Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Diamond Paste sharpening CPM 3V - Bill Tindall

Posts

Diamond Paste sharpening CPM 3V - Bill Tindall

#1

Diamond Paste sharpening CPM 3V - Bill Tindall

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I've been reading the old threads on CPM 3V and sharpening when I came across the problem of diamond particles lodging in the CPM 3V grooves from the grinder. As nearly as I can tell, the solution was to get an ultrasonic cleaner (David Barnett's idea); but David suggested we'd need a large one for chisels and plane blades. True? Is this the current state of the art? Or did using water based paste also solve the problem?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Diamond Paste sharpening CPM 3V - Bill Tindall

#2

My method for 3V

Steve Elliott

Since Bill hasn't chimed in, here's what I find to work well for 3V and M2:

Remove most of the metal by grinding. A standard Tormek wheel works, though somewhat slowly. A Norton 3X wheel works well too, and burning the edge is less of a danger because 3V is tempered at around 1000 deg. F. I like to establish the final edge shape (straight or cambered) on the grinder which takes a little finesse, but it's really not that hard to learn.

For a straight edge (jointer plane or chisel) I believe Bill uses a coarse diamond plate to take out any slight irregularities. Since the diamond isn't loose there's no problem with contamination due to larger particles sticking to the blade. I skip this step and just go to final honing.

Do the final honing using 1 micron or smaller loose diamond on cast iron. Increasing the angle a few degrees means you only need to remove a very small amount of steel. The 1 micron size is my choice based on wanting speed and a practical level of sharpness, but I sometimes use the same lapping plate with 1/2 or 1/4 micron diamond when I want an extra-keen edge.

I find it better to charge the lapping plate each time I hone. I rub a few tiny dabs of paste around with my finger and add a few drops of paint thinner. It takes maybe 30 seconds. After I'm done I wipe the plate off with a few drops of paint thinner.

I've tried hard maple as a substrate and it worked pretty well. I only used a trailing stroke to avoid digging the edge into the wood and the maple ended up black. MDF seems like it would be pretty soft but I haven't tried it. Acrylic has a stickier feel than cast iron but the diamond embeds in it OK.

Chromium Oxide cuts 3V well and the half-micron 3M microfinishing film gives a very sharp edge. Before I had cast iron I used the film attached to a flat substrate as a lapping plate and put diamond paste on that. It worked very well but eventually the film got bald and needed to be replaced.

Despite having a diamond protocol for 3V I still prefer waterstones for putting the final edge on Japanese blades. The softer feel just seems right, less harsh. There's something to finding a good match between the steel and the sharpening medium.

As to ultrasonic cleaners, I haven't tried them because I wanted to keep my method simple. They may work fine, but precise grinding can eliminate the need for intermediate grit sizes.

Re: Diamond Paste sharpening CPM 3V - Bill Tindall

#3

Following the leaders

Bob Hackett

I follow pretty much what Steve and Bill do because that`s where I learned about it.

I`d like to add these few changes;

I go from a 60 grit white grinding wheel(what I was using for turning at the time) on my 8" bench grinder to the fixed diamond plate(DMT medium) and then to 1/2 micron loose diamond.I bought enough to fill 2 medium sized plastic pill bottles for $10 on Ebay so now my brother and I both have a lifetime supply.

I use a cut down CI tablesaw table as a substrate and light olive oil to turn the diamond into paste and clean the swarf off the plate.

Honing pretty much any kind of HSS or CPM takes no longer than honing HCS with either oil or water stones,less actually because there`s no need to flatten anything,ever.

I have found both grinding and honing more enjoyable since I put magnifying lamps on both the grinder and the honing station and raised the grinder up to chest level.The lamp on the grinder needs to have a plastic lens as the sparks will embed and pit a glass one,lesson learned.

I`ve found that initial setting of any edge on the grinder goes better for me if I use a black magic marker on the back of whatever I`m grinding and then scribe the grind line into that blackened face so I can see it.I set my tool rest flat to the wheel((90 degrees to the wheel`s face,or the rest is pointed to the grinder`s shaft) and grind to the line.Once I establish the shape I want the edge to be I then adjust the rest(mine is a wide,flat plate BTW) to the bevel/bezel angle I need and grind till the sparks skate over the blackened face of the tool I`m grinding.The sparks skating over the top is my indicator that I`ve ground all the flat away.

From there it`s off to the diamonds.

Re: Diamond Paste sharpening CPM 3V - Bill Tindall

#4

Thanks, Steve & Bob

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OK, this seems doable. The Kanaban arrived today, much heavier than I'd thought it would be, plus it came wrapped in some plastic called Ferobrite, with the warning not to remove it until ready to use, volatile corrosion inhibitor. And I probably ordered too many grits of diamond paste - 5 water and 3 mineral oil. Also ordered a diamond plate. This should do it, now to find a CPM chisel for testing, so if you know of anyone who wants to sell one, please yell.

Steve, I'm with you on the ultrasonic, too much for the moment. For my Japanese steel, I plan to continue with natural stones for the foreseeable future; but your comment is intriguing, may have to swipe one of them over the diamond just for kicks.

Bob, thanks for the detail, magnifiers and grinder placement to follow.

Pam