We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I picked up 3 saws at a demolition site. All Diston, but only one has an etching. I've tried the steel wool and emery paper to clean up, but it's labourious.
As these saws are really of little value, can I, should I sand blast to clean up?
They will be used as work tools thereafter. My boss wants me to use a chain saw, but it always breaks, runs out of gas etc, in the middle of nowhere, and I'm running out of space in the sidecar for tools.
The only abrasive blasting I would do on something like these would be along the lines of walnut shells or something else that will attack the rust but not the steel.
Sand blasting or even glass beading will leave a toothed surface that will stain easily and collect things like pitch and sap faster than a surface that has been sanded in line with the blade.I speak from experience on this.
My advice is to leave the blasted surfaces for paint.
What I have done for work saws(like those we used for dock work over salt water)is too take either a straight line sander(like those used for auto body work) or in extreme cases a belt sander to the areas above the teeth.Look at a decent new saw and you can pretty well tell what grit you should start with.Where you go from there is up to you.
Just be aware that a thin saw blade will heat up quickly if you don`t keep the sander moving and/or cool the steel with air or water.
The original saws had a temper both sides of the saw, sandblasting removes the surface layer that destroys the temper. If you lose this temper, the saw blade bends when it binds and keeps the bend, making it far less useful than it otherwise could have been.
To see if the temper's already been destroyed, try and put the tip of the saw through the handle (ie: bend the saw tip back onto the heel.) Carefully let it go back to original shape (don't let it whip back - careful of accidental springback/saw blade snapping if you do this.)
The emery cloth and kerosene route is the safest way to go. You'll keep a quality saw, even if it is more work.
I haven't tried it on saws yet, but I've just started experiment with vinegar, and have been most impressed. Soaking for 24 hours or so followed by 3-4 minutes of moderately vigorous brass-wire-brushing cleaned up a block plane that would have taken me a good hour or more otherwise.
Not sure what container would accept a sawblade. You might have to knock up a shallow wooden tray and line with with sheet plastic.
Good on you not just for looking for hand tool solutions but for using a sidecar as your work truck.
I recommend using Mineral Spirits and the black 3M sandpaper. I get it at WalWart. Kerosene is really stinky stuff and will smell up everything it's near and won't go away for days.
The 3M sandpaper cuts good and clears itself pretty well, especially when used with Mineral Spirits.
For your purposes, you only need to get the rust off to the extent that the surface is smooth to the touch. Sand lengthwise, with the grain. Should take more than 30 minutes to get a blade smooth enough. Don't sand the sides of the teeth. It only makes it more difficult to sharpen.
Once the blade is clean, you'll then need to sharpen the teeth or the saw will be useless.
This has worked for me. Once you get the saw part way home, using any of the methods described in this thread, just use the saw. What I did with a rusty saw was get the rust off that's easiest to get, with mineral spirits and abrasive paper, then when I got sick of that (diminishing returns to effort) resawed about 3 feet down through a soft maple board about 8 inches wide. That much resawing left a smooth bright finish, even though closeup inspection still showed specks of corrosion on the blade. I figured, what the heck, from here all I need to do is saw.
This was a high quality Japanese saw which had been neglected, so was very good steel underneath, but so would the Disston's be.
You may be able to work the saw into shape by using it.
If they are sharp just use them, a little cosmetic issue won't matter on the jobsite. If they are dull, sharpen them - you would be surprised how quickly a rusted saw will clean itself up when used upon the wood it is made for.
I definitely wouldn't sand blast, but everybody already said that.
I have built up some skill with a single edged razor blade in a holder. It does take a little practice scraping off the rust and not scratching the steel too bad, but you will get it pretty quick.
One thing. Most people want to make their saws look like bright new metal any way they can. Seems to be the first thing anybody wants to do.
Chemical dips and electrozap, belt sanders, ..............anything at all to cut down to new metal.
Old saws that have never been used command the highest price because the steel is bright.
I used to think that it too.
I have done lots of rubbing with any number of abrasives and zapping and hey if you want to use acid, go for the gold.
6 or 12 minutes in warm 20% hydrochloric acid you can shave your face in it!
But I don't really aspire to raw steel anymore in an old saw.
I like a worn in patina. Good honest use but fine care I would value the most.
I want to scrape off active rust and try not to cut down into the bright steel so much.
Oil it up and you have a natural rust browning left behind that just looks genuine and classy. To me.
Plus you can maintain this.
Bright steel only lasts a short time even if you do get it bright.
Which in an old saw is not easy to do any way you go.
But it is easy to go for brown and keep it that way.
Screw the emery paper. Start with 100 grit paper with a sanding block. Lube if you want. Once the rust is gone move on to a finer grit. Sooner or later you'll have what you want. Leave it at that...
You have described pretty much what I do with most old rusted saw blades. I think I've seen a tutorial you did a few years back on how to clean a saw blade. In fact I got some good pointers from that. I thought at the time, "hey, this guy knows what he's do'n".
As we know, not all rust is the same. Some will be very light that can easily be removed with just steelwool. On the other end of the sprectrum the rust can be very dense and hard and well into the metal. This is the stuff that requires scraping. I use a box scraper blade that you can buy a plastic holder for, designed to hold a box scraper blade. The blades are wider, thicker and don't flex like a razor blade. You can use them similar to a scraper you use for wood. I find that on most hard rust, I can scrape about 75 percent of the rust off before going to the sandpaper. I use Mineral spirits even when scraping. It helps to lubricate just a bit and reduces the chance of scratching into bare bright metal.
Just as you do, I often times settle for a brownish surface and don't try to get the saw bright. Most of the time, the brownish surface can be shiney to some extent and also be waxed. When waxed, the saw will cut just as well as if it was shiney bright metal.
If a saw is just sharpened and not remove the rust, it will not cut smoothly because the rust will not slide through the kerf easily, however, a heavy set in the teeth will produce a wider kerf that will allow the rusty blade to slide without binding, but, a wide kerf usually will produce a rough cut. It depends on what the saw is used for. For rough framing type sawing, it doesn't matter much, but for finish work, a smoother, more accurate sawed surface is desired.
White distilled vinegar will remove most rust, but not the really thick hard stuff. When vinegar does remove all the rust, it leaves a dull matt finish. All acid type rust removers do this. Even Evapo-Rust which is not an acid, will leave that dull finish. I prefer the kind of finish that Mineral Spirits and sandpaper produces. I rarely use a higher grit than 600.
The reason I prefer Mineral Spirits over other solutions is because the viscosity is like water and helps clear the sandpaper better than oiliy type lubricants. It's easy on the hands. The smell doesn't linger for hours and hours or even days like kerosene does for example.
I have derusted hundreds of old saw blades. I've tried most of the methods mentioned and I always come back to the scraper, sandpaper and Mineral Spirits method. It's pretty much a personal preference. Different strokes kinda deal, I guess.
So, Justin, to what extent you clean your saws, depends mostly on what you want to use them for. If you will be replacing your chainsaw, probably all you need to do is file the teeth and set the teeth for a wide kerf. However, if you want a smooth cutting saw, you'll want the blade to be smooth enough so you can wax it and use minimum set, just enough to prevent binding.
I've heard a LOT of exotic and creative schemes to clean rust off. Most were not for the accident prone such as myself. I've cleaned and polished my share of rust and use most of them. If the rust is obscuring the etch the etch is probably a gonner anyway. I start with 100 grit and if I keep at it untill I get to 220 I start feeling anal about the whole thing (and my hair starts to hurt). And it doesn't take all that long 'till you've got a fairly good look'n result (let alone useable). I'm sure I'll be over ruled by the esteemed board, but I don't think there are really all that many saws that will be a loss to posterity for cleaning and using them. Don't go overboard about a saw. Clean 'er up and put 'er to work. Then get another to work on. Remember : the more saws we have the better look'n and smarter we get !