Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

I want a do-over

Posts

I want a do-over

#1

I want a do-over

Patrick Gibbons

I finished my drop-leaf table yesterday in the afternoon. It's a project that had more mistakes than even I should have made. The final killer is the proportion of the project. The top looks too small for it. I rechecked measurements and think that I made the base too wide by about 2 inches. I was using measurements out of a book on Stickley furniture that took projects directly from The Craftsman magazine that was published at the beginning of the 20th century. They gave a cut list and had some measurements listed on the isometric but other finished dimensions were left to the individual to cypher out. I made my tenons all the same length on the upper frame but now see that if I had made the tenons for the sides longer than the ends that I would have ended up with a better proportion on the overall project. Still I think the piece would have looked better with the sides an inch shorter than that. I'm going to start my next project but at this point I'm thinking I'm going to do this one over again. What should I do with the mistake. It looks too good to throw away but it stills bugs me.

Re: I want a do-over

#2

Re: I want a do-over

Bob Hackett

Seems to me you are in a very good position here.You say you can improve the proportions by cutting a few things down.My problem always seems to be that things need to be longer to look right.

Cut the ends down and see how it looks then.Alternately,take the top off the base and then build a smaller base to fit the existing top and a bigger top to fit the base you already have.

Give the one your like least to your MIL.She`ll just pile bric-a brac on it and nobody will notice anyway. ;)

Re: I want a do-over

#3

An excellent suggestion, Bob

Patrick Gibbons