Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Abrasive choice

Posts

Abrasive choice

#1

Abrasive choice

Patrick Gibbons

I remember reading on this forum some time ago that there was a better choice of sandpaper for the lower grits than silicone carbide to use for scary sharp flattening. Was it aluminum oxide?

Re: Abrasive choice

#2

Re: Abrasive choice

wilbur

I don't use scary sharp, but I do use 80 grit Norton 3X sandpaper on a granite plate if I want to remove metal in a hurry. Norton 3X is made with aluminum oxide abrasive.

Re: Abrasive choice

#3

Re: Abrasive choice

Duane Mohney

I use AO through 320 and the SC to 2000 for scary sharp, mainly because I can get PSA rolls upto 320 in AO for a decent price.

Re: Abrasive choice

#4

What I want to do is

Patrick Gibbons

flatten the backs of some chisels that are dubbed over. My diamond stone is taking too long and I want to be done with it. The SO was equally slow and needed to be replaced a lot. I thought it was AO that was better at taking off a lot of metal fast but I wasn't sure. Please correct me if this is not the best bet.

Re: Abrasive choice

#5

Re: What I want to do is

Duane Mohney

Depending on how bad the back is out of flat, I'll start as low as 80grint and work through a progression to 2000. Typically I do 80, 100, 180, 220, 320, 600, 1000, 1200, 2000.

It is said that you only need to do the last little bit of the blade, but I just can't balance much less than 3/4" and so that's what I flatten on the back of my blades

Re: Abrasive choice

#6

Re: What I want to do is

Bob Hackett

If I was doing what you propose I would start with either AO or SC for the larger grits and then go to SC for the mid to fine and end with either green honing compound or 1/2 micron diamond on an appropriate substrate.

The differences are AO is a good all around abrasive in the larger grits but it is not as durable as the SC and will begin to break down and dull faster.Likewise SC is not as durable as diamond so it will break down faster in the very fine grits.

If your diamond stone has lost it`s bite then you can still use it as a substrate with a recharge of the appropriate diamond paste.

I won`t go into it here but there is a big difference in the lifespan of diamond hones/stones that are made from polycrystaline and monocrystaline diamonds.

That life span is usually reflected in the price.

Re: Abrasive choice

#7

Re: Abrasive choice

Ron Hock

Silicone carbide (SC) is harder and sharper than aluminum oxide (AO) but it is more friable -- it crushes more easily. This is why wet-or-dry sandpaper wears out so fast when sharpening (and why refinishers and the auto painters use so much of it -- it performs well on softer materials.) Aluminum oxide is not as sharp or hard but it is much tougher and harder to crush so it lasts longer under pressure.

AO is the abrasive of choice for most sharpening systems. Most grinding wheels and waterstones use AO as their abrasive. Of course it's not that simple. There are eight or so different AO crystal forms, each with different mechanical properties. And which gets used where are trade secrets.

For me, if the decision is between SC and AO, I'll choose AO every time. I used to use wet-or-dry paper for sharpening but got tired of going through so many sheets. Then I discovered lapping, or honing, films. Neither sand nor paper, these Mylar-backed sheets are amazing. The AO grits are highly uniform and dense, the bonding remarkably durable. The longevity is impressive. I like the PSA, self sticking varieties but they don't remove easily and require some considerable stickum removal when replacing sheets*. I have two pieces of glass, sized to fit the sheets. One has 80-micron (approx 180-grit) on one side, 15-micron (700-grit?) on the other. The other piece of glass has 5-micron (2500-grit?) and 1-micron (8000-grit?). Not being a woodworker, I don't have a dedicated sharpening station to keep the stones, pond, supplies and attendant mess. So when I do sharpen, I often just grab the glass plates at get to it. If I had said sharpening station, I'd keep waterstones wet and handy but until then...

Search for lapping film or honing film when shopping. It's becoming readily available. It may seem pricey but it lasts very well.

*I want someone to apply a less sticky backing to the honing films. I want abrasive Post-Its, I guess. If you know of such a thing, let us know where you found it.

Keep 'em sharp!

Ron

Re: Abrasive choice

#8

Thanks, Ron

Neal in San Jose

If SC were a good abrasive for the purpose of working hardened steel, the manufacturers of grinding wheels would use it in their products. They don't. The makers of man-made sharpening stones would use it. They don't either. SC paper is in the paint store for a reason.

If you want to prove to yourself which is better, try this simple experiment (which I think you showed me, Ron): Take a piece of SC paper - maybe around 400 grit - and using your normal method, polish the back of an iron. Work in the same place on the paper for a minute or two or until the iron is very polished. Shiney, huh? Now move to an unused portion of the paper and make ONE pass. Look at it carefully (a small magnifier would help) and you will see scratches.

What happened is that the SC broke down very quickly and turned your 400 paper into very fine paper - 2000, 10,000 grit, who knows - and stopped cutting and began polishing. When you moved to the unused paper for one pass, it hadn't broken down and was cutting at the original size again.

Now repeat with AO paper, and you will see that the plane iron never gets shiney with 400 grit because it continues to cut as 400 grit. It turns sorta grey with a uniform scratch pattern, and moving to a new piece of paper doesn't change the results much.

When you want to prepare a blade for the next grit, you need a grit that keeps cutting at it's orginal size until YOU decide to go to a smaller grit.

Re: Abrasive choice

#9

Credit where it's due...

Ron Hock

That demonstration is from Don Naples of Wood Artistry, makers of the Lap Sharp System. Don knows more about abrasives than anyone else that I interviewed while I was doing the research for my book (The Perfect Edge, in case that fact has somehow eluded anyone.)

I thought I knew a lot about abrasives when I started doing my research. Ha! The more I learned the more there was to learn and the harder it became to learn it. The abrasives industry is very close-mouthed about their technologies. The Unified Abrasives Manufacturers' Association's website is very helpful but the detail may make you woozy: www.uama.org. And, of course, I did my best to summarize it all in my Really Great Book.

BTW, natural oilstones have been under much discussion lately so I thought I'd mention that they are mined novaculite, a recrystallized form of chert, one of the many forms silicon dioxide takes including sand, flint and quartz. SiO2 is softer than either AO or SC but it's held very tightly in its novaculite matrix so the stones tend to hold their shape well, even as the particles get dull. Natural Japanese waterstones contain SiO2 particles suspended in a clay matrix by sedimentation (as opposed to the novaculite's crystalline structure.)

It's a complex, abrasive world. Good luck!

Ron

Re: Abrasive choice

#10

Dumb question: whatever happened to emery paper?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Back in jr. high shop class, I was taught that emery paper was what you used on metal. Of course, we were also taught about flint paper. I guess I should just be glad that it was after the development of paper and the right glues for abrasives; I'd hate to have had to go catch my own shark to get a good abrasive sheet.

Anyway, where does emery paper stand in all this? Was it made obsolete by the improvement of aluminum oxide and silicone carbide papers?

Re: Abrasive choice

#11

Blue zirconia belt 80

Alexandre Grigoriev

That's what I use. I spray-glue it to a granite plate.

Re: Abrasive choice

#12

Re: Thanks, Ron

David Weaver

I agree with this, but from a different principle. I don't use sandpaper to sharpen - at all. I used to use norton 3x to flatten backs, but I don't do that much now because I have no reason to. Loose diamonds do a better and faster job when you can apply the appropriate amount of pressre, without having to peel used paper away from anything. They also don't wear noticably faster with high alloy steel.

Anyway, where I get my thoughts from is lapping steel planes. Not cast iron planes, steel plane soles and sides.

I have a bargain box from klingspor - it has 60+ grit in al ox and silicon carbide. I can pull a piece of paper from a scrap roll in it and just completely waste it without caring.

With a plane sole, the keenness of the paper is immediately apparent, because you're moving a relatively large surface over the abrasive, as soon as it loses its aggression, it gets noticably easier to push the plane across it. You also see the dry filings from the plane building up the paper, and I sweep them forward off the end of my lap with a dust broom to see how many there are as they slip off the side onto the top of my woodworking bench (yes, I know, the horrors - I don't mix planemaking and woodworking and clean the bench when I finish with a plane).

In my experience - and we're talking about anecdotes - nothing holds up well to lapping with a lot of pressure, but it is very evident that Aluminum oxide keeps cutting at an acceptable level for a much longer period of time than silicone carbide. By acceptable level, I mean how it feels and how much swarf is produced. Once you don't see much swarf, you know it's time to stop.

Whether or not the same thing is true when you use a lot of pressure and a much smaller point of contact, I can't say, but I spent a lot of hours lapping rough plane sides and bottoms on silicon carbide when I thought it was the superior abrasive, and I won't do that again.

Re: Abrasive choice

#13

Re: Dumb question: whatever happened to emery pape

David Weaver

That's a good question that I'd like to see the answer to. I think emery has variable hardness since it's natural, and I think the hardness might be less than silicone carbide.

I see emery cloth and paper in rough grits every time I shop online looking for PSA backed rolls of sandpaper.

Re: Abrasive choice

#14

Re: Credit where it's due...

Neal in San Jose

I saw Don tonight. He was the presenter at the Bay Area Woodworkers on steam bending. He's giving a presentation on sharpening at the Japan Woodworker in Alameda on Sat. from 9 to 1. Very expensive. $10, and they have Pete's coffee! I think I'll go.

Re: Abrasive choice

#15

Re: Credit where it's due...

Ron Hock

Should easily be worth $10. Even without the coffee.

Have fun and say hi to Don for me!