slides need to be rebuilt)

-Small 4 drawer chest of drawers.

-A half build mountain bike. I was a bicycle mechanic- don't ask.

-And on, and on...

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#10

Re: First-hand experience

James Watriss

Deepest sympathies over the loss of the drawings. All the rest can typically be replaced or done without.

:-(

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#11

Counter arguments

James Watriss

I heard various arguments for and against getting rid of tools.

The best argument for doing so is a philosophy from a friend of mine about the Zen of collecting. He says you gather a bunch of similar items together, learn what you can from the collection, and then send them all back out into the world so that they can continue to have useful existences, and the souls of those tools can eventually die content from a long life of work well done.

The best argument I heard towards not getting rid of tools, and I forget where I heard it... maybe in here? Never get rid of a tool that's paid for. Chances are good it's out of desperation. You might get half of your money back, if you're not desperate for money. Replacements will still be full cost, and likely not as well made. And the tool is only useful if you have it in your possession.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your unfinished projects a

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I'd have a lot more room in the shop!

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#13

I'd have to be a millipede to count mine

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

unfinished projects, that is.

And it'd take me all day to take my shoes off so I could count them.

Better to keep working and hope the universe, and my sweetie, don't add too many more.

Still, I'd rather face this problem than the problem at the other end of the continuum: everything's done, and nothing new to work on.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#14

Most all of them except...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

The ones under the bed, and the ones on the top shelf of the bed room closet. Oh, and the ones in the dinning room cupboards. :b

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#15

Easy

Kevin French Antrim, NH

I have to move it, sell it, down size it and have 2 months to do it.

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#16

So Kevin...

Bob Hackett

Where you headed this time?

I thought you had recently moved into the house you`re in now.

Squirrels getting the better of ya?

Re: If Someone Took ALL Your Tools Away - and

#17

Re: So Kevin...

Kevin French Antrim, NH

There's been a domestic division.

Not sure where I'm headed long term, immediately trying to work an arrangement to move in with an old friend who is dying of cancer to take care of him and his property.