Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Aluminum tote

Posts

Aluminum tote

#1

Aluminum tote

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Garage saling today, I picked up the first plane I've ever seen with an aluminum tote, a Stanley 5-1/4 (I'm terrible with type studies, but it does have the kidney-shaped hole on the lever cap, but a Made in USA iron).


I can see some obvious advantages (unlikely ever to break, and resistant to rot) and disadvantages (cold on the hand in winter); but are these totes collectible enough that I should consider scrounging a replacement tote and trying to sell this one?

Re: Aluminum tote

#2

I don't know about the value of the tote...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

It's been my understanding the Al totes were used a lot in schools. Along with the fact they also used a lot 5-1/4's as well.

I have a rosewood one that will fit it if you want it.

You know the drill...

Re: Aluminum tote

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Aluminum tote

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I've got a #40� with an aluminum tote.

I was told the totes were fitted to planes intended for use in industrial arts school shops, but I can't confirm the accuracy of that.

Walter's "Guide" says they were supplied as 'replacements only,' and that they were made in the 1930s. His (1994 version) book puts value at $10~#30.

Jim D.

Re: Aluminum tote

#4

Re: Aluminum tote

ThomD

How much lead do you figure is in that kind of casting?

Re: Aluminum tote

#5

Re: Aluminum tote

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I happen to have another 5-1/4 (frankenplane: got the body with tote, knob, frog, nothing else; scrounged an iron and chipbreaker; mounted a lever cap from some unknown plane that fit), and, while I haven't weighed them, the aluminum-toted one does feel heavier.

Re: Aluminum tote

#6

Re: Aluminum tote

Marv

I see them on eBay from time to time. Never have seen one bid up very high. I'll start paying more attention and let you know what I run across.

Marv

Re: Aluminum tote

#7

is the bottom corrugated?

David Miller from Iowa

If so, it is a reasonably valuable plane. If not it is still a nice plane.

As scott indicated, the aluminum handles were often used in schools (and factories) with concrete floors to help resist damage from breaking when inevitably pushed off the backside of the bench. Also the 5 1/4 was standard issue to schools for "manual training" class.

I'm guessing your plane is from the 1950s, possibly as late as 1960 with that hardwood knob.

Aluminum handles used to bring decent money - I have paid up to $45 for new old stock ones, but that was several years ago. I tried to sell a couple on eBay earlier this year and they bring about the same as a good rosewood one ($15 +/-).

I'd keep it and use it as is.

Re: Aluminum tote

#8

Three words for ya...

Bob Hackett

His to ree.

Keep it as is.

Guess that makes it 7,No wait 11 and a number.Ah,forget it! :b

Re: Aluminum tote

#9

Keep it?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Well, of course.

Re: Aluminum tote

#10

Re: Aluminum tote

ThomD

I was worried more about gettin the lead on your hands