Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

Posts

So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#1

So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

David Weaver

:b ..

And it arrives with two pieces of wood in it. One of them looks pretty innocent - it's the piece of wood that he tortured frank klausz with at the LN event a month or two ago. It's dense, it actually looks like a pretty nice piece of wood, and it's got a thin coat of shellac on one side.

On the other side, it says in pencil something like "work on this side", because he wants to keep the trophy side.

The second piece of wood is a small piece about big enough to make moulding plane wedges, but about 2 feet long. It's quartersawn, I have no idea what it is, but it looks relatively dense in some places, and it appears to grow puffed wheat in between the dense parts - or something about as dense as puffed wheat. What a pain!

I took the relatively innocent piece of wood down to my bench, pulled out my 55 degree infill plane, and took a swipe straight down the quartered grain and the only way the piece of wood could've looked worse would be if it would've exploded - so much for looking innocent.

To make matters worse, the face that I'm not allowed to touch isn't flat, and the side i'm playing on isn't level either :b I skewed the plane some since it's quartersawn, and went both directions on it, and it completely refused to be planed.

So, I got out a panel plane to at least level the side that I'm allowed to touch, and did that with much gnashing of teeth. This is now about 5 minutes into planing one goofy little piece of wood..

Got the infill smoother back out and started to work directly across the grain until most of the tearout was out, and then went back down the length askew, and that made it worse again (this is a plane with a mouth < .004"), and it took another full 5 minutes with many drops of sweat falling onto the subject piece until I found a direction that it was remotely close to being cooperative...

pictures to come, and I should be able to mail the package back to wilbur sometime in the near future. I'll let him finish the story when he gets it...

I have to agree with frank klaus (pretty wood, never build anything with it) and admit that i'm beat, though in the end, the embarrassment is not as bad as I thought it would be after the initial pass. It looks sort of like bubinga with closer grain, but I've never had trouble planing bubinga...or cocobolo...or ebony, or anything of the sort.

I wouldn't have believed a piece of wood could've been that bad without planing it myself. Just awful.

Thanks wilbur! Can you tell us what it is?

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#2

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur

Joe

That Wilbur pan is inscrutable!

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#3

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur

wilbur

I know that that piece of wood came from a flooring job from one of the members of our woodworking club that supplied the pieces for our club's Stack of Wood contest. They were all tropical species. Out of the species that were supplied, it looks most like bubinga to me, and maybe it's a particularly interlocked piece. The other possibilities based on the other species in the Stack of Wood are jatoba, cumaru, or Santos mahogany. Someone at the Lie-Nielsen event at Frank Klausz's shop thought it might be chechen, but I don't think it's that, either.

Glad you had fun with it! ;)

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#4

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur

wilbur

Hi Joe,

I would use the term "unplanable". Inscrutable is a board that you can't drill a pilot hole into. ;)

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#5

Chris Scholz

Did you try a Chinese pane? *LINK*

Chris Scholz

...they are supposed to be the tool of choice for this kind a wood.


Chinese Planes

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#6

Re: Did you try a Chinese pane?

David Weaver

Yes, an ebony muji, but the problem isn't really that the wood is dense and needs a steep angle, the problem is that it's dense in some spots, but the stuff that tears out is really soft. It's a rotten combination, so even scraping it doesn't do any good.

The infill works the best, and outperforms the muji by a fair amount, but the mouth is much tighter on it and it's heavier.

The muji is probably better than a stanley bench plane - I didn't even bother to go there with a standard bench plane based on how the panel plane didn't tolerate it.

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#7

Re: The pictures

David Weaver

The pictures, which as always, just don't do this task justice. Keep in mind, this board showed up sanded with no tearout on it and looked really nice, so even if the picture doesn't look as bad as you expect, take a good close look at the tearout. I left them (since they're large) as links so they wouldn't screw up navigating.

I can't imagine using something like this on a project without just sanding it - this is just a little board.

First, after my initial tries with several planes, the board after leveling most of the top - this is major tearout. Half of what comes out is just dust. Skewing the plane in this direction does nothing, and going back in the other direction is worse.

http://img180.imageshack.us/img180/2420/p1040236a.jpg

And then after that, this is the only direction, and with skew, that it would be planed. It was like walking a tight rope, do anything different or change the skew, and you get awful tearout and it's back to square one.

http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/5102/p1040242e.jpg

And the last picture, best picture I had of the remaining tearout. Even after planing it, this is still left in it. I thought about resharpening and seeing if I could get it out, but that would be unrealistic, you'd never tolerate it on a project.

http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/8420/p1040244.jpg

and scraping with a scraper plane or card scraper? Tried both of those, the same result.

Wilbur - I think it would make great flooring (mainly because of the sander)! If it would've had face grain, and not been rift sawn, I think it wouldn't have been that bad to plane, but we'll never know.

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#8

Re: The pictures

Warren in Lancaster, PA

That looks like a board tailor made for a double iron plane. A nice ribbon figure or what some people call a broken stripe. Is it some kind of African mahogany?

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#9

Looks may be deceiving..

David Weaver

I'm not sure what it is, but its density seems closer to ebony than african mahogany.

I don't think the double iron would do any good in this case because the areas that tear out are not nearly as dense, steeper made worse. I thought about getting out a japanese plane, but I left well enough alone once I got it close to planed.

I'd be entertained though to see anyone plane it along the grain no matter the plane or the amount of skewing.

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#10

Re: The pictures

wilbur

As I had mentioned above, from the information we got at our club's Stack of Wood contest, this was either bubinga, jatoba, cumaru, or Santos mahogany. Out of the species that were supplied, it looks most like bubinga to me, and maybe it's a particularly interlocked piece of bubinga. Someone at the Lie-Nielsen event at Frank Klausz's shop thought it might be chechen, but I don't think so based on photos of chechen that I have seen.

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#11

Re: The pictures

Frank D. in Montreal

In the first pic it looks a lot like Santos mahogany, but in the next 2 it looks a little browner and looks more like bubinga. Nothing smells like Santos mahogany though, it's easy to recognize if you've smelled it before (smells really good, although I know thats not much help...). I have some Santos mahogany with very similar reverse grain patterns.


img

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#13

Re: The pictures

wilbur

The picture that makes me think it's highly figured bubinga is the one on Woodfinder.

It doesn't smell particularly good.


img

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#14

Re: The pictures

Frank D. in Montreal

Yes,

I have some of that too! :D


img

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#15

Re: Frank, does it smell like Ceader?

Frank D. in Montreal

Kind of,

although it's sweeter and smells even better, like perfume. THe smell also lingers more than cedar. THe smell is perhaps closer to BC fir, but again, more perfume-like (?).

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#16

Insteresting...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I have a 10/4 blank I picked up as mahog. Or so I've been told. It has a ceder odor but much stronger like you said. It only smells like that when it's planed. It's weird that when I crosscut or ripped it didn't have any odor, very interesting, those boards were true Mothers to work, Also, mine were stringy more than anything.

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#17

Re: The pictures

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I have some pink satinwood veneer that looks like that. Didn't notice any special smell, but I would assume that any original smell has been washed out during the veneering process.

DC

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#18

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur

Dominic in Buck's County PA

Wilbur,

You wrote:

"Someone at the Lie-Nielsen event at Frank Klausz's shop thought it might be chechen, but I don't think it's that, either."

That would have be ME! :D :b And yeah, it's not the first time I've been off when it comes to wood identification. :D

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: So, I get this package in the mail from Wilbur Pan

#19

Re: The pictures

Tom Lewis

Looks like it might be Red Gum (Eucalyptus camaldulensis).

I have a love/hate relation with this wood. check out the Wikipedia entry with photo.

Tom Lewis