Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

Posts

Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#1

Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Friends, here is the next installment of my WIP. There are a couple of areas I could use some advice.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/Sideboard-Buildingtheframe.html

Looking forward to all and any comments and suggestions.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#2

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the f

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks for your continuing conversation about your work. I learn a lot from this kind of show and tell.

You asked about hinges. I am sentimentally attached to butt hinges, but your design calls for minimalist hinges, and butt hinges would not look quite right on it, I think. The knife/pivot hinges you pictured are one good solution. Soss hinges would be another, even more minimalist solution, but probably hard to fit to those curved doors - and they are more limiting in how the hinge stile meets the cabinet.

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#3

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the f

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Why didn't you let the rails cover the ends of the stiles? I can't imagine how bad the end grain will look exposed given the smoothness and beauty of your cabinets.

Pam

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#4

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the f

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

It is an interesting idea - may have advantages when installing the Brusso knife hinges.

However ...

1. Having the rail on top of the stile will emphasize the horizontal and make the doors appear squat.

2. The end grain will not be seen when the doors are closed.

3. One way or other there will be end grain showing (unless I mitred the corners, which would make it difficult to mortice-and-tenon).

Have I understood you? What did you have in mind with your suggestion?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#5

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the f *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I think that you probably should miter the corners. In my late night perusing I forgot that it was an entertainment center, thus tall. How tall? You make some very good points; but you're building a fine cabinet on which I think the nasty construction details shouldn't show. Of course, this is made more difficult since you've already built your rails.

If you miter, you can still do mortise & tenon, let me run off and provide a sample joint. Back later.

Pam

Found one example fairly quickly; but this doesn't solve the end grain problem, please follow the link. I'll look around some more.

OK, here's a drawing of a mitered blind M&T:




Mitered M&T

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#6

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the f

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think that you probably should miter the corners. In my late night perusing I forgot that it was an entertainment center, thus tall. How tall?

Hi Pam

Thanks for your input. This is very much welcomed.

I like your idea of a mitered corners. In fact I am prepared to make another (I think I only need one) new rail to accommodate the mitred corners. My only concern is whether it will be strong enough. Are mitred corners, with the reduced mortice area, as strong as traditional, squared m+t joints?

For reference, the units are (in total) 700mm (approx 27 1/2") high, including the feet (about 50mm/2" high) and the top (about 20mm/ 3/4" thick). That leaves doors 660mm/26" high.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#7

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the f

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Aha, a fairly short entertainment center (we usually have 6' tall centers sold here, aside from those hyperbole sellers who manage to call even the most basic shelf an "entertainment center"); so the users will definitely look down on the cabinet door tops, which makes a clean look all the more important.

I don't think you'll have any strength problems as long as you build the mortise & tenon as pictured. Also, there's all that glue surface within the miter itself. That's as long as your kids don't swing or jump on the doors. :)

Pam

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#8

Problems with mitred doors?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I Googled reviews of opinions about mitred doors on the internet with a view to strength, but came up with several comments that questioned their durability. Here is a sample:

We don't build doors with mitered construction & we don't recommend them to anyone. While they are aesthetically pleasing and unique, they are not the best built doors. Wood expands & contracts width wise based on the levels of humidity. Like the mitered joints on the door casings in your house, the miters will eventually open up & its to be expected & is accepted within the industry.

It would be good to get the opinion of others here.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#9

Re: Problems with mitred doors?

Bob Hackett

The only mitered joints that seem to hold long term up here where the humidity runs the wood from less than 5% during the winter heating season to over 13% during the summer months are splined miters.

One cabinet maker I know pinned both sides as well as using epoxy on the splines.He found the pins only added peace of mind and a decorative touch.

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#10

Chris Scholz

Try this tired and true method

Chris Scholz


Developed two thousand years ago, know to last a hundred years.

Chris

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#11

Re: Problems with mitred doors?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

First, some people can be talking about cope & stick mitered doors, which are notoriously weak; so probably a good idea to differentiate up front. I don't recommend cope & stick for anything.

Second, I agree with Chris Scholz. The difference between his drawing and mine is that mine is blind. Chris's would be much stronger, especially if the tenon is on the rail and the stile is mortised.

Third, I have mitered corners that have lasted for nine years with a lot of less-than-gentle door banging and the like in a non-HVAC space with humidity fluctuations.

Pam

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#12

Re: Problems with mitred doors?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Oh my aching head! :)

Pam, you and Chris have given me a headache! I happen to agree that the mitred corners would look better, but oh .. much more work. I will have to make another top rail, then the curved rail mitred into a straight mitred rail is going to be interesting. But I will give it a go this weekend.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#13

Re: Problems with mitred doors?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The angles will be a lot easier to make if you draw them life size and do the layout on the drawings. I had to make a few tenons angled at other than 90� in some rocking chairs I made a few years ago (not mitered, btw) and used this approach. Took a complicated layout and made it easy.

Pam

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#14

Re: Problems with mitred doors?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I was in the workshop today and had a rethink of using mitres. Faced with the actual pieces and construction it was clear to me that a mitred construction would end up looking strange when the face frames are added into the equation. So I am proceding with the original plan. More later.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sideboard-Entertainment Centre: Building the frame

#15

Featured details

Bob Hackett

Back when I used to build yachts we used to incorporate details and surprises into the work just so picky customers wouldn`t be disappointed.

The underside or backs of drawers would have small cartoons or stick figures that would be standing there with hands on hips and the bubble above would say"What you lookin` for?" or something similar.

I made most of the polished metalwork and deck hardware and my favorite was a simple stamped or engraved "GOTCHA!" on a polished surface that one would have to go to great lengths to view(like standing on your head).

Take some of your scrap brass plate and make a small plaque,then inlay the brass into the endgrain after you put your message on it.When people ask you can explain it`s history as this apparently goes back at least a century judging from the wooden boats we`ve restored.

Now that I think of it you could also use the brass to make a reinforcing plate to cover the endgrain,strengthen the connection of both the wood pieces and the hinge mounting on one end and then,with the addition of a slight curl on the outside edge of an overwidth piece on the far end,that plate can serve as a minimal door pull.The hinges are already brass so the pull would match perfectly.