Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

A question about Shaker detailing

Posts

A question about Shaker detailing

#1

A question about Shaker detailing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am in the process of completing a small Shaker table (it's Mother's Day this Sunday guys and gals!).

Are the pins for tenons always round (which is what I only ever recall seeing) or can they also be square at the surface? Also, were contrasting woods ever used and, if so, what is your opinion of a light wood pin into a dark wood body? A bit strong?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#2

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

Hank Knight

Hi Derek,

All of the reproduction Shaker furniture I've seen has round pins, but most of it is machine made. A lot of the original stuff has round pins too, but I have seen some original Shaker pieces with square pins. I've never seen color contrasting pins. The Shakers frowned upon ornamentation of all kinds; so, unless there is some functional reason for contrasting pin colors, I'd say to leave them off if you want to be faithful to the original concept.

Hank

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#3

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

ThomD

I have seen square pins, but I would have to research it to see where they were. I have always wondered how typical pins were in the first place, they don't show up in all that many antique tables around here. Doors are mostly wedged. But pins are in every timber frame. Anyone know. Will have to pull out a few books.

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#4

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Not only do I want to know if square pins are traditional Shaker (which I suspect they are from my sources so far), but then if the pins are left flush or raised (ala Mission detailing)?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#5

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

David Churnega

I have studied there furniture and have the definitive book of measured drawings. These included the joinery in detail. Contrasting wood is something the did not do.

I can send a drawing if you like. Just idicate what you are building.

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Flush Pins

Moses Yoder

All of the Shaker pins I have seen are flush. This makes it easier to clean, and the Shakers were all about simplicity.

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#7

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

Martin from Texas

Derek,

I have been to almost all of the Shaker museums. I have observed a lot of original Shaker furniture. All of the pegs I have seen have been round. They are all flush. I have taken classes from Kelly Mehler. Build a Shaker Table is an excellent video. I asked Kelly why he uses square pegs, when I had never seen them on a real Shaker piece. He said because he thought they looked better. So, if you want to be historically correct, use round pegs. If you want them to look nice, make them square. Kelly drills a round hole. Then takes a square peg, puts it in his pencil sharpener, makes it tapered round on one end, then pounds it into the round hole until the square part forces the hole into a square. Who says you can't put a square peg in a round hole?

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#9

Dry assembly in the gloom

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the offer David. The table is 90% complete - just assembly and finish. Think of a entry hall sized table. I suppose one would call it an occasional table. Lynndy wanted a table for her sewing machine, but not one like the traditional Shaker sewing table, and without a drawer. In the end I stretched a Shaker design, and reduced the end overhang a little for stability. It has breadboard ends.

Here is the dry assembly, taken in poor light so all the detail is lost, but you get an idea of the profile.


I'll post a decent picture on Sunday.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#10

I don't see any pegs. Where are they?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#11

Re: I don't see any pegs. Where are they?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

Heh .. no there are no pegs .. yet. That picture is a dry assembly. I was asking about peg shape before taking the step into pegging the legs.

Here is a picture of the bits and pieces ..


It looks like round pegs are more traditional.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#12

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

R.J. Whelan

Derek,

I went through my book of Shaker furniture last night and didn't find any pictures showing pegs in any other configuration than round.

IMHO, given the turned lower part of the leg, round pegs will look more resonant with the design.

As to contrasting colour: I found no examples of dark wood with light pegs. As dark as the material you're using is, my guess is the pegs will go nearly black when the end grain of the peg soaks up the finish.

Nice little sewing table: I made one for my wife last Christmas (out of walnut): mine was very similar in size, but had tapered legs and two small drawers.

RJ

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#13

Re: I don't see any pegs. Where are they?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I think it's too formal a piece for any pegs, round or square, looks great as is.

Pam

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#14

Formal!?!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Pam, It's a Shaker piece. Nothing formal about it. One must pin the pieces together. Glue alone won't work alone here. Surely you can understand the concept.

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#15

Re: Formal!?!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'm not sure what kind of answer you want here. Do I insult you in return? Do I ignore your insult and expand on why I think the table is formal? Do I complain about your pedestrian assessment of formality? Or do I explain why pegs would look bad on this table in the process of insulting your assessment of glue? Take your pick, I'm waiting.

Derek, might be a good idea to draw imaginary pegs on this table to see how they'd look. Perhaps you could use stopped pegs from the inside out, so they wouldn't show on the exterior.

Pam

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#16

Re: Formal!?!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the suggestions Pam.

Stopped pegs from the inside would be easy enough to do. I do need to use pegs of some form to not only prevent the joint opening up over time, but also the possibilty of racking (as the mortice is open at the top).

I do want the look of Shaker, however, which is why I originally asked about the shape of the pegs. At this time I plan to go with round pegs in the same wood, keep the diameter of the pegs narrow and drill then close in to the shoulder.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#17

Ellis Walentine

Pegs and m&t joints

Ellis Walentine

Hi Derek,

You're right in your allowing the decision to rest on functional concerns. That's what the Shakers did, usually as humbly and discreetly as possible. On small tables, which were not expected to encounter heavy racking forces, one or two pegs might be used but sometimes no pegs were used at all; whereas on larger tables like dining tables and sideboards, multiple pegs might be used. So, stylistically, it doesn't really matter if you use them. As for round vs square, pegs made up through the classical period (until ~1860) were usually whittled round or nearly so. Later pegs may have been machined and would appear more perfectly round. I have no information on whether the same wood was used for the pegs, but I think that is the case. They would appear a shade or two darker because they are endgrain.

None of my resources show open-ended mortises, which greatly compromise the strength of the leg and the joint as you are relying more heavily on the glue to hold it all together. In that case, I think pegs would be a good idea.

Ellis

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#18

stone mold and Shaker brain dump

Adam Cherubini

Derek,

If it's not too late, I suggest added a "stone mold" to the top's edges. I would underbevel the top all around then round off the upper surface with a bench plane (not a molding plane) Creating the so called stone mold. The upper radius will be greater than the lower radius.

Also, there's something funny about your apron. Maybe too small. I might have extended it to the pommels on the legs. I might suggest a nailed on molding there, like a cockbead. These sorts of features were not unheard of. Both the rounded table edge and the bead help maintain finish and allow for a nice hand hold to move the piece (which the Shakers did frequently).

As for pegs, I have only seen round pegs and I assume them to be structural, never decorative. As for contrast, they typically seemed to unify pieces incorporating different species with paint washes or stains. I don't think contrast was what they were after.

Socially/politically, Shakers were egalitarians or communists. You'll see these sensibilities reflected in their furniture. Some of their chest of drawers or built-ins for example will have all the drawers the same size. The reason for this is that members of the congregation were sharing these pieces and each got the same amount of storage space. Pieces for their own use will even have number plates on the doors and drawers so members could identify their cubbies.

Sometimes it's difficult to represent the original builders' philosophy in a piece. But I think where you can, you get a better reproduction. Knowing about the poeple can also help you answer questions like this one. Fundamentally, I don't think you'd see non-functional decoration on Shaker furniture (I'm sure there are exceptions).

They did, however, incorporate things like simple moldings into their furniture where they felt it served some utilitarian function. They also wanted things to be pretty and their version of pretty was shaped by the furniture and other decorative arts they were raised with. So their furniture forms are often similar to Federal.

Shaker is a deconstructionist style. They may have had unique forms, but I can't think of any off the top of my head. So when you think of Shaker, think of the style of the time without the ornamentation.

Like Mission, I think Shaker is popular because it's easy to make and mass produce (I'm thinking Pottery Barn furniture). But to do it well, you really have to get inside their heads and reproduce all the little details and get them just right. I think Becksvoort does a really great job.

Adam

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#19

Re: stone mold and Shaker brain dump

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Adam

Thank you for the detailed reply. This was not an insignificant effort.

What I'd like to do is use your comments/critique as the basis for further discussion. I'll reply to each point, and then hope that others may chime in as well.

I'll pop in that horrible picture again, the one taken in the dark, so we have an image to go with your points ...


The rationale behind this table: The idea was to build a small table in the Shaker style that was high enough to take a standard diningroom chair, which makes this the same height (30") as a Shaker dining/work table but it would be about 3" higher than the classic Shaker side table.

If it's not too late, I suggest added a "stone mold" to the top's edges. I would underbevel the top all around then round off the upper surface with a bench plane (not a molding plane) Creating the so called stone mold. The upper radius will be greater than the lower radius.

Every Shaker tabletop in this style has square edges. Some tops are bevelled from the underside, but I have not seen one that has round edges.

Also, there's something funny about your apron. Maybe too small.

You are correct. I deliberately reduced the width of the apron from about 4 1/2" to 3 1/2" as i wanted a lighter look. Lynndy did not want a drawer, which is likely the reason why the traditional Shaker apron has a wide appearance.

The top is 33" long and 19" deep. There is a table in Beckvoort's book (page 154) with identical dimensions (although it has slim drawers at each end and the overhang is just a little greater). I was not aware of it until this minute. So there! Goodness me, I was not expecting that!

I might have extended it to the pommels on the legs. I might suggest a nailed on molding there, like a cockbead. These sorts of features were not unheard of. Both the rounded table edge and the bead help maintain finish and allow for a nice hand hold to move the piece (which the Shakers did frequently).

I think that the proportion of the apron down the pommel is correct. Neverthless I actually do like the idea of a cockbead molding along the bottom of the apron, something I have used with several other pieces.


Adding a cockbead is easy enough, and I will try this out and see if it re-balances the apron in a positive way.

As for pegs, I have only seen round pegs and I assume them to be structural, never decorative. As for contrast, they typically seemed to unify pieces incorporating different species with paint washes or stains. I don't think contrast was what they were after.

As noted elsewhere, round pegs it will be (made with my trusty dowel plate).

Like Mission, I think Shaker is popular because it's easy to make and mass produce (I'm thinking Pottery Barn furniture). But to do it well, you really have to get inside their heads and reproduce all the little details and get them just right. I think Becksvoort does a really great job.

I have the Beckvoort book, as noted above, in which he has some wonderful pieces. I also have a book by Moser.

I think that Shaker furniture is frequently copied commercially because its lack of ornamentation lends itself more easily to mass production, while hobbiests may view it as less of a challenge. Personally I like simple lines where the proportions create the sense of balance. This balance is harder to achieve than one realises. All to often I see "Shaker" pieces looking chunky and clumsy. Perhaps the slimness of my effort may be seen as a reaction to these.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#20

Re: stone mold and Shaker brain dump

Bob Hackett

Derek,I think you may have hit on one of the most overlooked aspects of Shaker work,the simplicity.

As anyone who has taken a (seemingly) simple design and expanded upon it will tell you,The more simple the work the more difficult it is to bring through in a balanced execution that looks right.

A direct copy is one thing but a spin off or adaptation of a proven design is most times a hard run at recapturing the feel and overall spirit of the original.

MB.

PS-Wouldn`t the Shaker oval nested boxes be an original form?Their rockers are also a very unique form.

(He says knowing there`s very little new under the sun)

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#22

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

R.J. Whelan

Derek,

Unfortunately, at this time, I don't have a working camera.

RJ

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#23

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

thomd

On the apron, I agree it is too small. I did a kids Shaker art table once, and was partially following a leg design from FWW for a coffee table, so I guess that is where I got the idea. The part that didn't look right to me was that the apron was small but the leg turning did not start until about an inch down, as on your table. Over the years that has bothered me, on an otherwise pleasing table. But if it looks right to your eye...

Also, whether one uses a drawer or not the leg clearance is still the same for the same height, and the need to resist racking also.

I don't normally use pegs. I know they are all the rage, but the glue surface area is massive with tenons, and if properly sized they have all the strength required. There is the diff movement issue, but I have canoe seats I built with tenons in the early 80s, and they are still tight in cherry in a much harsher environment. Also, What if the diff movement does cause a joint failure, far better to use epoxy or hide glue that are reglueable, than to be loose, but held with a pin and still have to remake the joint.

My table was made of hickory over cherry, which looks nicer than I would have thought. Your wood is very rich, lucky place to live woodwise.

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#24

Answer? I didn't ask a question...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Also I don't see any insults as well. I don't think any Shaker piece of furniture is "formal". That's not how or why they made furniture. As I see it, it's utilitarian.

Sorry if I stepped on your toes.

Re: A question about Shaker detailing

#25

Re: Answer? I didn't ask a question...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

formal: adjective

1 done in accordance with rules of convention or etiquette; suitable for or constituting an official or important situation or occasion : a formal dinner party.

� (of a person or their manner) prim or stiff.

� of or denoting a style of writing or public speaking characterized by more elaborate grammatical structures and more conservative and technical vocabulary.

� (esp. of a house or garden) arranged in a regular, classical, and symmetrical manner.

2 officially sanctioned or recognized : a formal complaint.

� having a conventionally recognized form, structure, or set of rules : he had little formal education.

3 of or concerned with outward form or appearance, esp. as distinct from content or matter : I don't know enough about art to appreciate the purely formal qualities.

� having the form or appearance without the spirit : his sacrifice will be more formal than real.

� of or relating to linguistic or logical form as opposed to function or meaning.

In addition, I think there's an elegance in the simplicity of well done Shaker furniture that should be honored, and I think that showing joinery does not honor that elegance.

Pam