New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

highly embellished plane

Posts

highly embellished plane

#1

highly embellished plane

Catharine Kennedy

This is as "over-the-top" a plane as I have done- the center is sculpted, the backgrounds are all stippled.

Now onto the 2nd side!


img

Re: highly embellished plane

#2

David Barnett

Ambitiously embellished, I would say.

David Barnett

I can appreciate the time you've put into it. Is this one of your own planes?

Re: highly embellished plane

#3

Re: Ambitiously embellished, I would say.

Catharine Kennedy

yes- this is one of my bench working planes- took a week long workshop in engraving techniques a couple of weeks ago and needed to have a project- so grabbed this!

Re: highly embellished plane

#4

David Barnett

Re: Ambitiously embellished, I would say.

David Barnett

I've always been fond of running wheat borders. Overall nice use of space.

Re: highly embellished plane

#6

Wow.  Just...wow.

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm imagining the conversations years from now, on whatever replaces the Interweb, about these planes.

Re: highly embellished plane

#7

Re: Very nice! How long did side one take?

Catharine Kennedy

about 10 hours, not all at once though!

Re: highly embellished plane

#8

You are an Artiste !

steve mackay

Re: highly embellished plane

#9

Re: highly embellished plane

Marv

Hi Catherine,

How do you feel about carving an antique collectible tool, one that is considered rare and valuable?

The reason I ask....I have been critisized for wheat carving rare handsaw handles for a few customers. The critisizm comes from serious saw collectors. I wouldn't do it to a saw of that kind that I own but if a customer requests it, I will reluctantly do it if they insist.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: highly embellished plane

#10

Re: highly embellished plane

Catharine Kennedy

Antique, collectible guns are engraved...and probably never used for what they were intended. A lot of Lie-Nielsen tools are bought just to be collected. Are we talking about usefulness, or art, or just keeping them away from the horders?

I would like to think my skills would enhance a tool's value- obviously it isn't going to cut any better (more fun, but not better)- these items were made to be used-not just put on a shelf to accrue value...

Good topic for discussion!

Re: highly embellished plane

#11

Leo Cuellar

Gorgeous, is not descriptive enough...

Leo Cuellar

You really do add "value" to the tools you enhance. I'm sure there are enough un-altered tools stuck away in museums to satisfy the historians. Life is far too short to not have it enhanced by things of beauty that make us happy and inspire us to greater heights! Do not let any negative nellies tell you that your work would detract from a mass produced hunk of metal. It all adds to the journey of the tool, and anyone that owns it has the right to make it personal for themselves.

P.S. I'm contemplating doing something with my working planes that would be considered sacrilege by many, but I have to learn how to electroplate first :D

Re: highly embellished plane

#12

Re: highly embellished plane

Marv

Catherine,

Your work is super impressive. The kind of embellishing that you do to any tool, without a doubt, increases it's value, at least in my opinion. Some might argue, however, that there is a point at which those of us who enjoy the art of embellishing should draw a line that we shouldn't cross when it comes to choosing which tool to carve and which ones we won't. I tend to go along with this line of thought, but I also tend to go along with what an owner of a tool wants done to their tools. At times I'm torn between the two.

The few customers who have insisted on my wheat carving their rare saws don't use them. They are collectors and only display their tools for show. Usually, those who use their saws don't want to pay extra for the embellishments. I say usually because a few just like the look of them and don't mind the extra cost. Many collectors want little or no change to the tools they collect. Bottom line, there are many different attitudes when it comes to these issues.

I've engaged in more than a few discussions on the subject. The word "blasphemy" seems to creep into the converstion at times. Some people are very serious when it comes to retaining the age of a tool that includes rust and cracks and whatever else might give the tool "character". Any repair or added embellishment only deminishes that which they feel adds to the value.

Marv

Re: highly embellished plane

#13

Re: highly embellished plane

wilbur

Gorgeous work, as always! I really enjoy seeing your engraving work.

When you first start out on one of these projects, do you usually have to go through a series of sketches or drawings before hitting on your final design, or do you usually have a good idea of what you want to do with the plane right off the bat?

Re: highly embellished plane

#14

Re: highly embellished plane

Catharine Kennedy

Delighted you enjoy my work!

There are various "rules" in this work, so I have a general idea of where I need to put elements- but each plane is a bit different, one design doesn't fit all. For this plane, the border was cut in and the oval & its border were laid out and cut. One quadrant of that design was penciled in and cut. That pattern was then transferred via transfer was and clear tape to the next section. That was cut then both of the areas were transferred in the same manner to the side & cut.

When I got to the outside, that was laid out as I would any plane, the elements just kissing the border- the elements and the background (negative space) should balance each other out.

Takes time to get here! (but the journey is well worth it!)

Re: highly embellished plane

#15

David Barnett

To better appreciate what Catharine is saying...

David Barnett

...it's worthwhile to find Drawing & Understanding Scroll Designs by Ron Smith, and books heavy on photographs of engraved knives and firearms. Also, look at the galleries on:

The Engraver's Cafe,

http://www.igraver.com/forum/

The Fine Embellishment Forum,

http://tinyurl.com/FineEmbellishmentForum

And if you love bulino,

http://www.engravingforum.com/

Scrollwork is seemingly limitless. Amazing what the common acanthus can inspire. Who says a plane has to look plain?

Re: highly embellished plane

#16

Re: highly embellished plane

deloid

Very nice work and much better use of the negative space. One critique from one who is foollowing your path. Since you left the canvas with striations rather than a high polish your BG stippling is a little lost and your central Fleur de lis pattern is fuzzy rather than crisp.

Overall nice pattern and execution!

Re: highly embellished plane

#17

Re: highly embellished plane

Catharine Kennedy

Nice to see you're checking up on me! The central part is fuzzy because it's textured from being pounded by a punch (sculpted) This will get more consistant with practice, but not ever smooth unless I stone it.

Re: highly embellished plane

#18

Re: highly embellished plane

Bob Hackett

I`ve talked to motorcycle collectors who feel the same way.They thought it blasphemy to customize the old machines to make a "chopper".What they didn`t understand was that most of the bikes guys like me built started as a piece here and there that were assembled into a bike or a bike that we got as a wreck and rebuilt.I don`t ever remember seeing a complete, restorable old bike being customized.Many of the bikes we rode would have been sent to scrap if we hadn`t come along to save them.

An embellished tool or bike shows the level of commitment a person has to their lifestyle.

Any tools that has seen the benefits of skills of like Catharine,Marv and others practice is very unlikely to be misused,roughly handled,improperly stored or left out to rust.You can tell your stuff from the rest of the crowd at a glance and I find it far superior to things like repeated centerpunch marked initials or coded file grooves like the old timers used to mark their things.How can the rough markings,rust and damage from use be called by words such as character and history and yet things like finely done artistic embellishments be called anything less than the art they truly are?

Re: highly embellished plane

#19

Re: highly embellished plane

deloid

I try to follow posts from talented people like youself :)

Re: highly embellished plane

#20

Re: highly embellished plane

Ralph Lipeles

Hoping to see it up close at the Shaker Village Friday September 24th.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: highly embellished plane

#21

Re: highly embellished plane

Catharine Kennedy

Nope- not this year, Ralph- I retired from there last fall, after 16 years... engraving full time now- and doing woodworking for my own pleasure!

Sorry to miss you though!