Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

Posts

O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#1

Stephen Shepherd

O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

I was at a local Tandy/Leather Factory and saw this knife. The case said it was Damascus Stainless Steel Blade.

It looked to me and others present that the pattern was etched on the surface and not from fabrication.

Stephen


Damascus knife

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#2

Iv'e seen knifes like that...l

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

In a Indiana Jones movies. I won't be stopping at your house for breakfast.

:D

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#3

David Barnett

Kinda kitschy *LINK*

David Barnett

It's only nominally Damascus steel, Stephen. The more accurate term would be pattern welded. Stainless Damascus is often etched to highlight contrasting striations in the two metals. It's a cosmetic thing. Personally, I'd prefer plain carbon tool steel to that stuff anyday.

Faux Damascus, with showy artificial striations on a single steel substrate, is seen in imported mass-produced cheaply-made "flea market" knives.

True Damascus, made from wootz steel, was not a product of pattern welding (the studies on wootz nanotubes are intriguing, btw).

To really understand the difference between pattern welded and true Damascus, read Genuine Damascus Steel: A type of banded microstructure in hypereutectoid steels under links near the bottom of this bibliography:


J. D. Verhoeven and A. H. Pendray

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

Moses Yoder

A lot of this damascus steel nowadays is simply different types of steel forged into layers by machine and then set into an etching liquid that will eat a little bit of whichever steel is softest, leaving the lines. Nothing like the old fashioned hand made damascus. I read a little bit about it one time when I purchased a "damascus" knife blank.

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#5

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

bugbear

It looked to me and others present that the pattern was etched on the surface and not from fabrication.

Should be fairly easy to tell.

If it's etched, all the blades should show identical patterns.

But if it's laminated and ground, there ain't enough precision on this earth to make the patterns come out identical, because the grinding plane is at such a fine angle to the plane of the laminations.

So compare a few blades to each other, assuming the shop has more than one in stock.

BugBear

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

Stephen Shepherd

My 1850 English shotgun has barrels of true Damascus and I have seen many knives made with the same.

This tool is obviously an etched pattern and both sides are identical.

Stephen

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#7

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

ThomD

That appears to be laminated steel, though it is hard to tell from the pic. LV sells/sold nice kitchen knives made with a similar process. The outer steel surface is stainless and the tool is in the middle and is usually carbon steel. This is actually pretty functional and fundtionally pretty. Most people want more corrosion resistance than a pure carbon tool allows, and whatever posture one wants to take on the authenticity of one machine made steel over another, the patten is interesting.

Nomenclature is shifty stuff. Culturally one is allowed to take whatever departures one wants to, and the ship has long since sailed on Damascus. But even at that, the kind of blade here also has other names like San Mai.

Look at this knife:

http://www.leevalley.com/en/garden/page.aspx?p=32466&cat=2,40733,40738

They seem to be calling the line between the steel layers a hanom, when it should be a hardness line in the same steel. It gets kinda complicated

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#8

David Barnett

Again, nominal Damascus, Stephen...

David Barnett

...not true ancient Damascus. But yes, it still is common to call the pre-Twentieth Century twisted forge-welded barrels as described in Lord Egerton's treatise on Indo-Persian barrel forming: Indian and Oriental Armour, albeit inaccurately, as Damascus.

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#9

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

deloid

Hi Stephen,

I looked at some of the responses and there was a variety of opinions. I know this blade, I have seen many of them at tandy stores. You know I am also a leather worker and blacksmith. These are true modern damascus steel blades. As noted in one post the more correct term is pattern welded. All pattern welded, wootz, wrought shows the patern when treated with a mild acid to expose the different layers of carbon content or other substance.

Symmetry is a hallmark of pattern welded blades. The random pattern of true wootz and wrought (inclusions) make it desirable.

If the question is whether this pattern welded blade is better than the $30 plain jane version the answer is no. Is it a fake etch...? No.

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#10

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

deloid

Pattern welded can also be made "random patterned"

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#11

scott grandstaff

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

scott grandstaff

It looks like Damascus that is about 20 layers.

512 is something of a standard and I have seen 22,000 layer

Fold and weld, fold and weld.

yours Scott

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#12

David Barnett

Didja count all 22,000, Scott, didja?

David Barnett

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#13

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

darin

Google "scientific american Damascus steel" for more information but to summarize the secret had been lost for centuries. Although the process and ingredients have been reconstructed a small knife costs thousands of dollars and I doubt that a Damascus plane iron would be a improvement over what we have.

I think that the Scientific American issue that covered the rediscovery of the Secret was about 10 years ago.

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#14

scott grandstaff

Re: Didja count all 22,000, Scott, didja?

scott grandstaff

no, but since you are doubling with every fold it adds up pretty quick.

S

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#15

Another good reference...

John in NM

Is "A History of Metallography" by Cyril Stanley Smith. He covers the distinctions between pattern welding and forged Damascus steels in detail. Trouble is the book is a bit hard to come by these days, seems to be selling for around $200 on Amazon...

There was a copy at the University of Arizona Science Library 20 years ago, that's the sort of place I'd look for it :D

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#16

Re: Pattern welded.

ThomD

Are we sure about that. Where is the patern, it is just layers. Like calling plywood pattern laminated. Like the difference between grain and figure. To me pattern welded ought to be a ladder pattern etc...

In knives damascus tends to refer to a material where the edge is one of the hard layers, not an inserted layer bit.

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#17

Re: O.T. Leather working tool

bugbear

This tool is obviously an etched pattern and both sides are identical.

The latter implies the former - that's all I was sayin'

BugBear

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#18

The distinction, IIRC...

John in NM

Is that true Damascus steel is forged from a billet of iron in a reducing heat source like coke or coal. The lack of excess oxygen in the fire causes the formation of iron carbides on the surface of the billet. As it's folded and re-forged the carbide rich layer on the surface becomes the harder layer inside, multiplied with each fold.

Pattern welding is the term in the materials science and historical literature for any layer or patterned billet that is made up of sheets of differing steels that are forge welded and folded to create the pattern. Plywood would in fact be pattern wood, as simple layering is a pattern just as the twisted "Damascus" shotgun barrels are. I believe they're soldered rather than welded though, leading to many cautions against using smokeless charges in such a gun.

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#19

Chris Scholz

No comments on the leather tools, but

Chris Scholz

enjoy counting the, number of laminations in our Master Series plane blades

.

Chris

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#20

Why?

Bob Hackett

All this fuss and bother just because it`s too much trouble to chase down real wrought iron to back a HCS edge?

I understand the reasoning behind why they did it way back when but why do a pattern welded backing for a decent edge steel when it has to be WAY cheaper to produce,and for customers to buy,an iron made of one solid piece of whatever the edge is made from and is actually doing the work?

Everything except that edge is eye candy and serves no real purpose other than to say"Check out my disposable income level".

Wait,I just got it!

These irons go into those cool dovetailed bronze planes I heard about that are never used and only sit on a shelf in the study as an accoutrement to all those WWing books.

I get it now.

Never mind!(Said in his best Gilda Radner character voice.)

Re: O.T. Leather working tool *LINK*

#21

Chris Scholz

Re: Why?

Chris Scholz

Man Bob, you are hurting me :D

Of course you can take any old rusty piece of (reasonably high) carbon steel and make a decent woodworking tool out of it. In fact, many years ago folks did do absolutely amazing work with bronze or even stone tools.

Yes, there have always been ceremonial tools, I suppose showing off one's wealth, influence, importance---whatever that may mean---is human nature. Twist core is such an embellishment that falls into that category.

One can't even argue that folded and/or laminated steel stiffens the blade as is usually done. Snakeoil! Stiffness of steel has pretty much the same, no matter how high or low the carbon content.

What's left? There are serious woodworkers, folks who actually produce stuff, who swear by laminated (and folded) steel. It reduced vibrations, so the theory. In use laminated blades sound differently, they say. Sort of like the laser cut grooves in TS blades, although that is not really a fair comparison. Problem is that contrast to TS blades there is really no concise analysis of the dynamics of blades for handplanes. Should one give the laminated/folded steel blades at least the benefit of the doubt?

Chris