Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

A stupid question.....

Posts

A stupid question.....

#1

A stupid question.....

Edward in Vancouver

How exactly do you hold a marking/striking knife?

Say you want to mark a straight line using a combination square, does the bevel of the knife go against the edge, or the flat (face) side go against the edge?

This has been bothering me for quite a while. I don't want to chew up the edges of my square with a knife, and for the longest time I've been using pieces of scrap.

Re: A stupid question.....

#2

Re: A stupid question.....

bugbear

I have a tiny back bevel on the "flat" side of the blade, so that when the knife is flat on the straight edge the cutting edge juuust clears, and doesn't dig in.

BugBear

Re: A stupid question.....

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: A stupid question.....

Jack Guzman from Maine

Edward,

It depends. When marking dovetails for instance,the flat side is on the edge of your saw cut,the bevel is in the waste. .Or if you're marking a piece to length the bevel is the cut side.The trick to keep from cutting your straightedge is the angle at which you hold the knife.I aim it so the leading edge is just slightly off the guide. Turn it inward just slightly and you cut into the guide. Sometimes I have to run the bevel side against the guide. That way it's a little trickier to keep it in your line. I tip the knife so the flat on the bevel side is vertical.---Jack

Re: A stupid question.....

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

There are no stupid questions

Jack Guzman from Maine

If one person doesn't know the answer,the question is valid.---Jack

Re: A stupid question.....

#5

Re: A stupid question..... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Here's a link to Jeff Gorman's views on this. From this page several years ago I decided to place the bevel flat up against the edge I'm marking. Please note I haven't reread this in detail for some years.

Pam


Jeff Gorman's knife page

Re: A stupid question.....

#6

Re: A stupid question.....

Thomd

Just be sure not to let your finger overhang the edge of the ruler when using knives with relatively acute edge end geometry. One reason I like the low angle japanese knives. Also protects wooden squares.

Re: A stupid question.....

#7

Re: A stupid question.....

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for the links and information. If I understand correctly, it's not if the bevel is against or away from the straight edge, but the angle at how you hold the knife.

I have been practicing, first with wood (scrap) straightedges, and now with el-cheapo steel straight edges rubbed with a sharpie. (to see if I make any nicks)

Still need a bit of practice....