We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
My parents want me to repair a tread on their porch. The top tread, undersized, has split, and it is the one piece of decking on the porch that is under a roof support post. I'm thinking the only way to proceed is to jack up the roof, and pull the old board out. To do that, I would either have to put up a beam well outboard, but the simpler, and safer way would be to rip out the railing, (and probably end up replacing everything one can see, and a lot under it). I don't want to trim a piece to fit around the post, because the tread piece already looks a little decayed.
Very wise words, and for two reasons. The second being when you get in there you are going to find your "little job" is a monster, so you might as well at least avoid the surprise. Unfortunately the "clients" are a little wary and I end up wearing it for talking them into a larger job. What are sons for.
Trying to visualize this. Is there just one post that has to be lifted, or several? If just one, I am wondering if you could get a largish catspaw underneath that post, working from the inboard side, and lift the post up just enough (1/4" or so), so you can get a Sawzall in from the outboard side, slice the nails, and get the bad board out.
Another option, especially if the lifting is more extensive, is to use two hydraulic jacks (not very expensive) and some 4x4's, and lift whatever has to be lifted from the inboard side (on the porch). This would be a lot more comfortable if you find rot down underneath the cracked board--which is a pretty good bet. You could augment the jacks with deck-to-roof timbers, if it turns out that the overhead cover is gonna have to remain elevated for a while.
Good luck! If your parents are like mine were, they're thinking a quick, easy fix, not a redo.
When I completely rebuilt our porch several years ago, I lagscrewed boards to the house (to the framing); used joist hangers to fasten 2x6s at right angles to these boards and to the posts (lagscrews again), extending these 2x6s out past the porch; then jacked up the end of the 2x6s, finally supporting them with 4x4s. Because I was supporting the entire porch, four posts in total, I was able to X-brace the 4x4s in pairs to keep them stable.
This worked for the long, long period that the porch was being rebuilt - since I was still working full-time and kept getting interrupted by other things, it took me well over a year.
I don't know if this would work for your particular problem, but I offer it as how I solved the problem.
My remodeling-contractor son encounters this problem all the time: fix it now, knowing that someone will have to fix it again and again later; or convince the owners to allow a more comprehensive fix. He's learned that about all he can do is lay out the choices as clearly as possible and let the owners decide. Of course, he doesn't have to face them at holidays.
If your folks expect to move in the next few years, a short-term fix may be enough; if they're thinking they'll be there for a while, longer-term may make more sense. There is then the problem of whether you want to/are able to spend multiple weekends tearing the porch down to the foundation and up again.
I tore the railing and the post out. It looks like I can leave the demo at that, or take off half the house.:) The structure slopes about 2.5 inches over 6 feet, and is just propped up on some blocks, but the overall house has been here over 200 years, so maybe the porch is all that is holding it up.