Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

Posts

Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#1

Ellis Walentine

Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

Ellis Walentine

Joanne Adler and I dropped by Frank Klausz's shop yesterday afternoon for the tail end of the two-day Lie-Nielsen road show event. It's always a pleasure to see what Frank has going on. He, Chuck Bender of The Acanthus Workshop in Pottstown, PA, and Geoffrey (Adjust-A-Bench) Noden were there demonstrating various fine woodworking techniques, while Deneb Puchalski and the rest of the Lie-Nielsen staff demonstrated the entire range of L-N tools and accessories.

Here's Deneb checking out Frank's dovetail cutting techniques:


Here's Chuck working on the carved back splat for a period chair he's making. I liked the vise mounted carving platform he's devised...


After weighing all her options for a plane to fit the gap between her #3 and #7, Joanne was stuck on the decision between the bevel-down #5 1/2 and the bevel-up #62. After checking the heft and the cost of these two options, she went for the #62. I think she liked the idea of changing pitch just by changing blades.

I was sorry Tom Lie-Nielsen himself didn't make the trip to New Jersey, but it was good to see Frank and the rest of my craftsman pals there. From all accounts, the event was a rousing success for LieNielsen & Co.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#2

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

Dominic in Buck's County PA

HI Ellis,

I must have just missed seeing you! I had some of that spring steel with me and I was cutting it up and handing it out. Oh well, there's always the US mail!

My brother and I were there about 10:00-10:30am until some time after lunch. I wanted my brother to see some of the high end tools and get an appreciation for how well a tuned plane (other than mine!) would work. After watching Frank cut dovetails, he's got his eye on a LN Dovetail saw. So I'd say "mission accomplished"!

And I finally broke down and bought a Titemark Marking Gauge.

See ya,

Dominic

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#3

I like that exotic hammer Frank Klausz is using

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A good reminder that tools don't have to be made of unobtainium or engineered to be exotic to get the job done.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#4

Re: I like that exotic hammer Frank Klausz is usin

Bruce, a MN Galoot

He's so proficient at DT's that he makes it look like he could turn them out with a cold chisel and a 2 lb hammer.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#5

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

wilbur

Hi Ellis,

I must have just missed you, too. I was there with my two boys, who were remarkably well behaved even though I'm sure that they were there longer than they wanted to be. They wanted to come, and I did warn them that I was going to be there for a while, though. We left about 2 PM to get some lunch.

It was a lot of fun. I had wanted to see how the 50� and 55� frogs would work with a #4/#4-1/2 on more highly figured woods. I knew from past Lie-Nielsen events that they would probably have some curly maple to try planes on. I brought a nasty piece of interlocked Santos mahogany that I couldn't do anything with.

As I was going to give the high angle frogs a try, Frank Klausz came over and started working on it. He couldn't get anywhere with a #4-1/2 with a 55� frog. Then he tried a scraper plane. Then he tried a card scraper. Finally, he went in the back and put it through a sander, and finished it with some shellac. He gave it back to me and said, "Beautiful piece of wood. Don't make furniture with it." So I have the piece of wood that Frank Klausz couldn't plane. ;)

My older boy had a good time trying out the tools, as well. Here he is with Matt Kenney from Fine Woodworking having better success with his drawer grooving plane than Frank Klausz did.


And here Chuck Bender is showing him how to shape a ball and claw foot. If Chuck ever uses that on a piece of furniture and sells it, I am so busting him for violating child labor laws. ;)


It was also great to see Matt Bickford as well. He was busy enough that my boy didn't get a chance to try his planes. Which is just as well, since they were close to nuclear meltdown status by then.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#6

Ellis Walentine

Sorry I missed you, Wilbur

Ellis Walentine

I got there just before you left, but you were so busy talking with someone that Joanne and I walked on by and went to say hello to Mr. Frank. By the time he had regaled us with his latest tales, you had left. Next time, I'll interrupt you. :)

Great story about that piece of wood.

Ellis

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#7

It looks to me like you're corrupting your sons

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

the right way!

Warning: soon, if not already, you're going to be competing with your sons for shop space and time. It's well worth it, though.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#8

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

David Weaver

Wow...a piece of wood that plugged up FK with a 55 degree frog.

I'd love to get a shot at it with a couple of my planes.

Of course, Odate's book says to just put a back bevel on the iron of a kanna, and at some point you could get to an angle steep enough that you wouldn't need a plane with a .002" mouth to get away without tearing it out.

I haven't run into wood that will defy something along the lines of Brese's 55 degree planes with a really tight mouth, but I really don't have anything that difficult (rank curly maple and knotty/crotchy walnut is the worst I have on hand).

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#9

Ellis Walentine

Try ipe sometime

Ellis Walentine

You're lucky to get through that stuff with carbide-tipped cutters. I've never dared to try using hand planes on it, regardless of angle or type of steel. They'd dull in a heartbeat.

Some woods just aren't worth the effort.

Ellis

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#10

Re: Try ipe sometime

David Weaver

3680 on the relative hardness scale for IPE. All of my infills (except for a shepherd, which wouldn't get off the starting line with a figured wood, anyway, at 45 degrees) are HCS. It'd probably be dull in 10 strokes.

Santos mahogany is soft enough to work with hand tools, though not soft compared to most stuff people work a lot with hand tools. The santos mahogany that I've seen locally has all been straight small stuff, so I doubt it's in the class with ipe.

Cocobolo that hobbles my bench planes goes through the 55 degree infills without much fanfare (unless fanfare includes sharpening, there's plenty of that), but I've never thicknessed much of it by hand (nothing larger than a plane tote blank) - usually resaw it and then go from there.

I'd still love to take a shot at wilbur's board. :b

But IPE....no thanks :)

Btw...am I reading it right that the janka hardness chart all over the internet lists cocobolo as softer than yellow birch, ash, etc?

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#11

Re: Try ipe sometime

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

You're lucky to get through that stuff with carbide-tipped cutters. I've never dared to try using hand planes on it, regardless of angle or type of steel. They'd dull in a heartbeat.

Some woods just aren't worth the effort.

Hi Ellis

I was running a workshop on dovetailing this past weekend. Some of the guys brought along boards of their own to use (which they did not use as I had them all work with pine). We were chatting beforehand, and one handed me a rough sawn board. It was only about a foot long by about 6" wide and 1/2" thick but it weighed a ton. I was asked to plane it down. I missed the smirk on his face. Anyway I pulled out a plane with a 60 degree cutting angle and a CPM 3V blade and planed away. I really didn't think too much about the planing as the blade kept cutting and the shaving kept coming, and eventually the face was smooth and shiny. The eyes of this fellow kept getting bigger and bigger .. which I finally noticed, and I asked what the big deal was. Well it turned out that the board was Wandoo (Wandoo Eucalyptus), and when I heard this, my eyes opened wide as well.

Wandoo is one of thise superhard woods, in the same range as Ipe, with a similar Janka rating. It is sometimes used for flooring ... if you can get anyone to agree to lay it! It cannot be nailed without predrilling, and sanding wears out belts before the wood.

Something to be said for CPM 3V steel!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#12

Re: Try ipe sometime

David Weaver

Derek - are you going to tell the wondering public what plane comes in a 60 degree angle and a CPM 3V iron?

Is this the small brese kit with a transplanted iron?

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#15

So Dr. Derek it's not the No.3...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

You brought back to life. So are we to see something new from the lab?

Well, Derek Von Frankin Plane!?!

Scott, Yes, I have no patience.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#17

Ellis Walentine

I must try some wandoo

Ellis Walentine

Maybe we can have a "gnarliest woods" contest or some such. Ipe and wandoo sound like a match made in heaven.

Ellis

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#18

scott grandstaff

Re: Try ipe sometime

scott grandstaff

Oh bummer

I just got a bunch of it!! For free!

Some planks some scraps and a couple of 8' 4X4's.

yours Scott

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#19

Re: Try ipe sometime

wilbur

I once sawed through a scrap of ipe decking with a disposable blade Japanese saw. I made it through, and the cut was really straight and clean, but I had to trash the blade afterwards. The blade was on its last legs anyway.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#20

Re: Try ipe sometime

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

It surfaces well with hand planes, just try to cut through it :\

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#21

The mind boggles

Neal in San Jose

I just searched for Wandoo on woodfinder, and one of the two U.S. suppliers that popped up says they have birdseye Wandoo. If birdseye Wandoo is to normal Wandoo as birdseye Maple is to maple, I'm guessing my planes would sue for divorce if I bought any!

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#22

Chris Scholz

now we are talking...

Chris Scholz

...huang huali (yellow flowery pear wood), jichi mu (chicken wing wood, i.e. rosewood with the texture of chicken feathers), tieli mu (iron wood), zitan (zitan), standard repertoire of Asian woodworkers since the 15th century. Interlocking joinery, no glue; suppose cutting dovetails in ipe will be a warm-up exercise?

Went to the Trammell-Crow a few month ago where the had a special exhibit on jade carving (semi-precious stone that looks like soapstone but is extremely hard). Turns out there is not much carving carving going on but grinding; it took a craftsmen about 20 years to finish a medium-size vessel. In this context ipe must feel like butter.

Why don't we see more of Yeung Chan's work?

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#23

Re: The mind boggles

David Weaver

It's probably so dense that the bird's eyes don't make much of a difference with a steep angle of attack.

Cocobolo with small knots is like that, and cocobolo is almost as hard as wandoo. The grain around the small knots is so tight that you dread planing around them, but find that you can't really feel them with a decent heavy plane.

Re: Went to the L-N event at Frank Klausz's shop

#24

Re: It may be the #3 or it may not be the #3 ... :

Ian Neuhaus (in Sydney, Australia)

Does this mean you've found a board your Marcou can't handle??