Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

Posts

Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#1

Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

David Weaver

.. well, for the most part.


Not many details in pictures, just finally cleaned all of the metal off my bench and put a coat of oil on it.

The kit is a shepherd kit, and there are a few tiny details that I didn't finish, and don't plan to. You can spot them and call me out on them.

The kit itself had a lot of problems, I'm going to guess it's from near the end of shepherd's run. They are as follows:

* The mortise for the tote was not remotely the same size and shape as the tote itself. Given that it was rounded and not a similar curve profile, I couldn't believe it. The comment in the kit literature said that it would "take significant skill to fit the tote and mortise well, a challenge that doesn't exist in the smoother kits".

* The iron is soft. It isn't unusable, but it's disappointing given their literature talking about how long it will stay sharp I will probably, at some point, cut my own out of 3/16th stock and harden it. I would say it's comparable to a stanley sweetheart bench plane iron in hardness. I expected something in the 60 to 62 range, and it is not that.

* the holes for the crossbar for the lever cap are way too far forward - they are pre-done and you have no choice. The way the kit is designed and cut, you can't really move the rear infill forward - the mouth is already roughed in the bottom and the rear infill is roughly shaped to fit the profile. I had to pein a piece of O1 onto the chipbreaker to get the screw to reach, and even at that it is extended far back

* the metal for the sole was bowed

* the laser cuts on the side brass were not actually all to the same depth, they were concave, causing the sole to be very hollow in the center - when I filed the pins initially, I was sure that I was just seeing things as it was hard to measure accurately. This took eons to lap out, and indirectly sent me to the emergency room with metal in my eye as I used the slight barrel shape of the drum on the end of my belt sander to remove stock from the middle of the length of the sole. I've never had to go to that extreme before.

* the chipbreaker and iron are not centered properly - in order to even get the iron in the plane, the adjuster had to be installed tightly against one side of the slot (they cut the slot slightly larger than the adjuster), and even then, it's still not centered.

* while they are not centered properly, they are also not matched in terms of how far off they are. This results in the chipbreaker screw gripping literally one side of the iron when tight and floating on the other side. this is not optimal to say the least.

* The cocobolo infills had sides (significantly) out of square and were too narrow even before squaring for the infill. After squaring them very sparingly with a smoother by hand, I had to order cocobolo veneer and build them up quite a bit.

I think that covers it, but to put it plainly, this kit was a real turd, and a disappointment for what it cost me to get it. I had a LN 6 at one point, with cocobolo handles - my first premium plane. This kit made me wish I never sold it.

I contributed my own error to it - the bottom is the first time I used mild steel - I went right past my marking line when filing the mouth to final size, and it is about .009"-.01". I was hoping to start at half that. With common pitch and a stupidly shaped chipbreaker profile, you get tearout with it just like a common bench plane. The tearout isn't bad, but it requires follow up with a smoother. I know some of you guys are thinking "boo hoo". Yeah, i know, it's not a big deal, it requires no skill to work around minor tearout, but it's not what you shoot for making an infill (or at least i don't), and my smoother that I scratch built is nearly impossible to induce tearout (it is at a higher angle with a mouth about a third of the size of this one). Actually, both smoothers that i built are that way.

It does, however, plane with authority at just under 9 pounds (keep the wax handy, please). It's the first larger infill I've gotten (well, put together i guess) - you just sort of walk with it, there's no throwing it back and forth briskly.

It works acceptably well, and another coat of oil and a coat of wax and a tiny bit of cleanup on the front and rear metal and it'll be done for real.

Most of all, thank the lord above I'm done with it. I never thought I would be sitting in the ER in the middle of the city of pittsburgh with the late night loonies at midnight with a (fortunately very competent) resident picking metal off the surface of my eye right in the middle of the pupil with a needle.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#2

First Off CONGRATS!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I won't go near Shepard Planes. A lot of people got screwed and lot were somewhat dissatisfied at there expectations. Now don't get me wrong, but...

It's not I'd go near one, I'd actually like to put one together. The problem is that their not around much anymore. I was offered free assembly instructions etc... I couldn't make it to the show to participate.

Kinda glad I didn't. I stopped myself from ordering a 17" jointer. At $750.00 I consider myself lucky. Like I needed it anayway ;)

They disappeared after that.

David, Where were you about 5 years ago? :D

Excellent job, and thanks for a most excellent wright up on building your plane!

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#3

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I am not sure what is more remarkable, the end result or your perseverence!!! :)

The end result does indeed look excellent and, no, I cannot pick out items to criticise (woodworkers are always so self-critical!).

Perhaps the blade's softness is a blessing in disguise as it creates the reason to look for another. I would get or make one of a thickness to fill the mouth, just as you wanted all along. This should also sort out the lever cap/screw issue.

Finally, I think you have done a remarkable job on a crappy foundation. You have my admiration.

Now, have you tried the soapy water .... :D

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#5

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

wilbur

Hi David,

Given all the caveats with the kit, it's amazing that you got it into usable shape. There's an old saying that comes to mind about how it's not how well the pig can sing, it's that the pig can sing at all. I know I would have bailed on your project a long time ago.

Nice job!

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#6

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

David Weaver

Derek - I put some foaming handwash in a bottle last night and watered it down. That stuff doesn't slick like soap! It was all I had near the shop.

Tonight or tomorrow, I'll throw some dish soap into the bottle instead and see how it goes.

You're right about the chipbreaker slot being solved by another iron. I'll probably make one out of oversize 3/16th and make the slot narrow - there's no reason for it to be much wider than the diameter of the chipbreaker screw, and it's significantly wider, while the drum head of the screw is not (since it has to fit in the adjuster).

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#7

Re: First Off CONGRATS!

David Weaver

Scott - I only paid slightly less than that for this kit, and about that for this kit plus a chariot plane kit. Were I to make it from scratch, it would be otherwise similar but with a single 1/4" iron and bedded at 50 degrees.

This one's 18 inches. I think that's a nice length, so at least it has that going for it.

I can imagine that people who never built an infill before would be pretty dissatisfied with the kit when they tried to just follow instructions and put it together. I lapped 4 ounces of metal off of the sides and the bottom - that's just an unbelievable amount.

I put it aside when I first got it because while the instructions are long in words, they are not so clear. I think it might've been ruined or at least not turned out nearly as well if I wouldn't have built a couple of planes first. I tossed the instructions aside after the first step (cleaning out the corners of the pins and tails and widening them), and only needed them for that to figure out whether they instruced you to even up the depth of everything. It was clear from the instructions that they though you only needed to do the corners.

You were smart to stay away from the kits!

I have a st james bay kit to do next, and then two more to scratch build before I take a break. It'll be interesting to see how the st james bay smoother kit goes. It's got no wood with it, but it was 1/4th the price and the iron is hardened and left hard so you can temper it in the kitchen oven to whatever hardness you want.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#8

Thanks for the nice comments, guys.   

David Weaver

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#9

scott grandstaff

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

scott grandstaff

First off you did a beautiful job David!! It looks very nice from here.

Building any infill plane is no walk in the park. An entire set of separate skills is called into play and it is just not an easy job to build one. Nobody should have ever pretended it was easy, its not.

The Shepard guys were fairly reasonable in the price of their kits at the very beginning. Nobody expected it to be easy, and they weren't charging so much.

As time went on, the price climbed to way out past what a very tough to finish kit should have been (I thought).

They began telling people how easy they were. But not everyone has a large mill and a surface grinder, and a high degree skill with such machines, on hand.

Lapping 4 ounces of metal indeed!

I expect the placement of the lever cap hinge pin holes was probably because they changed blade parameters along the way and the kit you got had been put together from leftover parts at the end of the company run. The blade itself was probably pulled from the cull pile a dropped into the box at the last minute too.

Lever cap placement is very critical in an infill. Seemingly simple, because of the long looking cap screw, the placement actually has very little leeway.

The Shepard guys wanted too much too fast. Enough was never close to enough for those two. I tried to reason with them, even at the very beginning. Setting out goals no 20 man crew could fulfill, and adding more and more on top of that. The quality began to suffer because they had meetings and weekend seminars and sales promotion scheduled on top of running a tiny factory all week.

I was really surprised they lasted as long as they did. They had some serious determination, give them that.

I honestly think if they'd have slowed down a little and concentrated on details more and let the big picture unfold a bit slower, they would still be going very strongly right now.

Anyway, great job David. Glad you got it together.

OH PS, never reveal defects which nobody else will ever know, if you didn't volunteer it. :D

yours Scott

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#10

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

David Weaver

Scott - I think you're right about them still being around if they'd have settled for moderate growth or sustaining business and keeping their eye on the ball.

The kit itself was fairly well thought out. IF everything would've been done to the level of precision it could've without too much extra effort, it would've been a great kit. Who would complain about having most of the metal roughed out already for the pins and tails, and the sides cut? That's a major pain for someone without a milling machine. My standard operating procedure for that is to cut waste away from sides with a hacksaw in straight lines, and then literally take a coarse belt sander and grind down to the line. That takes time - a couple of hours for an entire plane. It's not that fun.

Anyway, the two most notable shortcomings of my finish work that I purposely left alone were ..actually, 3.

1) i initially finshed the insides of the cheeks. They are soft brass, and got dinged up a bit over the assembly process. I left them alone and did not retouch them.

2) I put no bevels on the sides, even though I think they are to be there. That could be done later, I skipped it. I feel somewhat obligated to do that at some point in the future, but the plane doesn't warrant it - it'll certainly never have a level of monetary value that justifies it.

3) I didn't touch the metal at all on the edges of the sides above the cheeks - if you look closely, you can see that there are still some milling marks on it. They aren't coarse marks. As easy as the brass scratches, I'm not that motivated to take a dowel and sandpaper and do that job - it'll be so tarnished in a couple of months that nobody will be able to tell anything, anwyay.

And one that you can't see - because of the amount of lapping that had to be done, the bottom is convex by a couple of thousandths - I haven't measured. I'd guess 3 or 4. I'll measure it sometime, just so I can relate in my head what it looks like against a starrett edge vs. a numerical value. In general, I've been able to lap planes that don't require too much work into an almost "no light between the sole and a starrett edge". The more work required in hand lapping the worse the results. For a skilled user, having a slightly convex sole is no issue, so I'm not going to trouble about it. I'm sure a lot of older planes are much more out of flat.

The picture really isn't good enough resolution to see a lot of that. I didn't want to upload a honking huge picture.

You're right that the skill set is different for building planes - it's more of a constant problem solving set, even when you build your own from scratch. There is also a little more finesse or "winging it" involved for some parts, and other parts go very slow. Fundamental understanding of what makes a plane work well helps you differentiate what standard you apply to each part of the process more or less intuitively.

Oh yeah, I blued the chipbreaker, too. I seem to have a habit of doing that the first time I clean any rust off a chipbreaker. I like the way it looks.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#11

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

Paul M.

I've worked on two Shepherd infill planes. Note that I say "worked" on as only one was completed.

My first attempt was a complete hash of their chariot plane. I guess I was peining too hard as I completely crushed this poor thing. I looked for my posting on it in the archives, but I can't seem to find it so I guess it didn't survive the latest software updates on WC. The title was "Am I the only ham-fisted moron?" which should tell you what you would expect to see in the photos. Maybe somebody better than I can find this in the archives.

The second one (years later and just before Shepherd imploded) occurred because of them making a road trip to San Diego. I figured if they were going to come out here to host a seminar in building these things with hands-on guidance then I have a chance. I made their large shoulder plane which turned out OK. But it hardly gets used. I prefer using my 92 or 93 because this beast is just too massive to use. I thought briefly about sending this to Catherine to pretty it up, but that's one of those "lipstick on a pig" type of things I don't prefer to do. So it sits in a drawer and doesn't get used very often.

I did learn exactly how much I hate metalwork. :( That was the best lesson I learned in this adventure.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#12

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

I gotta tell you, I'm truly impressed with what you have done with the plane kit. There are some good things--for example, the front bun is just a great job.

Just as a suggestion..... tackle the blade first. Those other items like the detailing on the metal edges, and lapping out the convexity--there's no motivation for doing those until the iron is right. But once you have a good iron and tighten up the mouth, then you're within distance of having a fine plane.

In fact, if it was my money (and it ain't), I would think about just sending a drawing and $100 or whatever to Ron Hock, and let him make an A2 or O1 (and his O1 is great these days) for you. That'd give you a fresh start on making the plane right. You deserve for it to be right, after all this.

Again, my hat is off to you! And to the resident MD who got the shavings out of your eye.

Wiley

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#13

Here's your post, I think *LINK*

wilbur

I hope this was the one you were thinking of, although it looks like the picture you had originally posted went AWOL.


Paul's ham fisted post

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#14

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

David Weaver

Wiley - as much as I'd like to take credit for the front bun, it's roughed in that shape already. All you have to do is rasp it, clean it up with sandpaper and scotchbrite and trim everything flush with the brass (it wasn't flush, the brass was actually proud).

I just ran it for a while in some hard maple, it's working more nicely than I remembered at the end of my frustrated session yesterday. Though the iron is not ideal, it's holding up a little better after a regrind, hopefully it continues to get better. I ground about a 16th off of it, to start because it came complete with huge nicks, but that may not have been quite enough to get to "good metal", I hope. It's still not centered, but the first heavy session flattening a hard maple panel (and not just fiddling around with boards checking to find out how fine it will go in a cut) will tell whether or not the iron is an immediate issue.

Thanks for the nice comments. It's no Nakano togo kanna, but I guess it's trying a little to reveal its positives. The mass makes planing hard maple downright pleasant, though in cherry and walnut yesterday, it didn't really do anything to differentiate itself from a kanna or a well tuned bench plane - they just aren't dense enough for its mass to be an asset.

Started to bevel the sides tonight after it had a little more of a differentiating showing tonight, too - I guess I just can't let it go unfinished - just took a day to cool of from the frustration.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#15

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

David Weaver

I would think the chariot would be a pretty difficult plane to start with. Looking at the kit, they don't give you much room to work around the mouth - not even enough to get a diamond card file through.

I haven't looked at the instructions for it - I'm pretty sure I don't have them, actually, but I'll end up making it sometime.

I think the best plane for people to start with is scratch building a plane like Ron Brese's small smoother, but without overstuffing it, and with an iron that is held in by a crossbar, since it makes tuning the lever cap to the iron easier. It also allows you to use 2 inch wide stock for all sides, so you only need to cut the stock to length.

Your past that now, though, since you've built the shoulder plane, and there aren't many newbies on this site, so I may have just said all of that for my own benefit :b

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#16

Re: St. James Bay Tool kit.

Barry Vabeach

David, nice work. What type of St. James kit did you get. His website shows mostly cast kits, but I seen a number of auctions of dovetailed kits, and I don't know whether he makes those in house - or whether they came from somewhere else?

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#17

Re: St. James Bay Tool kit.

David Weaver

Thanks, Barry. The kit that I got was one of the norris dovetailed smoother kits that was being sold on ebay. It's pretty straightforward. I can't remember the guy's name, but I talked to him for quite a while on the phone.

IIRC, it was pretty much pins, and you have to do the rest of the work, similar to the shepherd kits - about $175 with everything but the wood - it's pretty nice for that, a lot of roughing work is machined away.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#18

I was just thinking about Shepherd tonight...

James Watriss

I still have a heavy smoother kit up on a shelf in the shop, and I found their construction videos on my computer the other day. Somehow I had the presence of mind at the time to archive them.

Still haven't 100% decided to put the kit up on ebay with the videos... but I'm getting there. Your post certainly wasn't a glowing review.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#19

Re: I was just thinking about Shepherd tonight...

David Weaver

Based on the responses here and elsewhere, if it's an earlier kit with a nice mark on the iron (even the stamp done on my iron is very small, and poorly done) and a deeper signature on the lever cap, maybe it's worthwhile.

If you don't know whether or not you'll use it, you could dump the kit and spend half as much on the raw materials and just make the plane from scratch.

Re: Finished a panel plane kit tonight..

#20

Re: Here's your post, I think

Paul M.

Thanks Wilbur. That was indeed the post. I guess the picture got lost.