Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

Posts

Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#1

Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I few weeks back I posted an article on making a dovetail chisel, which included grinding shallow shoulders on the sides of chisels.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Soyouwanttomakeadovetailchisel.html

I had begun a set of dovetail chisels inspired by a set made by Dave Jeske for Jim Shaver. These were rehandled LNs. Truly, these are amongst the most beautiful Western chisels I have seen. As you can see below, the handles are lengthened over the standard LN handle.


Now the Lord knows I do not need more chisels! :) But they have been calling to me for a couple of years .. and I needed some that I could use a hammer on (my Blue Spruce dovetail chisels have African Blackwood handles and are just for pushing), and I had time on my hands while the glue was drying on a veneer repair ... and ... oh, who am I kidding, I just wanted a set like these ;)

One of the reasons for my interest in the rehandled LNs was that I had a bunch of Stanley #750s that I wanted to modify - I hope no one is offended here. Believe me they were not in good condition when I started out - and the handles for the LNs and the Stanleys are essentially the same design/shape.

I finished them up today. Made a completely new set of handles in She-oak - these you can hammer on with a genno ... and the genno will come off second best. This stuff is tough.



The sizes are 1", 3/4", 1/2", 3/8", 1/4" and 1/8".

A better gauge of the colour and figure ...


(My apologies for the lack of clarity - my SLR was stolen returning to Perth from Cape Town about a month ago - apparently a common occurence there. Wish someone had warned me. Due to be replaced soon).

The blades were all hollow profiled on the sides (as per the method in my article). The 1", 3/4", 1/2" and 1/8" are badged "#750". The 3/8" is badged "Stanley" (but is considered to be a #750). The 1/4" is badged "Made in USA" and is not a #750. In fact the shape was different to the others here and I ground it to match. It also would not hold an edge for long, so I re-tempered the steel (took about 5 minutes with torches), and now is excellent.


The 1/8" is a #750 but began life as a 1/4" chisel. I am quite pleased with this one ..



I do not recall having seen a 1/8" #750 - anyone have one that they can post a picture of here?

Just a by-the-way .. Before making these handles I did try an alternate design ..


I thought the shape/concept very appealing aesthetically. However, on trying it out I found that I missed the indent at the transition that provided a place to push against.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#2

Those are purdy!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Nice job Derek, especially the handles. How or what did you do to get them all the same size and shape (relatively speaking)?

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#3

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

Andy Lincoln ,in Dearborn,MI

Derek,

Those look really great.Do you have an idea of the postage from Down Under to the states?

I want to be sure and reimburse you for the postage when my chisels arrive.: )

Really they do look great.How much time do you figure you have into the handles.Was it tough to

fit each one?

Andy

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#4

Thanks for the tutorial and

Bruce, a MN Galoot

congratulations on a well done job.

Question: Your handles are longer than either the Blue Spruce or the LN's. What made you decide on that - balance, feel, esthetics?

Thanks,

Bruce

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#5

Re: Those are purdy!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Scott.

I made 773 and chose the best 6.

Actually, that's close. I made 2, did not like them but found the rhythm, and the next 6 were fine.

Regards fropm Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#6

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Andy

Hmm ... when can I expect the check? :)

Speed? The more one does, the faster it goes. I think that it took about two of hours in all.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#7

Handle preferences and chisel design

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

Chisel handles are an interesting area. I meant to ask this when I posted originally, but it appears to have slipped away - what is your preferred handle type?

For paring I like a long handle. I have several Japanese slicks and the long handles balance the long blades. Long handles lighten the blade for more control? Perhaps this is why the lighter tanged types make better paring chisels than the socketed design? Or is that just me?

Why did I reject the straight handle for the #750s? That seems contrary to my choice for the Japanese slicks. I think it depends how you hold a chisel handle, and how you plan to push it.

The finger recess on the 750-type does allow for more down force. I really love the aesthetics of the straight handled version I made. But in practice the recessed version just felt better in the hand.

Then there are handles for wacking - hooped or not ....

What do others think and prefer?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#8

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for your answer, Derek, that helps.

I've held only a couple different styles of chisels: Japanese, Berg, Hirsch and some nondescript Freud I had for a while. My preference is for Berg, but they're my go-to chisel for most things that don't require beating. The Hirsch get beat on, but they're firmers.

Until recently, I'd never had my hands on a LN or Stanley 750-style chisel handle. About 2 months ago, I ran into a guy at a MN Woodturners Assoc meeting who is a friend of Tom L-N and who designs handles for him. He had one of a new line of chisels along and I got to fondle it (and no, I don't know what was new about it). The handle was very similar to the 750 and LN current lines and was surely an eye-opener for me.

So, fast forward a bit, and last weekend I turned a couple handles for two socket chisels that Bill H gave me (thanks, Bill!) and used the general LN/750 design, sized to fit my hands. That design IMHO has lasted for a long time for a reason - it fit very well.

With that as a backdrop, I'm interested in any deviations from that format. You started with the LN and Blue Spruce (IMHO the prettiest chisel I've ever seen) but chose to make your own longer, so I was curious what advantage that longer handle has over the other two designs. I prefer shorter chisels and can't explain why, but then I don't have to, either, and neither do you. "Like" is what it is.

I'm thinking of making a couple dovetail chisels from scratch, but they won't be sockets, of course; they'll be more along the line of the BS.

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#9

Observations of a neophyte hobbyist

Stuart Hough

I am in no way anything other than a neophyte that aspires to attain knowledge and skill approaching the level of most on this forum. Having said that, I have acquired several styles of chisels, from old Swans and Witherby's to turn-of-the-century and newer Stanleys and the like. One thing I have noticed (and am glad to be able to offer my opinion on) is that the Stanley 750-style handles, along with the Witherbys, seem to "fall to hand" intuitively, and in my hand at least, seem to allow me to work with the chisel more easliy and with more confidence. I still have a lot to learn, but I really like the feel these handles give me when I'm working with they are attached to. Just my VERY humble opinion.

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#10

Handle preferences and chisel design

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Interesting question Derek. For me the most comfy handles are the ones on my Stanley 40 & 50's (everlasting). The weight of these are a bit much sometimes, but I like the way they feel in my hand. Most of my chisels are Japanese (with hoops). Their nice but sometimes seem to small in diameter. I have 1 LN chisel and the the handle is nice, but seems a bit short.

I have a different idea on pairing chisels. It's my opinion no one makes a good pairing chisel today. Paring chisels should have long thin blades and a relatively short handle for pushing like the old Marples and Witherby chisels.

The blade is what guides the cut not the handle.

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#11

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Dean J in MN

I'm fond of the old school tapered octagon handles...


Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#12

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Is that the one you were using at the MWTCA meet in Medina? Wish I'd looked more carefully.

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#13

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Dean

How does this design compare with others, both straight (like Japanese slicks) and traditional (like Stanley/LN/BS)? My first thought is that my hand would want to slide down the handle, which would not make for a secure grip.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#14

scott grandstaff

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design *LINK*

scott grandstaff

Ahhh chisel handles!!

Who could pick? Who would want to?

Just when I think I have a favorite pattern, I try another and love that too.

I like long and short and fat and curvy. Sometimes I like them just to be different!

Rectangles and tapers and furniture leg curves!@! Carved and fluted.

Rosewood, boxwood, fruitwood, oak!

inlaid, carved and double helix hand turned brass accents! Inlaid cast pewter.

Who could choose? Who would want to?

yours Scott


chisel handle patterns

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#15

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Scott

I've always enjoyed your chisel handles.... now, since this is intended to be an exercise in understanding the pros and cons of design, which do you prefer to use, and why?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#16

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Dean J in MN

The handles sure do look like one would lose their grip, but in use I've not found that to be the case. The cross section is a rectangle, with the edges clipped off. The long axis is aligned with the bevel, so I have feedback of the orientation of the tool in my hands. When I am roughing out rabbets, or using the chisles in the "former chisel" mode I hold them a la moxon, right hand near the bevel and the butt of the chisel in my shoulder, driving with my body.


When I pare, I also hold the tool as near the bevel as possible, and the other hand is more or less partially wrapped over the butt, arms locked to my body and driven forward with my legs. I wish this photo showed my other hand, but I hope you get the idea.


I don't like rounded handles, they poke into my shoulder... :)

Dean

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#17

Re: Handle preferences and chisel design

Dean J in MN

Bruce --

Yes, same chisels as we used during the demo at MWTCA.

-Dean

Re: Stanley #750 dovetail chilsels

#18

Re: Handle preferences

Bob Hackett

As most of you know I prefer socket chisels and my preferences tend toward something that works with that socket.

I like the lower section of the handle to be an extension of that socket and either continue that taper( if the chisel is a large one) or flare slightly to fit my hand.

I like the "stepped handle" as it provides purchase for my thumb and first finger when I wrap them around the minor diameter above the step and then the rest of my hand holds the socket/transition.

I make my chisel handles overly large to help with my diminished grip and the main body has a barrel shape above the step.I also include multiple grooves burned into the largest part of the barrel to help my grip.

For rough work with driven chisels I`ve tried hoops,caps in leather and metal and just plain nothing.For the real grunt chisels I like a cap idea I made using SS tube as a hoop and a SS carriage bolt head as a dome or "striking button" like on a wood plane.I use mostly mallets of wood or urethane to drive chisels so mushrooming is not a problem and the capped hoop eliminates the driving the hoop into the handle body problem.The capped hoop is held with a dab of silicone sealer to keep it in place as the wood shrinks in winter.

Double duty chisels,used for both paring and driving usually get a handle capped with heavy leather washers cut from either shoe sole leather or old industrial flat belts when I can find them.

One thing I like about a socket chisel is that if I decide to drive with my body I can quickly change the handle from a short ball/paring handle to a mini slick handle just by rapping the side of the blade on a piece of wood to loosen the socket and then switch handles for the change of approach.Having this ability works much better for me as it lets me get both hands comfortable in a variety of grips and I find the longer slick type handles allow me to get as much power as driving just pushing with my body and the control is much better.

I now use my larger gouges and some specialty chisels(like corner chisels) with long handles to good effect.Being hunched over driving the chisel with my shoulder (the site of 3 surgeries) didn`t work for me so I went to the longer handle with a large button/knob on the end like a slick and when I put either a pad or my hand between the flared end and my shoulder I am in a more upright position I find more comfortable and can get more power behind the cut too.

The longer handle also helps in steering a cut or better sensing if you`re square while cutting.

I will try to unravel the mystery of posting pics and then maybe take some to better illustrate what I`m rambling about if needed.

MB