Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Need design opinions

Posts

Need design opinions

#1

Need design opinions

Larry Wyatt

I'm making a potpourri box for a friend and am struggling a bit with design. Attached are two pics of the box. As you can see, I've added another ball on the top in one of the pics. The mahogany piece with carved out edges is not glued on yet.


Your considered opinions on the overall and specific design of the top? Bigger ball? No ball? More holes? Fewer holes? More smaller holes? I'm trying to tie in all the circles/spheres. Arrrgggghhh!! LOL

Thanks

Larry Wyatt

aka Cole's Dad

Re: Need design opinions

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

No ball

Jack Guzman from Maine

Larry,I would leave out the ball on top. Keep it simple.Detail the edges of the mahogany piece some and I'd call it good.---Jack

Re: Need design opinions

#3

Re: No ball

wilbur

I agree with leaving off the ball. If you were going to use the ball as a grip for the lid, you could undercut the edges of the mahogany piece, and that would give you the holding area to allow the mahogany piece to serve as a grip.

As far as the holes, I think I would add more holes to let more of the potpourri aroma to come out. I know nothing about these things, but the pictures of potpourri boxes that I have seen seem to have more surface area for the aroma to come out.

Re: Need design opinions

#4

Design opinion

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Larry

The ball is out of place.

You have done some nice work here, and I would keep most of what you have. My suggestion would be to lose the shaped piece on top, drill more holes around the circumference (the whole - sorry - idea is to let the smell out), and then add a handle. What I have is mind is a simple "bridge" type, made out of dowel (in keeping with the round) but on the diagonal (to reduced the squareness...


If you are industrious, carve the "bridge" handle into a semi-circle.

Quick drawing on Paint.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Need design opinions

#5

Re: Design opinion

Bob Hackett

To build on what Derek proposed,I would orient the handle across one diagonal and then make 2 short slots oriented across the opposite diagonal to balance the long handle with the holes.Think transitional detail.

Re: Need design opinions

#6

Re: Need design opinions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Larry,

Very nice gift!! I suggest taking the mahogany ornament on top and cut a half-moon shape from it, to serve as a pull. Orient this semi circular pull with the grain, so it's not fighting the distinctive grain on the box lid.

You could affix the pull by fashioning it with an extra 1/4" extension at the base to serve as a tenon, and mortise ver-r-r-y carefully for it into the lid. Alternatively, take a small chisel or knife and hollow the base of the pull just enough so you get flush no-gap fit all around, glue it down, then drill and glue two 1/8" dowels into it from the underside of the lid, just for good measure. Suggested detail: carve the half moon so it is narrowest at the base, and flares slightly toward the top.

My apologies for any cribbing I have done from Derek's earlier post!

Wiley

Re: Need design opinions

#7

Leo Cuellar

Re: Need design opinions

Leo Cuellar

If you really want to keep the ball element, a finial shape might work.

Re: Need design opinions

#8

no ball

roninkokomo

Re: Need design opinions

#9

One more

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi again Larry

I was passing by and thought I'd have another look. It occurred to me that you could do something a little more decorative and less boring that plain holes.

This is just an illustration of what I mean ... just convert the existing holes into "double teardrops" (its what they remind me of). Add a pair of facing teardrops, and these may be used as finger grips for the lid. Or use whatever design you like .. musical signs, daisies ...


Watdoyoutink?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Need design opinions

#10

Many thanks, folks!!

Larry Wyatt

It's fascinating to see how many varied opinions that I received. And I thank each one of your for your input.

I'll post the final product when it's finished.

Larry

Re: Need design opinions

#11

Re: One more

Larry Wyatt

Hiya Derek:

I received one suggestion on the power side about more small holes. I had pretty much decided it needed more holes, but smaller. I want to make a design of them, and your suggestion gives me some ideas.

Thanks!

Larry