Re: accurate inlay
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Eliot,
Caveat: I haven't done the job you're describing. I assume you want the lift plate flush with the router table.
Thoughts: Doing this job with handtools is considerably simplified if you can laminate the router table, because that would obviate having to do a precision job of digging out a 9x12 field to a precise depth.
What I'd do is make a surround for the lift plate that is the right height. Then screw/glue it down onto the base of the router table, centered over the spindle hole.
For example, suppose the lift plate is 3/8" thick, and you want the total thickness of the router table to be 7/8" thick. Then the strategy is to make yourself a 1/2" thick base that is 16x20, or whatever the overall table size. Then make yourself a 3/8" thick panel that is also 16x20 (or whatever). Position the router lift plate where you want it on the 3/8" panel, and clamp it down so it doesn't move. I would pencil around the lift plate, and key everything to the inside edge of the pencil line.
First make the corners. Figure out the radius of the corners of the lift plate, and match that with a drill--Forstner or brad point. The key thing is that you don't want the drill to skate. So you need a way to exactly register the drill onto your 3/8" panel. I would locate the drill at each corner by eye, so the drill matches the inside arc of the pencil. Then press the drill into the panel, so that it's brad point marks the spot. Take a scribe and deepen that mark. Then chuck the drill into whatever you're gonna use--I'd use a brace--register the brad point into the marks you've made, and drill straight through the 3/8" panel into wood backing (so you don't have a mess on the backside).
Now connect the dots. You have a pencil line which connects the holes you've drilled, and is tangent to them. Clamp a straight edge alone each of those four straight lines between the holes, and knife along the straight edge, so that you have knifed the inside edge of your pencil lines. You are later going to register a chisel in those knife lines--that's why you want a physical mark.
Now saw out the bulk of the waste, going as close as you dare to your pencil lines. This is the great saving of the lamination method, because you just saw out a hole in the 3/8" panel, and don't have to dig out a precision recess in solid stock with a hand router.
Now take a chisel (they always say a 'sharp chisel', but sharp is understood with any hand tool--otherwise they don't work). Take the chisel, and nibble away the waste until you're very close to your knifed lines. The final chisel cut is registered in the knife line--just lean over onto the haft of the chisel and drive it down with your body weight.
Test against your router lift plate, and make any fine adjustments with the chisel.
This whole method is predicated on your being able to find a drill that is the exact radius of the router lift plate corners. If that isn't possible, then we have to talk about gouges......
Wiley