Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Hardening Steel?

Posts

Hardening Steel?

#1

Hardening Steel?

David Miller from Iowa

I'm making a table (with hand tools, so this is not too far OT) and I'm trying to make a little latching gizmo out of some standard store bought j bolts - but they are too soft and bend. Is there a quick and easy way to harden them with a blowtorch or something? Thanks, david

Re: Hardening Steel?

#2

Chris Scholz

Re: Hardening Steel?

Chris Scholz

Hardened steel has just about the same modulus of elasticity as not hardened steel. In fact all steel has just about the same modulus of elasticity of 200 GPa. (Of course hardened steel has higher yield strength than unhardened steel, but that's not what you are talking about if I understand your problem correctly.)

I'd say don't waste you time with hardening. Get a bigger bolt.

Chris

Re: Hardening Steel?

#3

Probably no *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They're probably mild steel, and thus not something you can harden/temper/stiffen with much success. You might contact an auto parts store that sells truck stuff (hooks for rope and that kind of thing), and see if they've got something made with a higher grade of steel; or a boating supply store, with the same idea in mind.

I've used Green Boat Stuff, linked below, once, for a non-boating need, and was very impressed with their customer service and their ability to think outside the boat, as it were.

Homegrown hardware can really be challenging, but it's sure nice when it succeeds.


http://www.greenboatstuff.com/

Re: Hardening Steel?

#4

Re: Hardening Steel?

Marv

Case hardening is about the best you can do with that kind of steel. Case hardening is only skin deep so it really wouldn't do much for you.

You might try finding some stainless steel bolts that are tougher and less apt to bend. The better hardware stores will carry an assortment of stainless fasteners.

Marv

Re: Hardening Steel?

#5

Re: Hardening Steel?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

many hardware stores carry grade 5 and grade 8 bolts, which are made of much better steel than the standard grade. I'd try those before attempting to harden mild steel.

Re: Hardening Steel?

#6

Re: Hardening Steel?

dburnard

Not sure what spec of steel the bold material is but, it mild steel is hardenable to some degree, probably enough for your purpose...

These days typically mild steel batches will contain 15-20 points of carbon (unless spec'ed for less, like 1008) and it can actually be hardened considerably, just not to edge holding hardnesses.

Do a search for "Super Quench". It's a variation on a brine quench with surfactants added to prevent steam jacketing during the quench, developed at a Sandia Lab.

May not apply to your scenario, but it's a handy thing to know.

Re: Hardening Steel?

#7

Re: Hardening Steel?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

What happens if you use it for quenching high carbon steel?

Pam

Re: Hardening Steel?

#8

Re: Hardening Steel?

Bob Hackett

It really depends on what type of high carbon steel you have.Some are meant to be quenched in water,others brine and still others oil.

If you`re unsure the best bet is to start with oil as that is the more friendly quench and then try to cut the steel with a file or in this case try to bend it.

If it isn`t hard enough then jump up to water or lastly go to brine.

If you take something meant to quench in oil(like O1) and dump it in water then chances are the steel will crack or otherwise fail.

One other thing to keep in mind ,especially with quick quench steels(like W1 or 2) is that a lot of stress is cranked into the piece during the hardening phase(first heat/quench cycle) and many times if you don`t draw the temper quickly the piece may crack/break if you put it on the bench and wait till morning to temper.

Nothing is more discouraging than to fuss over getting something up to critical temp,quenching successfully to glass hard and then carefully placing a bit of work on the bench late at nite only to come back first thing in the morning to temper and find it laying right where you placed it in 2 or more pieces. :(

Another thing to keep in mind is that you are thinking about using cad plated hardware for heating and hardening then forget it.The cad plate is REAL bad news in the fumes department and the effects are cumulative. :O

Re: Hardening Steel?

#9

Re: Hardening Steel?

Bob Hackett

I`d like to suggest posting a sketch or pic of what you have in mind so we all can see what`s involved.Enough of us here have dealt with custom hardware issues that surely someone can give you some info on redesign or a source for hardware off the shelf.

All we need is a clear idea of what you`d like to have happen.Pictures really are worth a least 1000 words. :D

Re: Hardening Steel?

#10

Re: Hardening Steel?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OK, but I was responding to Dave and the article he cited in which statements were made that only low carbon steel was suitable for the super quench. Which, of course, made me wonder what happens if you do a super quench on high carbon steel. Are you saying it gets too brittle and cracks?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Hardening Steel?

#11

Re: Hardening Steel?

bugbear

From googling, it appears that Super Quench was specifically developed for mild steels.

For higher carbon steels, the correct heat treatments are well known (water, oil, brine, etc, according to steel type).

BugBear

Re: Hardening Steel?

#12

Yes

Bob Hackett

Super quench is an aggressive water quench so if you try to quench the wrong type of steel in it expect bad things.

Each different type of steel has certain specs and parameters that must be met in order to have successful results.Failure means an unusable part.Either the part will be too soft and wear or bend or too hard and break/crack.

Some of the steels have such tight requirements that even the guys with the computer controlled furnaces will predict a certain percentage of loss.

There are literally thousands of types of steels out there and like most things you need to match the proper steel to the application and then do the proper heat treatment to either harden,soften or reduce stresses in the finished part.

Just as we have many woods with different characteristics to consider the same holds true for metals as well.

Contrary to popular belief steel is not just steel and we have yet to come up with one type of alloy that can do it all.

Re: Hardening Steel?

#13

Re: Hardening Steel?

Bob Hackett

One of the things that is often overlooked during quenching is agitation,and not the mental type either.

Water type quenches(to include brine and super quench) have a nasty trick up their sleeves.When you plunge hot metal into water you get a layer of steam(air and water)around the part that keeps the water from reaching the part and pulling the heat from it as quickly.Unless you aggressively agitate the part while quenching to break that steam blanket up you will get uneven hardening,localized stresses and increased chance of failure of the part due to things like cracking and warping.

Most heat treaters will tell you to keep the part completely submerged in the quenchant and to move it in a quick figure eight pattern.The pros doing batch work use pumps and baskets to do the same thing.

BTW-Super quench will only raise the hardness of mild steel a few points and only really works well on parts of small cross section,don`t expect big things from it.

It will not allow you to take rebar and make a plane iron out of it or turn a hardware store butter bolt into a new head bolt for your bike.

Re: Hardening Steel?

#14

Thanks, got it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Hardening Steel?

#15

Thanks, Paul.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Hardening Steel?

#16

Re: Yes

bugbear

Contrary to popular belief steel is not just steel and we have yet to come up with one type of alloy that can do it all.

At the risk of slight topic drift, this guy lists 548 steels ... just for knives!

http://www.zknives.com/knives/steels/steelchart.php

BugBear

Re: Hardening Steel?

#17

Re: Hardening Steel?

ThomD

What Super Quench will or won`t do still seems to create controversy. People certainly have hardened stuff with it like anvils and hammers that are large section, and where a decent bump in hardness is required. But these require as near as possible to 50 points, well above mild steel levels.

Over 50 points I have heard that metal quenched in SQ `goes off like a grenade` Not safe, or as others have suggested, what one would want to do. SQ is based on the idea that hardening tapers off before hardenability because the quenches used bubbled up too much and didn`t cool the metal fast enough. SQ deals with surface tension etc... With hardenable tool steels this causes too rapid cooling.

One option with the OP`s projects, would be to try some 4130. It is much stronger without heat treating. One still runs up against the stiffness vs. strength issues. The stronger cat bolts are hardenable steels and could be heat treated. Remeber this involves hardening and them drawing the temper to reduce brittleness. Another option would be music wire, then find online info on making springs, which is about the hardness you would want.

http://www.victornet.com/alphabetic/Music-Wire/164.html?id=qZHFdHm7

Re: Hardening Steel?

#18

Chris Scholz

Re: Yes

Chris Scholz

Agreed,

But, contrary to popular belief hardening does not stiffen steel but, uh, how do I put that, harden steel.

The stiffness of steel is just about the same. So with respect to elasticity (I believe that is what is relevant for the OP's problem), steel IS just steel.

Chris

Re: Hardening Steel?

#19

I would disagree

Bob Hackett

I would have to respectfully disagree on that point.

There`s a reason we use a particular steel for a particular purpose and while most steels will act the same in an annealed or soft state their properties can change dramatically once they are heat treated.

For example;Take a piece of re-bar and heat it till the critical temp is reached(no longer attracted to a magnet) and then quench that re-bar in oil till cool.Now grind back the scale till you can see bright steel and heat till you see a dark straw color appear along that bright area.

Now take a piece from and old rock/digging bar and do the same thing to it.

Wearing a faceshield and gloves now try prying against 2 immovable objects with these 2 pieces of steel.

The re-bar will bend and stay bent.The rock bar made of higher carbon steel(tool steel) will bend slightly if at all and then return to it`s shape once pressure is released.

If you hadn`t drawn the hardness from the HCS by tempering and just tried prying with the 2 pieces then the re-bar would still have bent but there`s a chance the old rock bar would have broken instead of bending.A better(but more dangerous) test in the hardened state would have been to either throw both pieces to a concrete floor or lay them on a hard object(not an anvil please)and hit them both with a hammer.The re-bar may bend or dent but the HCS bar would most likely break like it was made from glass.This is what the term"glass hard" means.

Heat isn`t the only way to harden a piece of steel.Steel can also be work hardened to a point where it will fracture and fail.The same alloy of mild steel will have noticeable differences in it`s hot rolled and cold rolled forms.The cold rolling work hardens the steel and the cold rolled item will require more force in order to punch,shear and bend than the softer hot rolled.

Annealing may make all metals soft and somewhat similar in that soft state but the ability to harden and temper a steel,determined by the alloy and most commonly by addition of carbon, makes all the difference in how a steel wears,resists deflection(as in spring steel alloys),holds an edge,etc.

How and when a metal hardens is what determines the suitability of a metal for a task and in that respect all steels are very much NOT equal.

MB

Re: Hardening Steel?

#20

Chris Scholz

Re: I would disagree

Chris Scholz

Yes of course the steel goes through dramatic changes when hardening and hardened steel behaves quite differently than non hardened steel for large deformation.

The thing is that traditionally you design things such that you stay well below the yield point, i.e. in the. In the elastic region hardened and non-hardened steel behave just about the same. (between point 1 and 2 on the stress-strain curve)

The example you describe is of course valid. However you are not in the elastic region but allow for plastic deformation you your bars (plasticity).

Based on good engineering practices I assumed that the OP would design his fixture in the elastic region (in fact he was complaining about "bending", i.e. plastic deformation).

I fact, relative recent machine design rules allow for a limited amount of plastic deformation. In this case hardened steel will give you an advantage over non-hardened steel. Classical example is the Dehnschraube (apologies, can not find anything in English on that topic how do y'all call them screws?), that has been used in cylinder heads of high-performance combustion engines and many other heavy duty machine parts for many years.

Dimensioning of such screws/bolts is well understood and reasonably straight-forward, (of course metric units make life a lot easier here). I do not think that's what the OP had mind, though. So without a basic sketch of what he wants we may not be able to help him much.

In that sense, I'll stick with what I said.

Re: Hardening Steel?

#21

I`m not an engineer but...

Bob Hackett

I did sleep in a Holiday Inn last nite. :D

Re: Hardening Steel?

#22

How about a socket head cap screw?

John in NM

I seem to remember they are pretty hard. Or go with stainless or grade 8's.