Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

Posts

Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#1

Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Does anyone know whether Lee Valley's chairmaker's scraper (link below) is modeled after an historic design or whether it's original with Lee Valley? If the latter, it looks like Woodcraft likes the idea too, since they seem to have copied it pretty well outright, as evidenced by the WoodRiver "Deluxe Scraper Set" visible at this address:

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2020573/23361/WoodRiver-Deluxe-Scraper-Set.aspx?refcode=10IN05RL


Lee Valley's handle-with-knob scraper

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#2

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal?

David Weaver

This was actually brought up before, and I think woodcraft, when contacted by LV, said they'd sell their stock out. This one is a little different looking, but not in a material sense. I guess they decided they're going to sell one anyway.

I think the one they had before was the "borg" copy that japan woodworker carries (JWW never stopped selling it).

Not a big fan of knockoffs like that.

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#3

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal?

chuckbeck in cent il

I really despise the deceptions of W&*^dRiver. If I need a tool they steal, then I'll just make the tool myself if I can't afford the real deal and put it down on the next one from Lee Valley. Woodcraft is becoming a slander around here.

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#4

scott grandstaff

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal?

scott grandstaff

Well, it looks pretty bad for Woodcraft alright.

Not much originality at the --very-- least.

But, the basic tool is a yacht scraper for taking the barnacles off your hull. Works for lots of other jobs as well.

It goes back before 1900 in that configuration. Stanley made one. Starrett.

Lots and lots of others too.

Before the metal frame, wood handles go back centuries. I am pretty sure the Phoenicians had something.

Here's mine. An altered Stanley from long before either one of these current ones. I like the new ones, but there isn't much beef to the frame.


yours Scott

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#5

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal?

Bob Hackett

It`s no doubt made in China too.

If this type of thing bothers you at all(and IMO it should) then I hope it bothers you enough to spend that extra money and support the folks who went thru the trouble to do the R&D and bring it to you in it`s first incarnation.

When you buy a rip-off like this it`s just rewarding the folks who rob other`s ideas.Not to mention that they are taking that idea and having it manufactured in either a 3rd world or communist country in order to cut the throat of the people who developed it.

It really is becoming more and more important to think about what we support with our dollars and where they go when they leave our hands.

That`s about as close as I care to skate to the political edge for now.

Anybody interested in a slightly used soapbox?

MB

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#6

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal?

Rob Lee

Hi Bill -

While it's not a new concept, ours is an original design.

Cheers -

Rob Lee

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#7

Now I HAVE to buy the skew blocks

Chuck Nickerson

as a show of support for LV. If my wife was a stronger supporter of intellectual copyright concepts it might help justify the purchase, but she's basically just frugal.

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal? *LINK*

#8

Re: Another woodcraft idea steal?

ThomD

I'd do the same make it myself, though... Sorta a difference without a distinction as far as the copying goes.