Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Spoke shave blade

Posts

Spoke shave blade

#1

Spoke shave blade

Patrick Gibbons

A friend gave me a Goodell Pratt #36 patternmaker's spoke shave. An example can be seen at Rose Antiques. It does not have a way to feed the blade, the blade is hand adjusted. The original blade is still good but seems thin. Are there any replacement blades available for a shave like this?

Re: Spoke shave blade

#2

Re: Spoke shave blade

Neal in San Jose

Kinda hard to tell exactly without dimensions, but five sources that might help are Hock tools, St. James Bay, Lie Nielsen, Lee Valley and Jim Reed. All carry replacement spokeshave blades. If you can't find a direct replacement in one of those places, Jim Reed has been known to make specials. He used to post here regularly, but I haven't seen him around lately. Ron Hock has also been known to make specials. I don't know if he still will, but you can check with him. I think St. James Bay might knock out a special as well. You can also make one yourself - it isn't that difficult.

Re: Spoke shave blade

#3

Go with it

David Miller from Iowa

The blades on that model are thin and they work fine.

(Pause while I get my soap box)

The reason thick blades are in style is that they reduce chatter when going against the grain when planing difficult hardwood. Spokeshaves generally go with the grain and chatter is not an issue - like when Stanley had their razor edge spokeshaves.

Just sharpen and go, the edge is far more critical than the thickness on a spokeshave.

Re: Spoke shave blade

#4

Re: Go with it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

While I haven't used my Stanley 63 (which has a very thin blade) much, I've been pleased by how little it's chattered.

I would add to David's comment that tool quality matters - the 63 is a Sweetheart. The plague-green Kunz of the same size and configuration that I owned chattered like a squirrel on Starbucks, and I shed no tears when I gave it away.

Re: Spoke shave blade

#5

Agree with the others

James Watriss

I suggest you see how the current blade handles first.

I can't speak to G-P shaves, but if the irons are like a lot of other stuff being made at the time, the blade may be better than you think.

One more point on chattering... planes in particular typically need stiffer irons because they are often used to take full width shavings. Spokeshaves typically are not.

Re: Spoke shave blade

#6

Another consideration

Neal in San Jose

Apart from functionality, there is the desire to keep some tools pretty much intact. The original blade will probably work just fine. I mean, that was the manufacturer's original intent. But, if it's Patrick's intention to keep the tool in as-found condition, then a replacement blade makes sense. Warning!!! Drive By Gloat ahead!!! I have a similar situation with a Sweethart vintage #62 bevel up jack that I don't want to sharpen or lap the original blade so I'm looking at using an aftermarket blade. All I need is a "round tuit"