Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

Posts

The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#1

The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Over the past month I've been discussing cutting dovetails and fretsaws with Lee Marshall, the designer at New Concepts (link below).

Lee offers three sizes of fretsaw - 3", 5" and 8" - in a novel design that is aimed at creating a rigid, non-flexing aluminium frame. These are light fretsaws for the jewelry industry and serious hobbiests. A few woodworkers have discovered his saws, and I have little doubt that many will soon be queuing up for one of them.

Lee mentioned to me that he also had a titanium model in the works. "The Titanium frame is my attempt to "turn swords into plowshares". The material that I have access to is 1/8" thick that was left over from the F-22 fighter."

I was going to purchase the 8" model, but at this point decided to wait for the titanium to go into production. It would be stiffer than the aluminium, which is a Good Thing in this type of saw.

Anyway, I received a email from Lee a couple of days ago to say that he was sending me a package ... a titanium fretsaw, an earlier prototype, the design of which has been improved, so this saw was not for sale and a gift. "It was cut pretty early in the design stage and is now obsolete. I have made numerous changes that make it even stronger, lighter, and that also increase ease of use."

It arrived today. It will get blooded this weekend. I just wanted to share this beautiful, really cool fretsaw with all. Damn it is cool!


Close up of the clamping mechanism ..


Wiley, you have the aluminium 8" don't you? What's your experience so far?

Regards from Perth

Derek


New Concepts

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#2

Stylin'

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'll be interested to hear how it works. It certainly looks bridge-truss stiff.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#3

Re: The coolest fretsaw.

Ace Karner

I have the 8 inch alum saw, it is awesome. I know the titanium must weigh less but the alum is so light I can hardly see how it could be that much different. I'm sure that it can stand even more tension but at that the one I have can tighten a blade until it sings like a fiddle string.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#4

Re: The coolest fretsaw.

David Weaver

Is there a chance that there could be long-term cumulative stress issues with the aluminium version? Given the amount of tension on a fretsaw blade, maybe the term is materially indefinite.

It would be nice to see a skeletal steel version. An internal argument (in my brain) would be that steel would be a lot tougher to work than aluminium.....but this seems like an argument hardly worth having if there is a titanium version coming!

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#5

Awesome, but...

David Miller from Iowa

This is a fantastic, cool saw. A triumph of modern design and i would love to have one.

As a practical matter, does anyone know if this is stiffer than the bowsaw-style coping/jewlers saw someone posted on here a couple years ago? Someone was making the ones with a center spline and a tensioner on top and I really liked that idea. Anyone recall who that was?

Just thinking that for all the cool design and titanium and all, I would be interested to know if it stood up to the tension style saw in performance.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#6

IIRC,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

David Barnett and Pam Niedermayer might have them, too.

It's on my list of stuff to get when I can start working on that list.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#7

It's about weight.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As a practical matter, does anyone know if this is stiffer than the bowsaw-style coping/jewlers saw someone posted on here a couple years ago? Someone was making the ones with a center spline and a tensioner on top and I really liked that idea. Anyone recall who that was?

Hi David

I think that was Bob Smalser. He wrote a great tutorial for a small coping bowsaw. In fact I was planning on making something similar before I came across the KC fretsaw.

http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/bSmalser/art/shopTools/shopTools1.asp

The other one to look out for is the Gramercy (by Tools for Working Wood).

My concern about a wooden coping/fret saw is the weight, or should I say the combination of weight and balance. I like to saw one-handed and not have to prop the other end of the saw up with a second hand.

Just hefting the KC fretsaw it is easy to tell that it will be comfortable and non-fatiguing to use.

I have 2 fretsaws in my shop that get used a lot. One is a 3" vintage jeweller's saw. However this can only be used on drawer fronts or boxes about 5" wide. The other is the (German-made) 12" Featherweight fretsaw sold by LV. The latter is the lightest by far of many I have used but it suffers in becoming distorted when you really crank up the tension (I had to make a repair to mine after about 2 years of use). Still it is the easiest fretsaw of the pick. The KC fretsaw promises to be both light and extremely stiff, a unique combination.

LV link: http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=45654&cat=1,42884,42902

The two fretsaws mentioned above:


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#8

Re: IIRC,

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't have a good one yet, no real need at this point; but they're bookmarked, just waiting for that first marketry project. I'd bet David Burnett has multiples of fret saws hanging about.

Pam

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#9

My mistake

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I was under the impression that you had ordered one when David mentioned them. Sorry.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#10

Re: My mistake

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Maybe I left that impression, was quite impressed with the saw's potential. Of course, often when I get to the ordering part I get dissuaded when confronted with the price. Nothing to be sorry for. :)

Pam

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#11

David Barnett

How'd you guess?

David Barnett

"I'd bet David Burnett has multiples of fret saws hanging about."

In fact, two are the pre-red-handled variety (I modify mine for consistency, anyway). Lee Marshall truly makes the best all-round sawframe, although I use mine mostly for metals. The 5" is perfect for DTs. Combined with Rio Grande's Laser Gold blades, it's almost a challenge to break a blade before's its time. The combination of lightness and rigidity also extends blade life because there is less tendency to over-tighten (I don't even bother to de-tension these) and to over-grip or force the cut. Even more important to goldsmiths, these saws offer superb, almost unconscious control in the cut for those skilled enough to appreciate that.

Do you really need a Knew Concepts saw to cut dovetail waste? Of course not! These are 'finesse' tools as woodworking goes. But they'll earn their keep with 2/0 blades for marquetry and inlay, cutting sheet brass, silver, aluminum, copper, resin, ivory, horn, bone, whatever. And they're just so darned nice to use.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#12

Technique revisited

Bob Hackett

I have a question on sawing technique for you if you don`t mind David.

Do you saw at a bench holding the blade horizontal and powering mostly from the shoulder or do you use a bench hook holding the blade vertical and power it mostly with your forearm,pivoting at the elbow rather than the shoulder?

After you answer I may have some follow on questions.

TIA.

MB

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#13

Re: How'd you guess?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Having a saw that can handle metal and wood would be very handy for the little stuff. I'll buy one one of these days.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#14

Re: The coolest fretsaw.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

Yes, based on David Barnett's recommendation on these pages, I bought the 8" aluminum frame. I would almost call it featherlight, and it is very rigid. Real glad to hear you have made this connection and will be evaluating the titanium frame.

This is easily the best of the half dozen saw frames I have tried over the years. I won't go into the foibles of each of them, but they were many--typically if you put on enough tension to get the blade rigid, the frame would twist. The frame would twist before you could get enough tension on the blade, and the lack of tension would get worse as the blade heats in use and lengthens a little. This frame will not twist and will get the blade really tight.

You showed the tensioning mechanism which is really sweet. The best of them all I've tried. There was one French made saw frame some years ago that Garrett Wade carried, and was recommended by some, that would come apart like a clock when trying to get the blade secured and tensioned--I spent considerable time on hand and knees in sawdust looking for parts of that saw!

My best saw prior to this was also a D. Barnett recommendation--a good French made saw from Contenti jewelers, the one with the rigid frame that you lean into to bend, and tighten the blade while its bent under your weight. This one is more rigid than that one, holds the blade under more tension, and the blade can be changed 1, 2, nothing.

The acid test for me on rigidity is whether the blade deflects and develops slack in use. This is the first frame (for me) that doesn't deflect, and therefore keeps the blade from heating.

Right now, I'm still looking for the perfect blade. Am using No. 2 Olson (0.012" thick, the thickness of a dozuki saw kerf) skip tooth right now, which I thought was a decent blade until I felt the one that Lee Marshall sent with the saw frame. Now that was a sharp blade, and I instantly knew that the Olson blade is quite dull in comparison. The thing is, Lee's blade is a jeweler's blade, and to get a jeweler's blade that is 0.012" thick, you have to go to 8/0 or so, and have 80-90 tpi. So I'm stuck with the Olson's, but continually on the lookout for a sharper woodworking (scroll saw) blade.

I'm most interested to hear of your results with Lee's titanium frame. I think I will get a 5" when they come out.

Wiley

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#15

Re: The coolest fretsaw.

darin

I also purchased one and I agree with all of the positive comments however to be perfectly honest I found two non functional things that greatly disappointed me. First and foremost are the burrs around all of the cuts made by the water jet or whatever was was used to cut it out second is the ugly red painted handle.

I don't remember what it cost but surely improving those two issues would not increase the price much and would make it look like the premium tool that it is.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#16

David Barnett

And the answer is... *LINK*

David Barnett

"Do you saw at a bench holding the blade horizontal and powering mostly from the shoulder or do you use a bench hook holding the blade vertical and power it mostly with your forearm, pivoting at the elbow rather than the shoulder?"

Both, Bob. And sometimes in-between. Pretty much the norm for goldsmiths, I'd say.

When I'm at the jeweler's bench using the pin, I saw from the elbow while the hand and wrist stay remarkably quiet and relaxed, the shoulder even more so (handle mods can enhance this). The frame is almost always vertical. I also used this technique with a bird's-mouth for marquetry, although I tilted the frame between 8 to 12 degrees for a 'plug fit'. When cutting thin sheet, whether metal or wood, it's important to have a good view of the cut line. While veneer packets and boule can be cut on the other axis, this requires a different approach to supporting the work and jigging the saw, such as the 'chevalet' traditionally used in France.

As I do sawing at the Taig lathe, a horizontal technique is required to clear the lathe bed and cross slide, so the shoulder and all the other joints get into the game. While sawing off the strictly vertical can involve the shoulder through the hand in a running or locomotive connecting rod action, I try to minimize such motions, tilting and even rocking my body to get a controlled stroke. I'm comfortable with both axes by now, but vertical is my mainstay, and with the right music, I can do it all day without fatigue. More precise, less tiring.

As for in-between: instead of the bench pin, I often hold my work in the GRS Benchmate, a rotating multi-axis vise that presents the workpiece so you can get at things in so many ways it has revolutionized stone setting, fabrication and finishing. It's second nature to saw or carve (yes, jeweler's 'carve' and trim with saw blades) when the work is so accessibly and visibly secured.

Beyond that, I sometimes saw work held in an engraver's block (ball vise), which means horizontal or close to. And sawing wire coiled on a mandrel into jump rings is definitely horizontal.

Follow ups?

(By the way, the goldsmith in the link now uses Lee's Knew Concept saws)


James Miller, piercing master at his bench pin

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#17

Thanks David,and follow on

Bob Hackett

As you know I have shoulder problems.I have been trying to adapt to this new to me technique of sawing with the blade vertical and using only my forearm.

I thought it was just me but from your post it sounds like I`m not alone in my trouble with isolating the shoulder.You say rocking your body helps,how so?

You also mentioned handle mods,could you describe what has worked for you or link to a pic(nod,nod,wink,wink,say no more)?

Thanks again for your usual detailed answer.

MB

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#18

David Barnett

Hope this'll do 'til I borrow a camera... *LINK*

David Barnett

Warning: most of this will be of little or no interest to anyone other than Mainely Bob.

"As you know I have shoulder problems.I have been trying to adapt to this new to me technique of sawing with the blade vertical and using only my forearm. I thought it was just me but from your post it sounds like I`m not alone in my trouble with isolating the shoulder.You say rocking your body helps, how so You also mentioned handle mods,could you describe what has worked for you or link to a pic (nod, nod, wink, wink, say no more)?"

While my right shoulder (rotator cuff) was injured, the weight of my arm alone was excruciating. At worst, sawing was simply out of the question. Now that I've healed sawing is again enjoyable. Even so, having had carpal tunnel syndrome and shoulder problems on my right side, I'm very aware and careful of repetitive tasks.

Firstly, Bob, let me say that I'd not likely waste out DTs with the saw held vertically. I don't relish bending to see the underside of the workpiece. So for DTs you'll just have to chug along as best you can. At least the strokes are short and the sawframe light. One thing, though, don't rotate your arm bringing your hand into supination. Pronation is the way to go, and quartering with the right thumb at 10 o'clock is better still.

I should say right here that I'm not particularly fond of the standard sawframe handles in line with the blade. For most people this may never present a problem, but for people with hand-wrist-elbow-shoulder issues, it can truly suck.

Notice that I said 'may' in the last sentence. If you do a lot of fret sawing with standard handle orientation, I'm convinced some sort of repetitive motion injury will eventually present, which is why I favor ergonomics that promote lighter gripping at offset angles for enhanced control and stamina.

Difficult as it sounds, it's really straightforward and easy, and an hour or so of fiddling about will yield life-changing rewards.

I just want to say one word to you, Bob. Just one word... plastics.

Or rather more specifically, thermoplastics.

Yes, while there was craft before modern thermoplastics; pitch, wax, shellac, and whatever other amorphous goos, glues, resins, plasters and oleaginates could be pressed into service to hold things relatively fast, low temperature modelable reusable plastics have improved the lot of the fumble-fingered and those unfortunates with only two hands. Jett Sett, Plastiform and now Thermo-Loc are the new shellacs, with safer, more comfortable working temperatures and economies of reuse. While these are primarily intended for fixturing, they have become very popular for on-the-fly ergonomic tool handle mods. I keep finding new semi-permanent uses for the stuff and find myself buying more.

Whether you heat Jett Sett in hot water (140F) or nuke Thermo-Loc in the microwave, it's easy to find the shape that feels just right. If it adds too much weight to an existing handle you can replace it, hollow it out, shorten it, make a new featherweight modeling form. You'll think of more tricks and uses, too. Ergonomically formed offset graver handles bring my thumb into play for extra control and finesse. Tapered triangular wax carving tool handles beat skinny round ones anyday. Fly tying tools. And so on.

If you want a new handle right away and reusablity isn't too important, get some hand-kneadable epoxy putty. Pretty versatile.

Okay... I'll take a break. I am still cameraless, but I'll borrow one midweek and show you what works for me. Thousand words.

Oh... almost forgot... rocking. I do this for sawing, engraving, filing, stone setting, wire inlay, all sorts of precision tasks. For sawing the stroke is short and obviously slow, but extremely precise for notching settings and undercutting prongs. For woodworking, this is how I pare. Rocking limits the axes of motion and degrees of freedom. I rest my arm against my side and simply rock bath and forth. Great control under the microscope, especially with the workpiece at waist height. Of course, I have the advantage of considerable avoirdupois for arm support. At least it's good for something.

Sources for fixturing compounds:

Otto Frei

http://tinyurl.com/mbe4q - Jett Sett

http://tinyurl.com/2cn4cgv - Thermo-Loc

Rio Grande

http://tinyurl.com/233uhlo - Jett Sett

Contenti

http://tinyurl.com/2g6ttzw - Jett Sett

SEP

http://tinyurl.com/29zwzj2 - Jett Sett (good price)

FDJ

http://tinyurl.com/26sz338 - Thermo-Loc

GRS

http://tinyurl.com/237dgrx - Thermo-Loc

I knew I'd mentioned some of this on WC. Just search on Jett Sett for more.

http://tinyurl.com/2gyv7du

http://tinyurl.com/22jjc68

http://tinyurl.com/22nbce4

Here's a link to how goldsmith Brian Meeks modifies his saw handles. They're in line with the blade but that's what works for him.


Brian's sawframe handles

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#19

You are obviously psychic

Bob Hackett

I was going to ask what you could do to improve grip.Right now I`m using either the foam grips off exercise equipment or the tape you would wrap the grip of a tennis racket with to increase the diameter and help my grip.

Your suggestions are several orders of magnitude better than that.

I had thought about trying epoxy putty and placing a sandwich bag over my hand to keep it from sticking to the handle but decided not to for some reason.

Thanks David,this will help immensely.

MB

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#20

Re: You are obviously psychic

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Wow, that really is a great post by David (man who knows everything)!

Bob, following in line with David's thought of modifying the grip, I wonder if it would help if you could manage to get two hands on the saw. Like add a second handle along the far end of the sawframe. I realize you're trying to take the load off your shoulder, and that wouldn't really do it, but would spread the load onto both shoulders.

Also, I wouldn't give up on the idea of placing the board face down (with appearance side up, of course), and sawing the waste vertically. Am pretty sure you could do this relying on sense of vertical, and still not mess up the underside (very much). Agree with David you don't want to be looking under there.

Wiley

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#21

David Barnett

Point taken

David Barnett

Actually, Wiley, you can do all right with a horizontal workpiece if you invert the sawframe, cutting on the upstroke. Tilting the frame slightly forward a few degrees will keep you away from the hidden line, but as carcase and drawer stock is a bit thicker than marquetry, there will be more blade bearing diagonally in the work, which may lead to more blade attrition. So being the cheap bastard I am, I'll risk the strain and the pain.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#22

David Barnett

One other thing...

David Barnett

I neglected to mention that using all the fingers in the grip, that is to say, the fist, is awkward, stressful and definitely overkill. The index and pinky can actually work against the grip, demanding more force and rigidizing the muscles, with loss of control and ease. Generally, it's much easier to break free of a fist grip than the thumb, middle and ring finger grip. Ask your neighborhood aikido master to demonstrate. This is my go to #2 smoother grip and works nicely for the occasional rapier duel, as well.

Re: The coolest fretsaw. *LINK*

#23

One thing working in my favor

Bob Hackett

Don`t know if I mentioned that I`ve done a lot of welding it tight places.

Working while watching things in a mirror is nothing new to me. :)