Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Traditional Japanese saw handles

Posts

Traditional Japanese saw handles

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Traditional Japanese saw handles

Jack Guzman from Maine

I was looking for a slightly better than cheap flush cut saw at Rockler. They were out of the dedicated flush cut saw but for about $30 they had a Japanese saw kit with two blades. One flush cut,one dozuki. I bought it and set it up with the flush cut blade. Now,what to do with the dozuki blade.

I cut a piece of fir to length,sliced 1/4" off one edge,grooved the fat part for my blade,then glued the slice back on. I don't like that mickey mouse looking set screw (something about a bamboo handle and a white plastic knurled screw head don't match)so I drilled a hole where the notch in the blade is and inserted a hickory peg. Then I shaped the handle and wrapped it in rattan(what I had on hand).Looks great,works fine,I'm happy. Now for my questions.

I notice people talking about high quality,expertly fashioned Japanese saws.Somehow I can't imagine these saws are held in their handles with a mickey mouse lookin set screw. So ,how are these done? What did traditional saw handles consist of and how were they attached? Is it still done the same way?

thanks---Jack

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#2

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Don't know that much tradition except for maebiki; but quality Japanese saws typically have pointed handle ends, made of a different material than the saw body and forge welded onto the saw body. The handles are made of paulownia or kiri, very light weight wood, and have recesses for the blade. Then they're wrapped with string or rattan. Here's an example from the Hida site:


Pam

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#3

let me ask you this...

Bob Hackett

Are you just curious or looking for history and/or a departure point?

Maybe I`m the exception to the rule but whenever I step off into some type of tool or handle project I try to stay away from what the accepted "normal" or traditional approach was and focus on what it is I want the tool or handle to do for me and how I plan to approach the work.

Once I have a prototype spun up that is acceptable for my use I may research other alternatives so I can use what I came up with and what is traditionally used as departure points in order to refine things(in highly figured/flashy wood where appropriate :D ).

Thin line between limiting yourself by following tradition and yet still getting all the benefits of a time tested,proven design.

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

just curious

Jack Guzman from Maine

I just started wondering.I just couldn't imagine those screws being anything but a cheap modern shortcut. I'm more than happy with my solution but I thought higher end makers must have a better way.---Jack

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

Jack Guzman from Maine

That makes alot more sense. I guess those set screws on my saw were designed for easy blade replacement,as in throwaway blades.---Jack

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#6

Ellis Walentine

Replaceable vs dedicated blades

Ellis Walentine

As Pam has noted, the blades on traditional Japanese saws have dedicated handles. Over the past 20 years or so, several Japanese saw makers have ventured into handles like you describe, with replaceable blades, presumably to encourage people to just replace the blades when dull, as opposed to trying to sharpen them. Sharpening a Japanese saw is fussy work and requires better eyesight than I have at this stage of the game, so I'm all for buying a relatively inexpensive replacement blade rather than sharpening or attempting to sharpen a medium quality blade that might have impulse-hardened teeth and a host of other concessions to cost.

Ellis

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#7

Re: Replaceable vs dedicated blades

Paul M.

Most of the cheaper Japanese saw blades are stamped out by machine. They run the teeth very quickly through an induction hardening process after machine sharpening and setting the teeth which makes the teeth stay sharper longer but also make them almost impossible to resharpen later. They are intended to be disposable, hence the removable handles.

I got to see this process when I was in Japan several years ago. It was all highly automated and completely separate from the higher end saws that were created more manually.

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Replaceable vs dedicated blades

Jack Guzman from Maine

Ellis,what you say makes total sense but I still think that set screw is ugly.I mean ,if they're going to go through the trouble of making the blade replaceable,the least they could do is make the handle look half decent. They do expect you to keep it. I think I'll try to find a better looking replacement screw for the saw I have that still has it's set screw. Or maybe drill out the threads and put in a peg.---Jack

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#9

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Jack,

As Pam showed, there is no set screw. It's a friction fit of the long tang. The handle stocks are done as you did--they're ripped lengthwise in two, slightly offcenter, grooved offcenter with the saw tang going into the fat half, reglued and wrapped with rattan or string, although Joel used to have one that was sharkskin wrapped.

The set screw helps blade replacement, as Ellis said, but also it is needed for tight fit because of the short insertion of the replaceable blade saws.

The traditional method starts with the groove a bit undersized. Final fitting is done after glueup, sometimes by a keyhole saw down the groove to widen it slightly. The most advanced users I know of do the final fit by 'burning in', heating the tang glowing hot (with a wet towel to heat sink and protect the hardened blade), and then insert the hot tang into the handle groove. After the smoke clears, you have a perfectly tight fit, plus a burned-in fit is not going to make the blade deflect. It's possible to make a large saw take a slight crimp (not permanent) if it is forced into the handle (don't ask me how I know that).

Wiley

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#10

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Hard to say, but I suspect that today they serve to pin the rattan wrapping.

Pam

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#11

Ellis Walentine

They call that...

Ellis Walentine

... a design opportunity. By all means do something wonderful to customize your saw and make it more user friendly. How about a little ebony knob instead of the plastic one?

Go for it. Show us the results.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#12

Re: They call that...

ThomD

With replaceable blade saws there are also friction fits, that lever into place. That guy in Seattle used to sell them.

In a few instances I have made my own handles to save money. I have secured the stub tenon into a slot in the saw handle with epoxy. in one case I wrapped it with rattan, but more recently I tend to just leave them as wooden handles. In fact, the guy in Seattle sells the hardware so one can fix them in handles and retain the blade demount feature.

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#13

Re: let me ask you this...

bugbear

Thin line between limiting yourself by following tradition and yet still getting all the benefits of a time tested,proven design.

Ain't that the truth. Too many people who proudly "think outside the box" proudly ignore the hard earned knowledge of the past.

The trick is to leverage old knowledge, possibly in new ways or combinations.

Ignoring it is just dumb.

BugBear

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#14

Saving the box

Bob Hackett

They say that ignorance is bliss.I like to start off as blissfully unaware of what went before as possible.

Traditional can also mean what was easiest to manufacture or what was designed to fit most of the masses.The closer you get to present day offerings the more you lose those small nuances that can make all the difference.

Once you have put the "box" out of sight and attempted to erase that picture of it from your mind then you can begin to formulate an unbiased picture of what is truly the best approach for YOU.

Once the YOU prototype is done you can then go WAY back and do some research from the time when tools were made to be used all day every day and the ergonomics were not influenced by price.

As an example,The most comfortable totes for planes are not the ones we see on Stanley iron planes although that`s what most try to copy.You have to look back a ways before Stanley and at early wood planes to get those type of totes that were a joy to hold. It`s no surprise that C&W chose to use them rather than a Stanley clone on their planes.

Leverage,that`s a very appropriate word.Thanks for that,Bugbear.

MB

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#15

Re: let me ask you this...

Marv

In general terms, nothing wrong with thinking outside the proverbial box. It's called progress. It's called innovation. It's called individualism. Think LV tools as just one example.

We can appreciate and respect tradition while at the same time use our own knowledge and skills to express individual ideas and invention.

Just because it's old doesn't mean it is better.

If we had allowed ourselves to remain cooped up in that box, we would still be living in the dark ages.

Having said that, looking around the world today, perhaps the human species would be better off if time measurement had never been invented. Same goes for the wheel. The oil mess in the Gulf comes to mind. Talk about "stupid".

Marv

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#16

The trick is balance, of course

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of the VPs at my old university used to say, "And that will be a change; and change is good." I managed never to scream at him, "NO! It will be a change; and whether it's good or bad depends on what it does."

The old isn't necessarily better; the new isn't necessarily better. When Lee Valley's designs succeed, they do so because the designers have rethought how to solve the problems the old tools were meant to solve, while learning from the solutions those old tools embody. There's a reason that Rob Lee has a warehouse full of old tools, and it's not just because he's a fool for rust (though gathering that stuff to have a "DNA bank" of the old tools for design and development has got to be the finest way ever of using tax writeoffs to support an old tool addiction).

The old stuff has, generally, come up with one or several solutions to a problem. Doesn't make these solutions the only ones; but the decent old tools generally do offer solutions that work.

I briefly owned a scribing tool that was billed as The Solution for cabinet and similar scribing. Didn't work worth a darn because the designers had failed to take some critical elements into account. I went back to my old General Tools cheapie, still one of the best scribing-to-fit tools ever, which, although it requires some acquired skill to use, solves the essential problems quite well.

All of which is a longer babbly way of saying what BugBear said more elegantly. Time to shut up and go back to marking out window parts, using some old tools.

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#17

Ellis Walentine

Re: They call that...

Ellis Walentine

Wasn't that Tashiro's? The saw brand was Zeta, as I recall.

Ellis

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#18

Re: They call that...

Thomd

Bingo! Nice guy, based on the one visit I had.

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#19

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

The two saws I bought from Yataiki came with the handles separated from the blades. I don't remember if I asked how to secure the saws in their handle, but what I did was to insert the blades into the handles, then firmly tap the butt of the handle on the workbench. The blades sunk right in after a few strokes.

Now, I don't use the saws very often, my schedule has taken me off woodworking recently, but the saws have given no indication that the blade is coming off the handle. I guess that the soft wood handles compress enough to let the blade in yet hold it in place afterwards.

DC

Re: Traditional Japanese saw handles

#20

Leo Cuellar

AMEN!

Leo Cuellar