Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

Posts

Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#1

Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Hit the garage sales today - nothing, or junk, except for one sale that had a moderately large wet grinding wheel. Not the big 2-3 foot jobbies, but probably 16-18", big cast iron tub and cover. The man who's selling it says it used to have a foot treadle, but he or his dad motorized it at some point.

These show up around here about as often as a humble movie actor, so I'm wondering whether to drive out again tomorrow to see if it's still there (company coming this afternoon, so I can't go back today). Has anyone used one of these, and how do they compare with smaller wet stones (I have a Delta 10" wet/dry grinder, similar to the Tormek but with a little 5" dry wheel and no honing/polishing wheel)?

If I had space, it'd be tempting as a pretty, but I'm trying to focus on function here.

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#2

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I b

wilbur

I haven't used a wet grinding wheel like you describe, but despite all the recent discussion of dry grinding wheels, I'm pretty happy with the speed of how my Tormek grinds, so a larger wheel should be at least as good, if not faster due to the increased SFPM from the larger diameter.

But then again, Bill, you're the same person who wound up with multiple cast iron table saw tops, so getting something like this should be a bit of no brainer. Go get it! ;)

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#3

Reality check

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

The question is whether you want to use it or display it? These types of vintage tools do not work as efficiently as the modern versions - actually, this one likely does not have a modern equivalent. So, do you think that you can modify it for everyday-type use? Otherwise it will sit in a corner, just taking up valuable real estate, and never get used. You would be better off finding the exact tool/machine you believe you need.

It's all very romantic - and I would buy it in a heartbeat if I had the space to display it - but the reality is that it likely will not replace the Tormek you really have your heart set on.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#4

Re: Reality check

Patrick Gibbons

If this is one of the old sandstone wheels, I think you would be pleased with it. The major problem is dressing it. These don't burn your edge and work pretty fast. I can't verify this from personal use even though I have one. I've been too lazy to build the mount for my wheel. My father always had good things to say about this kind of wheel.

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#5

Reality check: Sandstone Wheel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a 20" sandstone wheel and I like it very much. But I must say it takes some skill and experience to use. A beginner will press too hard against the wheel, causing it to glaze, which is frustrating and the temptation is to press even harder. Once you get the hang of it, though, the surface stays lively and doesn't ever need dressing.

Another note is that with such a large diameter, the hollow grind is insignificant. (Do the math yourself.) Those who think 18th century woodworkers were hollow grinding tools the same way some do today are off base here. Further, 18th century plane irons were on the thin side, and chisels were also quite delicate, so hollow grinding was not as important as with heavier tools.

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#6

Re: Reality check: Sandstone Wheel

thomd

Lots of farms have these smaller wheels. Was interesting to note that In the Cab's Apprentice, they mention the standard cabinet shop wheel being much larger, 4 feet sticks in the mind, not sure. It would cut a flatter bevel, and also keep running at speed. Certainly these smaller wheels are pretty good as far as diameter is concerned, but it might argue for coming up with some motor to keep them trucking along. Won't need to be much if you could get it up to speed by hand.

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#7

Didn't buy it

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The owner wouldn't move from a price beyond my budget. I don't know that he really wants to sell it - he was telling me about using it as a young man, under his father's tutelage, and I think this may be the tool that truly connects him to his dad.

Fine - not that I really needed it. After all, I need to save up for that Tormek that Derek thinks I need :D

Looked at Tormek prices in the course of this weekend - man, the price has jumped since I drooled over them last!

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#8

Re: Didn't buy it

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Not trying to be the perennial scrooge, but I truly don't see the value of the Tormak. Several years ago I investigated grinders, looked at and tried several, and determined there was nothing the Tormak could do that the Makita horizontal couldn't, except make the dreaded hollow grinds. They're both equally fast/slow, both slop around a bunch of water in dribs and drabs, etc. So I bought the Makita and have been as pleased as I could be with an electric grinder. Talk about damning with faint praise. :)

Pam

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#9

Re: Didn't buy it

wilbur

For me, the two main benefits of a Tormek are:

1. Sharpening turning tools.

2. Not having to worry about grinder wheel and metal dust.

For sharpening flat edge tools like plane blades and chisels, I do agree that there are many other alternatives to the Tormek.

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#10

Choices and strategies

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I truly don't see the value of the Tormak

Hi Pam

Your Makita grinding system is appropriate for your needs - you predominantly use Japanese blades, and prefer honing a flat bevel face.

The Tormek excells at creating hollow grinds safely. It is also excellent at maintaining a hollow grind to the blade edge. For those that seek to hone microbevels, this system is ideal. That is not to say the Tormek is the only way to get there.

I do not view the two systems as interchangeable. They are different in their sharpening strategies.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#11

Re: Didn't buy it

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I sharpen lots of gouges, some of which are turning chisels, as well as flat blades. And I don't see why a Tormak relieves you of grinder wheel and metal dust concerns.

Pam

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#12

Re: Didn't buy it (edited for clarification)

wilbur

On the dust thing, I meant compared to a dry wheel grinder. I know that the Makita is a waterstone-based system -- I was talking about what I liked about the Tormek in a more global sense.

From what I know about the Makita, I think I know how you can sharpen gouges, but can you put a fingernail grind on a spindle gouge with it?

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#13

Re: Choices and strategies

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

For those who want to make hollow grinds, there are several other vertical grinders whose wheels get wet. And I certainly don't consider the systems equivalent. I think the Makita makes me happier; but just in case I get too happy, I've got many stones, which are my real goto sharpeners, as well as a regular 6" grinder and an old belt sander that seems to like laying about on its back. :)

Pam

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#14

OK, but the Makita is a wet grinder, too.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#15

Sure, it behaves like a flat stone.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Wet grinding wheel at garage sale - should I buy?

#16

Re: Reality check: Sandstone Wheel

Dean J in MN

Warren,

My take on the 18th C grinding/honing is summed up with:

"Grind low; Hone high."

I don't think they hollow ground to some particular angle so that they could rest the front and rear of the hollow on the stone to hone. Holtzapffel describes it as:

"In all cases in which the sharpening of the tools is completed upon the oilstone the principal part of the material is removed upon the grindstoneat an angle a little less than that forming the ultimate edge of the tool the greatest differences being made in the tools for soft wood whichonly require a mederate degree of strength in their edges such as the plane irons, paring chisels, and gouges which are generally ground about10 degrees more acutely than they are sharpened."

I do the same with my small grinder, I grind at 20-25deg and hone higher, depending on the tools. I don't use the hollow for registration on the stone, rather just as a means of keeping my sharpening bevel small. I guess that sharpening bevel is what the modern term "microbevel" really is?

-Dean