Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

Posts

Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#1

Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

Marv

This is a no-name 12" 13ppi tenon rip backsaw. The handle was only about .700 thick. I added enough to each side of the hand grip, using Mahogany to increase the thickness to 7/8". The original handle is Beech.



Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#2

How "Do you do that voodoo that you do so well"?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Another incredible job, Marv! It appears that the scale of the wheat carving is finer than others you've done, or is that just my imagination?

I would never have thought to apply additional wood to the handle -- another good idea to store away.

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#3

Re: How "Do you do that voodoo that you do so well

Marv

Hi Bruce,

Voodoo? Well, I start with a lousy handle and start sawing and rasping and carving until it looks like something that feels good and won't hurt my eyes to look at. This thing has been hanging around my shop for a couple years trying to get my attention. I kept it covered with an old rag so I wouldn't have to look at it everyday. It actually has a good blade that cleaned up nicely. It had a missing tooth that took several jointings and filings to make it grow back.

Yes, I did the wheats a little closer together on this one. There's no two handles alike.

The finish on this one is a coat of pine stain on the Beech part for the purpose of blending some of the darkened spots that shows up on old Beech wood. And four coats of clear Lacquer, 00 steelwooled between coats and a final 0000 steelwooling and a good rub down with a common paper towel. The 0000 steelwool gently removes the dipped-in-honey look that lacquer produces and leaves a mild sheen that is glass smooth that feels really nice when you wrap your hand around the hand grip.

I filed the teeth with a 4 degree rake that makes it cut fast but not grabby. Not much set, about .004 each side.

Marv

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#4

Purty ! Nice save !

steve mackay

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#5

Stunning!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Marv,

That is magnificent craftsmanship! I agree with Bruce--your wheat carving sure does take to that mahogany!

Where do these saws go?

Wiley

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#6

Re: Stunning!

Marv

Thanks Wiley, :)

I have a list of customers who I let know that I have a certain saw available. One of them will either buy it or they will refer one of their friends to me.

I gained some recognition when I used to sell on eBay a lot. That brought a number of customers my way outside of eBay. I have a number of saw friends who I have helped learn how to sharpen and rework their saws. They refer people to me who ask them for saws.

I don't advertise because I don't want to get into a business mode where I could get bogged down with the daily grind that would suck all the fun out of it.

I do quite few saws that people send to me for reconditioning or just to be sharpened.

The most fun is to take a saw like this one that is horrible to look at and transform it into what it might have looked like if it had been made 75 years earlier and make it function as it should.

Marv

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#7

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear

wilbur

Fabulous job on that saw handle, Marv!

Did you consider putting a lamb's tongue on the handle when you were working on it? It looks like you're already more than halfway there.

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#8

OK Marv, It's nice but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I don't see any green at all :D

Excellent, as usual.

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#9

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear *LINK*

Marv

Hi Wilbur,

Yes, I did consider it, but the cheek part of the handle is so unusually thin, I decided against it.

I did do another one that was similar to this one in it's original form that I added a lamb's tongue to.

Below is a link to a Picasa album that shows lots of before and after pictures of the saw I did for a customer last year that includes the lamb's tongue. This saw required an adnormal amount of work.

Marv





Backsaw overhaul with lanb's tongue

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#10

Believe it or not.....

Marv

Thanks Scott,

Believe it or not, there is actually a tinge of green embedded in the wood just below the upper horn. I'm not sure what it is, but no amount of rasping, scraping or sanding would make it go away.

Marv

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#11

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear

Ace Karner

Another great save, you are the master! I recently finished re-shaping and sharpening a Acme 120 using your wonderful tutorial you wrote up on Woodnet and it came out great.

I now have a request, could you please post a pictorial on your wheat carving, I would love to see the tools and technique you use.

Your faithful if somewhat delinquent student.

Ace

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#12

OK Mr Wizzard!

Bob Hackett

Time to empty those sleeves.

Where else can we find more of your inspirational work?

These before,during and after pics are definite article material and I,for one ,will take all I can get so...

More,more,more (he says as he holds up a lighter in each hand)!!

PS-I am officially stealing the lamination technique.Big hands need big grips and I`ve always been a ham handed kind of guy. :D

Thanks for the post and pics Marv.

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#13

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear

Marv

Hi Ace,

I think you might be confusing me with Daryl Weir. Last year, Daryl did a tutorial on how to properly file an Acme 120. Congratulations on successfully following his instructions.

The main purpose for the Acme 120 as I'm sure you already know, is to produce a very smooth cut with no set in the teeth and is to be used to cut only hardwoods. I suggested to Daryl that perhaps the same thing can be accomplished with an "extra" ground Disston No.12. Daryl agreed but pointed out that the pointier teeth would dull faster due to the No.12 not having as hard a blade. However, when you can file your own saws, it becomes a moot point, so to speak.

I'm in the process of doing a tutorial/pictorial for my wheat carving technique. I'm doing it using the Google Picasa program. Chip carving knives are normally used for wheat carving, but not being an accomplished carver, chip carving knives didn't work for me. I ended up making a special gouge type tool that gives me much better control of size and location for each wheat. It looks simple and actually is after some practice.

Marv

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#14

Re: OK Mr Wizzard!

Marv

Hi Bob,

Thanks for the koodies..uhhhh...I mean Kudoes. :D

When I did the lamination handle, I did first one side, then rough cut it to the shape of the hand grip, then did the other side. I used forstner bits to drill the inside radius for the horns, then merely sawed between the holes. The reason for doing it in two steps was so I could easily see where I was bandsawing without cutting into the original hand grip. The pictures below show some of what was done.

Marv





Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#15

Bee - Yoo - Tee - FUL

Patrick Gibbons

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#16

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear

Ace Karner

You are of course right, you would think that with such a small group of real saw experts I could keep you guys straight :\ On the other hand he's a pretty smart guy to be confused with. :)

I look forward to your tutorial, I too seem to have a real problem with chip carving.

Thanks for you reply.

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#17

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Golf Tee's

Jim in Burlington On

Do you also repair Golf Tee's? Would it not have been easier to start over and make the whole handle?

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#18

Re: Golf Tee's

Marv

I don't play golf...

However, I have attempted making a handle but this is the best I came up with. I intend to keep trying and maybe I can do better with a little practice. :D


Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#19

Re: Golf Tee's

Andy Lincoln ,in Dearborn,MI

Marv,

I see you are using one of my templates to make handles from......

Andy,

with a Disston Mitre saw for a langdon,sitting idle with no handle til I get round 'tuit.

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#20

Re: Golf Tee's

Marv

Hi Andy,

I have several other templates that I've copied from. Perhaps the one in the picture below is also one of yours? ;)

Marv


Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#21

scott grandstaff

Re: completely lovely

scott grandstaff

Way to go Marv

A triumph of salvage. Silk purse indeed. I love to see it.

yours Scott

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#22

scott grandstaff

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear

scott grandstaff

Hey Marv

If you can do this work, this well, you can carve from scratch anytime you want.

Just saw the slot first, or nearly first. Its the hardest part. After that, the rest is pretty easy.

Start saving pix of different handle patterns and when the time comes, take a little from this one and a little from that one and come up with one of your own.

Oh, and make up a short story of your wheat carving soon???

The good artist steals from the great artist.

The great artist steals from everyone.

yours Scott


Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#23

You guys have GOT to stop doing this

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My keyboard's going to short out from all the drool puddles. Geez.

Stunning handle, Scott. Did you make the saw nuts?

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#24

scott grandstaff

Re: You guys have GOT to stop doing this

scott grandstaff

Awww thanks Bill

Yes, its cocobolo and the tiny screws are stuffed with abalone.

The whole saw is about 1/2 size, 16" blade.

For a Little Prince.

yours again Scott

Re: Another butcher job, starting with a sow's ear.

#25

scott grandstaff

Re: forgot the other pic, DoH

scott grandstaff

:b