Finished a panel plane kit tonight..
David Weaver
.. well, for the most part.

Not many details in pictures, just finally cleaned all of the metal off my bench and put a coat of oil on it.
The kit is a shepherd kit, and there are a few tiny details that I didn't finish, and don't plan to. You can spot them and call me out on them.
The kit itself had a lot of problems, I'm going to guess it's from near the end of shepherd's run. They are as follows:
* The mortise for the tote was not remotely the same size and shape as the tote itself. Given that it was rounded and not a similar curve profile, I couldn't believe it. The comment in the kit literature said that it would "take significant skill to fit the tote and mortise well, a challenge that doesn't exist in the smoother kits".
* The iron is soft. It isn't unusable, but it's disappointing given their literature talking about how long it will stay sharp I will probably, at some point, cut my own out of 3/16th stock and harden it. I would say it's comparable to a stanley sweetheart bench plane iron in hardness. I expected something in the 60 to 62 range, and it is not that.
* the holes for the crossbar for the lever cap are way too far forward - they are pre-done and you have no choice. The way the kit is designed and cut, you can't really move the rear infill forward - the mouth is already roughed in the bottom and the rear infill is roughly shaped to fit the profile. I had to pein a piece of O1 onto the chipbreaker to get the screw to reach, and even at that it is extended far back
* the metal for the sole was bowed
* the laser cuts on the side brass were not actually all to the same depth, they were concave, causing the sole to be very hollow in the center - when I filed the pins initially, I was sure that I was just seeing things as it was hard to measure accurately. This took eons to lap out, and indirectly sent me to the emergency room with metal in my eye as I used the slight barrel shape of the drum on the end of my belt sander to remove stock from the middle of the length of the sole. I've never had to go to that extreme before.
* the chipbreaker and iron are not centered properly - in order to even get the iron in the plane, the adjuster had to be installed tightly against one side of the slot (they cut the slot slightly larger than the adjuster), and even then, it's still not centered.
* while they are not centered properly, they are also not matched in terms of how far off they are. This results in the chipbreaker screw gripping literally one side of the iron when tight and floating on the other side. this is not optimal to say the least.
* The cocobolo infills had sides (significantly) out of square and were too narrow even before squaring for the infill. After squaring them very sparingly with a smoother by hand, I had to order cocobolo veneer and build them up quite a bit.
I think that covers it, but to put it plainly, this kit was a real turd, and a disappointment for what it cost me to get it. I had a LN 6 at one point, with cocobolo handles - my first premium plane. This kit made me wish I never sold it.
I contributed my own error to it - the bottom is the first time I used mild steel - I went right past my marking line when filing the mouth to final size, and it is about .009"-.01". I was hoping to start at half that. With common pitch and a stupidly shaped chipbreaker profile, you get tearout with it just like a common bench plane. The tearout isn't bad, but it requires follow up with a smoother. I know some of you guys are thinking "boo hoo". Yeah, i know, it's not a big deal, it requires no skill to work around minor tearout, but it's not what you shoot for making an infill (or at least i don't), and my smoother that I scratch built is nearly impossible to induce tearout (it is at a higher angle with a mouth about a third of the size of this one). Actually, both smoothers that i built are that way.
It does, however, plane with authority at just under 9 pounds (keep the wax handy, please). It's the first larger infill I've gotten (well, put together i guess) - you just sort of walk with it, there's no throwing it back and forth briskly.
It works acceptably well, and another coat of oil and a coat of wax and a tiny bit of cleanup on the front and rear metal and it'll be done for real.
Most of all, thank the lord above I'm done with it. I never thought I would be sitting in the ER in the middle of the city of pittsburgh with the late night loonies at midnight with a (fortunately very competent) resident picking metal off the surface of my eye right in the middle of the pupil with a needle.



That was the best lesson I learned in this adventure.



