Just a thought
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Dave,
I have only used a convex shave on one part of one project, and found it a difficult tool to just 'sharpen and use'. So I'll offer my experience, with the caveat that it ain't much experience.
I eventually was able to use the tool productively, but only after some unhappy moments like you are describing. This may be obvious to you--it wasn't to me--but it's hard to find the sweet spot of a convex shave. With a flat-bottomed shave, there is only one choice--the shave has to be flat on its face. With the convex shave, it will only cut properly at one angle, but you have to find it. And it will also only cut properly if you have the right blade projection.
Initially, I kept setting too much blade projection--this was on a shave without an adjuster. What would happen is that I would fail to make a test cut when the blade projection was right, then advance it more to get contact, and then that would be too much and I would get chatter.
So I would suggest this diagnostic: using your adjuster screws, set the blade at a slight skew, so that it transitions from 'no cut' to 'some cut' across the shave. Then take a thin stick, like 1/4" wide, and find out where the sweet spot is across the shave. Once you find the sweet spot, then use the adjuster screws to level the whole blade and broaden the sweet spot. You could make the sweet spot go all across the shave face, or else could leave a little skew in the blade as some like to do. Shave on the thin stick until you have a curve in it, comparable to the curve in the project wood. Make adjustments to blade depth as required, as the curve deepens.
The point is, to focus down and find the sweet spot on a thin stick. Now you know you have the blade depth right, and you have some muscle memory finding the correct angle to hold the shave at. BTW, I am assuming you're holding the shave close to the cutting action, and not spreading your hands to go on the handles. You want your thumbs on the cutting head (IMO, IME).
So now you can turn to the project wood. You should be within fine tuning of good results.
That's what I did. Worked OK, but with the grain only.
Wiley