squaring an edge
les winter
New post on u-tube by Lie-Nielsen on squaring or repairing nicked edges. I thought it was very cool.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPDxEb98ah8
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
squaring an edge
les winter
New post on u-tube by Lie-Nielsen on squaring or repairing nicked edges. I thought it was very cool.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPDxEb98ah8
Re: squaring an edge
David Weaver
I think I hear Larry coming!
I hope the secondary bevel that was imposed onto the iron in the first part of the video was fake (the enormous high wear bevel). I think it probably was. I'd hate to remove that with sandpaper and a honing guide (I used to do exactly that).
A coarse wheel on a grinder should remove any chance of getting as hot as he's talking about when squaring the edge. I've never used anything but a coarse wheel to do that, unless it's really minor, and then a tormek.
And my last bit - I noticed that a 60 grit belt on one of those cheap low speed bench top belt sanders barely makes the edge of an iron warm if you check it from time to time. I wouldn't be afraid to square an edge with one of those for even a second.
But, I recognize why Lie Nielsen can't make a video dealing with all of that high speed powered stuff, because they would be seeing a lot of beginners sending them back blued irons asking if they could get new ones because "something's wrong with this one and it won't hold an edge".
Boy oh boy, though, I sure am glad I'm no longer using a long run of sandpaper and a honing guide to do primaries any longer.
Re: squaring an edge
Dean J in MN
More than one way to skin a cat, but I'd much rather spend my time working wood so I use my high speed grinder to square (or camber) an edge.
If you grind that new edge (square or cambered) at 90 degrees to the wheel and with a light touch there is nearly zero chance of burning. Once the edge is shaped, work the bevel, again light touch and you're off and running.
Larry recommends this method, so I think I hear him coming too! 
If you live in fear of your grinder -- head to the local hardware store, buy some mild steel and grind some bevels on it (or use some beater chisels). Do it until you can manage to grind without getting the steel too hot to comfortable hold in your bare hand -- light touch, high speed grinder and a freshly dressed coarse wheel is all you need. Once you learn the skill, you own it for life.
-Dean
well.....
Larry Williams
I've got to agree with Dean, once one learns to grind they'll never look back.
But then I like Deneb and Don and I once enjoyed an incredible salmon dinner at his home. Kate is a great cook!
I also don't know what Lie-Nielsen's policy is about customers calling after having grinding problems. It could be they just replace the irons for people and I can understand why they might prefer people don't grind. This may be especially true given the number of people I see recommend WoodCraft's 8" slow speed grinder. I've worked with one and think I might have better success avoiding overheating tools if I tried to remove metal with a torch. I've been trying to pick battles and not take on that grinder too but it's probably a mistake. The only wheel I've seen that can match the white wheel on that grinder for poor quality and high heat is the 5" white wheel on Delta's Wet/Dry grinder. Please don't recommend these things if you haven't used them.
messed that up *LINK*
Larry Williams
It was Don and I who had dinner at Deneb's. Sorry for the clumsy editing.
BTW, one of the problems with saying I don't care for WoodCraft's grinder is that I don't really have a good alternative other than a Baldor or a Kalamazoo and these are both relatively expensive. Grizzly has a belt grinder but it needs a lot of modification to really be useful. I do have hopes for the belt grinder offered by General International, one of the sponsors here. Has anyone used their belt grinder?
General International belt grinder
Coupla questions
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Larry,
Is the problem the Woodcraft grinder, or the wheel that comes with it? Or both? You mentioned the wheel being poor.
The variable speed grinders (6" and 8") which Woodcraft is now offering have 60g white wheels rated at L. 'L' is a hard wheel and could be expected to load up. Dunno if the wheel you used is the L wheel.
But anyway, what about just getting a softer wheel for the same machine, like Joel's seeded gel 'I' wheel. Would that work? Or was there too much play in the machine you used?
Anyone else have one of these machines? What is your experience?
Wiley ..... all questions today
Re: Coupla questions
Bob Hackett
You can look to the turning forum`s archives for info on the variable speed grinder put out by Delta.The speed control seems to be the weak link.
Most metalworkers who want a heavy duty variable speed machine are going to a belt sander with a 3 phase motor and a VFD control.That`s what most pro knife makers are using.Google Burr King to see an example.
The problem with a blanket blessing on any one grinder is that it disregards that we are individuals and as such have a widely variable array of approaches.
I know a few people who could burn HCS on a hand grinder,a water cooled wheel would be their only hope power wise but for them I would recommend the LN approach.
Other people have the technique down but tend to be either impatient or heavy handed.For them belted abrasive may serve better as they grind cooler than the same grit wheel.The quick change belts also allow for using the same machine for everything from roughing out an edge to power honing.
What I do is buy grinders at garage sales after I plug them in and test for reasonable performance and sloppy bearings.The wheel is the key to the system,anything of reasonable power and no slop in the bearings/spindle(to include end play) will spin a wheel.Getting the best wheel for the job is the critical part.Once you understand what the numbers on a wheel mean you can make an informed decision on what will and will not work given your approach and the steel in hand.
After the wheel is brought home you need to balance and mount the wheel and then true it.I favor a diamond point for both truing and dressing my wheels.I buy just the points and make the holders/handles and usually incorporate some type of adjustable system to control depth.A simple round collar on the shaft that holds the point is all I need most times.
One of the things I like about a single diamond point is that it allows me to free hand a custom shape on the face of a wheel if I want.
Burr King... I like!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I don't know what it was
Larry Williams
Several years ago I taught part-time in a local high school woodworking program and was there for a year. The grinder with the Wolverine attachment was new when I got there and I spent a few hours trying to figure out a technique or dressing schedule to deal with that grinder. I wasn't having any luck and asked them to purchase a coarse gray wheel for the grinder. They agreed to put one in the budget for the next year but that didn't do me any good.
I had a worn out bottom-of-the-line Craftsman 6" grinder in my shop which I'd replaced it with a better grinder. I repaired this grinder with parts cannibalized from an old metal-bodied Skil saw and donated it with a worn star-wheel dresser to the school. Even though the tool rests on that grinder were unsuitable, it was the grinder I used and taught students to use. Those who were interested did pretty well at grinding as long as they stayed away from that WoodCraft grinder.
I have no idea what wheel it was but it was too fine, loaded in a heart-beat and dulled quickly.
Re: squaring an edge
scott grandstaff
Learn to grind, learn to grind, learn to grind
If you just settle in and practice, you can grind whatever you want! Not just a plane or chisel blade. Anything!
Pull off whatever is on your grinder when you get it, first thing, and throw it away. Right into the trash, don't even bother keeping for "just in case".
Get the coarsest wheel you can find. Norton makes a passable 46, but Pacific Abrasives is the champ at 36 grit. It costs no more but they are harder to find.
Snagging wheel they call it. These cut outstandingly fast and hardly ever heat up the steel unless you mess up, and mess up bad.
Fine is not the answer here. Fine wheels are no particle of the answer especially when you are starting.
If you want to do things the easy way, always start with the coarsest you have. Get down to some fresh meat, first thing.
That primped and primed and fine tuned edge you used to have??
You don't want that anymore. Its gone. Used up, too far gone to save.
Get rid if it altogether and get you a good place to start again. Expose some brand new fresh steel and have the full working hollow ground geometry on your side again. Makes every other step a piece of cake. Hone and strop for seconds instead of hours when you have the geometry on your side.
And you get the geometry in 45 seconds at the grinder!
Start with an old junk lawn mower blade. Or your own lawn mower blade off your mower.
It probably needs maintenance anyway.
Dig in and don't stop until you have sweet even deep hollow grinds, matching, at each end. Set the tool rest for the proper bevel if you want, but I just set the rest square to the wheel and leave it there, myself.
You can gauge the bevel easy enough with a bit of practice. No sense setting yourself up as a dependent. Eyeball it, you'll get it.
So what if you mess up to start??
You are going to mess up at the beginning!! This is a given.
Don't -even- let yourself care. Its just part of the show.
Don't stop or even slow down. Stick with it. Address that wheel with your work piece, settle in, and grind.
Keep the dip can handy. I use a coffee can about 3/4 full of water.
First one side then the other and look to see where you are not doing it right, and go again. And again!!
A full length, straight, deep hollow grind is your goal.
You've got plenty of steel so redo a perfect bevel if you want, just for drill.
When you approach an even hollow grind, you can feel it.
Its a "pocket" you drop into. You can lengthen or shorten the bevel as necessary by dropping into the pocket and steering slightly one way or the other. To the top or to the bottom to lengthen or shorten, but still in the pocket.
............................................................................................................
There will be a point near the beginning, you won't think you're going to get it. You'll think this is just too loose and too many chances for error and this is just too damn hard. How am I ever going to find the angle and the pressure, all the while moving across, and keep a sweet bevel going at the sale time??
But................
Right on the other side of this?
Trust me.
Just past that point you think you have to give up?
Right at that next step??
Guess what?
That's when it starts to happen.
That's when you get to boldly cut into the steel at your whim, with vigor, and have it not only behave itself, but you have some surety that its going happen that way.
It becomes comfortable and secure, in other words.
Like and old friend who is going to take a nasty job off your hands for you, and make it sweet as a tart.
Make it just how you wanted and no trouble at all.
You are already moving past it in your head to the next step.
Learn this, and you can grind every plane blade you own (well except the molding blades), every chisel you own, the kitchen shears and the hedge trimmers, your pocketknife and tiny eyebrow/cuticle shears........ all of them,
..........faster than you can suffer though one-single-chipped-1/2"-chisel doing it the way shown in this video for the learning challenged.
You buy your grinder only once. You buy one wheel, it lasts for a decade or more.
Nothing else works anywhere near so fast and cheap, and trust me, a fresh hollow grind when you want one, and you usually will, is nice.... and soooo forgiving.
Here is a hollow ground bevel.
From almost 3/16" stock down to ~1/32 near the edge, when the secondary bevel takes over.
Full hollow to the spine. Both sides equal. Not burnt in the process.
And done simply freehand at the grinder. No jigs, no special stuff. Just a piece of steel, an old grinder, and me.
And guys, I'm not the best by a longshot.
There are scads of guys this good with a grinder.
You only have to learn this once and then you'll be free. Forever!
yours Scott
Re: well.....
ThomD
While I mostly don't bother with water, when grinding fragile steels, or with bad wheels, one trick is to dip the tool in water and grind only so lang as the tool end remains wet. The minute the tool dries up, dip it again. Don't electrocute yoursel, people! The water is really there just to give a visual cue that the edge is under 200F. Of course if the wheel is super frustrating, one may not make a lot of progress, but at least one shouldn't ruin edges.
Re: messed that up
ThomD
Like General, never heard of that belt size though. The deal is that they don't make the serious belts (or distribute them) for other than the 1x42 and 2x72. May not be true everywhere just my observation.
I have a KMG grinder:
http://www.beaumontmetalworks.com/grinder.html
It started out as a forum project for people to build and buy parts from KMG. People mostly seem to prefer just buying the thing outright. The buildalong is on Bladeforums, though they seem stingy with search, so it may be hard to find...
There is lots of this kind of stuff out there.
Re: messed that up
ThomD
D'oh
http://www.dfoggknives.com/PDF/GrinderPlans.pdf