Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Recurve Bow - resources?

Posts

Recurve Bow - resources?

#1

Recurve Bow - resources?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

Hi, all -

After a LONG hiatus from woodworking, I'm itching to start a new project - a recurve bow. I've done some googling, but thought I'd ask here - anyone done this? Any pointers or supremely good resources I should be checking out?

TIA,

Scott

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#2

I've made several *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and have gotten all my supplies from Bingham. He's loaded with advice, too.

BTW, you can make a lot of the stuff yourself, especially parallel, non-tapered laminations, risers and tips. The oven can be made from light bulbs and foil-faced insulation, and the mold is nothing more than some mdf and fire hose.

It's been a while since I put one together, but if you have questions fire away.

BTW, Mike Fedora, of Fedora Archery some place in Pennsylvania, makes some of the very best bows in existence. He was really helpful to me.


Bingham Archery

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#3

Re: I've made several

Scott in Douglassville, PA

Thanks, Bruce! I've had a look through Bingham's site. Lots to glean. FWIW, I intend on doing as much as possible myself, so I'm sure I'll be hounding you with questions along the way.

Fedora's site is inspiring.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#4

Re: I've made several

Bruce, a MN Galoot

be sure to call Bingham. He's an entertaining character - opinionated, knowledgeable, informative. There is no such thing as a question too small for him.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#5

Re: I've made several

ThomD

I have made bows, was really ionto it in the 80s, and 90s, and did a bit a few years ago.

I would recomend in addition, pirates of archeyr site. There is some stupid politics between various sites, but pirates seems to have a lot of actual numbers around composite plastic bows (fiberglass, carbon).

Of course recurve doesn't break it out as to whether you want to make wood or glass type recurves. All wood bows can be pretty much as high performance but are working a lot closer to max, and have enviro sympathies. Still, great way to learn design and tillering on the cheap. If you want to learn about wood, get the \bowyers \bible books. \book 4 has all new info so if you don't want to read all three, that would be where to start. Also Tim Baker's articles are the best one how they tick. In books 1 and 4, with 4 being up to date. A wooden bow is an ultimate hand tool project in that it can all be done by hand and is done to a fairly high standard, though not all that difficult just what you do counts.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#6

Plus, if you're at all interested in longbows *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

there is an enormous amount of info and instruction to be found

click on Self Bows and Laminated Bows


here

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#8

Speaking of longbows...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

...and perhaps OT for here, but I'll ask anyway: Fundamentally, what's the practical difference between a recurve and a longbow? I understand the recurve's laminated, and I'm pretty sure the recurve provides a higher velocity for the arrow at the same draw weight, but is that it? I'm attacking this project with a friend, who has a hankerin' for a yew longbow. Would think that, given a nice riven billet of yew/ash/osage orange (whatever), that it'd largely be an exercise in draknives and spokeshaves. Am I on the right track?

Scott

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#9

scott grandstaff

Re: Speaking of longbows...

scott grandstaff

So far as I know, recurve just means the end of the limbs are curved forward.

Whether laminated or steamed.

I have a friend who make traditional bows, strictly local yew (ok, he's the youngest tribal elder).

The bows are very simple. Split a billet (not too long, I live in the dense woods)

Shave it to a bow shape. Tiller it until it draws even and then steam bend the ends.

With nothing but Pacific yew he gets 40-60 pounds draw weight and that is plenty.

They are sometimes fragile so he loses about 1 in 3 to sudden catastrophic failure

(hey, he is just going on his own, nobody here remembers how they used to do it once).

But they are cool and there is always red hot interest at the tribal gatherings.

And you ought to see his arrows!! Now those are spectacular! A thin straight hollow kind of brush that grows around here. Its a bush that grows at the edges of the forest, in small draws that look like wide creekbeds, but aren't. Since they are hollow, he packs them with black sand (yes the stuff that collects in the bottom of the gold pan with the nuggets) for added weight and impact.

Before packing he straightens them with a hot rock that has a hole in it.

Heat the rock and wet the arrow and work it straight.

Anyway, you can't really go so far wrong with a simple bow. Just plunge in and give it a few tries.

Don't expect everything to work right away, keep at it.

You'll be fine.

yours Scott

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#10

Re: Speaking of longbows...

Hank Knight

Scott,

A "self bow" is simple stick with the string attached to each end and tightened to form an arc or bow. All primitive bows are self bows. The "long bow" is a self bow that is longer and heavier than most. It came into use in England in the Middle Ages. Some English examples are almost seven feet long with draw weights in excess of 100 lbs. They had much more striking and penetrating power than primitive self bows, so much so they could easily penetrate plate armor. Consequently, plate armor was immediately rendered obsolete, and the long bow quickly became the standard weapon for armed conflict throughout Western Europe.

The "recurve bow" first appeared in China and has been around for a long time - like thousands of years. It is a more sophisticated design than the self bow or the long bow and was the product of more highly advanced Chinese weapons technology. The recurve bow was prevalent for centuries in other parts of Asia as well, like Persia and Japan. It features graceful reverse curves at the end of its limbs - hence the "recurve" name. The curves give the bow a more "whippy" action and significantly more velocity than a straight self bow. A recurve bow will be shorter and lighter than a long bow with comparable striking power so they were more convenient to use and carry around. They were much more effective than self bows for fighting from horseback.

Modern limb materials like fiberglass and other exotics and modern glues made laminated recurve bows stronger and relatively easy to build. They were the mainstay of sport archery for a long time. Now, however, they have given way to the "compound bow" that uses cables and pulleys to achive great power with relatively light draw weights. Unfortunately, the graceful recurve bow is becoming something a relic and is appreciated by a diminishing number of traditionalists like me.

Probably more than you wanted to know.

Hank

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#11

Thanks, Hank...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

After shooting a bow for 30 some-odd years, it's funny that I only have/had a superficial knowledge of this stuff.

There's a balance to be had on this project: The guy I'm working with has his sights set on a classic, "Robin Hood"-type yew long bow. I think there's an assumption of ease of building there. Personally, I'd like to make either a recurve selfbow or recurve composite bow. I've been doing a bit of research today, and understand tillering on a selfbow; not sure yet how that'd be accomplished with a composite bow. Yet.

This is to be a summer project, so there's research time. I really like the idea, though, of resawing and planing my lams, bending on a form, and shaping a riser. The selfbows seem almost too simple in construction, though I'm sure that's naive. An excuse to use my steamer, though, is enticing...

Scott

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#12

Re: Thanks, Hank...

Hank Knight

I've been a bow shooter all my life - not so much now but, I still enjoy it. I've long wanted to build a recurve bow and have done a lot of reading about it. It's one of those projects I never seem to get around to - always something more pressing. I'll be iterested in how your project goes. Please post about it.

Hank

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#13

Tillering a recurve

Bruce, a MN Galoot

isn't much different from tillering a longbow. My experience with longbows has been with composites - laminated maple cores (a product called "superflex actionwood") with very thin walnut laminations that I made and clear fiberglass. There was very little reflex in the limbs.

The recurves were target bows, white fiberglass and maple lams.

Tillering a composite bow is accomplished by taking minute amounts off the width of the limbs, being VERY careful in the process. We're talking maybe 1/64" at a shot. There's a lot of theory that is beyond me that goes into the design of the limb wrt where to taper, thinner ends, narrower limbs, etc. It all has to do with the "whip" that Hank refers to.

I've seen some pretty snazzy bows made of zebrawood, osage orange, red elm and bamboo. Howard Hill shot bamboo bows as high as 115 lbs, shooting solid aluminum arrows for penetration. A friend of mine made his first bow of bamboo and fiberglass, 1-1/2" wide near the riser and 70 long. He was unable to brace it to string it. In fact, he put it between two chairs, stood on it and it still wouldn't bend enough to string. He had to cut it down to about 1" wide and the draw weight was 82 lbs.

Come to think of it, I think I have a reprint of a book at home on how to build a composite recurve. I'll see if I can find a reference for you.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#14

Re: Speaking of longbows...

Thomd

These days it is really difficult to answer this question. There is at the competitive level a class distinction between longbows and recurves, so there is a motive to stretch the distinction as far as possible so as to win in the longbow category. The same thing applies in hunting where there are fewer class type rules and still a premium payed by some on what constitutes a longbow. In addition this is not something that is agreed upon internationally so you get a different response in the UK where the longbow of English history originated, and there isn't the same hunting or competitive situation as in the US and Canada or elsewhere. At the moment I have about half a dozen longbows and they range from a classic English longbow by Don Adams to a custom aluminum riser model with laminated recurve limbs that is shortish (yeah, it is a "longbow". Some longbows these days are as short as 50 some inches.

The techie definition is that on a longbow the string does not touch the limbs except at the nocks, while on the recurve it follows the limb tips. This has led to a new category of bow which has recurved limbs but not so much as to allow string touch. These have been around for a long time except the new version uses laminated limbs that have a reverse taper built into them and is know as a Hybrid.

- Not all longbows are self-bows, Many modern ones are laminated, either wood or glass.

-The English longbow, notwithstanding it's storied past is not more sophisticated than others out there. Most bows are an adaptation to the available wood, and the field tactics. Yew and Osage are woods that allow the thick/narrow section bow to be made. But equally good bows can be made out of other woods as long as their section is adjusted. One possible reason for the English bow is in order to get as many possible from the available wood, which is rare as a % of overall wood in a given type, and was part of the English tactical advantage.

- Some recurve manufacture is more advanced than self bows, if it uses materials like horn and glue and sinew. These composites are complex, but the real art of archery is in extracting efficiency from culturally available materials and making tactically efficient bows. This is not the province of any one type of bow. The recurve allows the string to maintain an efficient pulling angle on the ends of the limb tips, retarding the onset of "stack", a steepening in the slope of the force draw curve. (how hard to pull at any given length). This allows short bows, but it makes the ends less stable, and there are other ways to get short. It is hard to say what is the fastest bow, but I can tell you that there are straight hickory longbows that have more speed than compound bows (cables and pulleys) had, when I started out 30+ years ago. So who is fastest can depend on who is working on what. Compounds are still faster with their speeds increased by 75% over the same period, and constitute a separate discusion.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#15

Re: Speaking of longbows...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I recall one day at the outdoor range, packing up at the end of my round of shooting my composite longbow, 68", 62# at 32" arrow length (long arms). A compound bow shooter asked if he could try mine. Now, he shot a 75# compound with 60-65% let-off, and he could hardly draw my bow, much less try to hold it to aim. Now this also begs the question of aiming, because it's a completely different theory of shooting. He was impressed, though, by the fact that my bow weighed a whopping 20 oz.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#16

Comment from the peanut gallery

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

by someone who's never shot a bow as an adult, and only a home-made one as a kid:

there are echoes of handtool vs. powertool here; or, for that matter, John Henry vs. the steam hammer.

as a Luddite, I'm happy to hear that the old, simple bows still have both their adherents and their advantages.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#17

Bill, you can make a self longbow

Bruce, a MN Galoot

with an axe, drawknife and spokeshave, and maybe a pocket knife to cut the rest and nocks. A nice rasp would be helpful, too. And a scraper, but you have a bunch of those :D

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#18

I also have far too many

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

drawknives, spokeshaves, rasps, and projects.

I've always dug the English longbows - like a lot of people raised in the 50s, I grew up on the romance of the English defending themselves against the Normans at Hastings, Robin Hood, etc. I think I'd have to work out quite a bit to pull one, though.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#19

Stephen Shepherd

Bow wood

Stephen Shepherd

I have made a few self bows and even a couple of sinew backed bows. I have used yew, osage, ash and maple. The osage orange bow blanks had small sound knots and I was taught that as long as the knots were solid and round they were not a problem.

There is a trend of primitive archers to make their bows of maple and orienting the grain at 90 degrees the normal orientation and getting greater distances with their arrows.

Stephen

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#20

Re: Bow wood

ThomD

90 degrees, like balsacore, or flat vs edge grain? Sounds interesting.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#21

Proof that Hank knows everything.

wilbur

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#22

Re: Comment from the peanut gallery

ThomD

Tactically, if you can hit what you are aiming at, old fashioned bows have all the advantages. They are faster and more flexible, and with the possible exception of the very largest game on earth, they are capable of anything. The very largest game has been taken, it is an open question as to whether that is a good idea for a variety of reasons.

Archery is a steep slope for most people, a very subtle business, in many regards. Compounds have reduced the steepness, and have made it far easier to keep an edge over years of city dwelling without access to practice. But compounds are also tough to shoot if you have to keep up with the Jones. When I was a budding youthful rifle shooter, there was something at the Olympics called the English match (it not me was at the Olympics). 60 rounds prone with a 22. The first perfect score was shot by a Canadian as it happens. Latter in the 90s I was struck by the fact that while rifles are obviously capable of greater accuracy. Some of the unknown distance, open country courses being shot standing by compound bow shooters where boring in on English Match accuracy, though no perfect scores. But it is still amazing what these guys can do.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#23

Re: Speaking of longbows...

ThomD

"I recall one day at the outdoor range, packing up at the end of my round of ... a whopping 20 o"

While there are all kinds of ways of measuring this stuff, it is normally far harder to pull a 75 pound compound than a 75 pound longbow - more area under the force draw curve. Because at the end the draw the compound holding weight drops to zippish levels (one of the great mechanical tricks of all hand tools), it is much harder to hold a longbow at full draw. Many longbow shooters don't hold at full draw as you allude to, while most compound shooters hold at full draw, so it is actually harder to physically handle a compound than a longbow. There are lots of longbows are harder myths that don't stand up. As you know, the main issue is getting the arrows on target. If you can do that with a longbow or recurve, the rest is pretty much gravy (lighter, quicker, faster second shots, much less clutter, faster second shots, easier to hit moving targets etc... So easy when you know how... The hard part is getting good enough in the first place.

Mostly this stuff doesn't have much to do with hand tools, but it is astonishing what the market place has done for this segment of "hand tools" - almost doubled the velocity performance in 30 years, just for starters, it does make you wonder what could be with woodworking tools if anyone cared enough to push it down the road.

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#24

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Bow wood

Stephen Shepherd

Thom,

The grain is oriented with the growth rings oriented toward the direction of flight. So that makes it quartersawn on the widest sides. They are getting some great distance, not quite approaching the Plains Indians laminated horn and antler bows but respectable.

Stephen

Re: Recurve Bow - resources?

#25

Got me, Wilbur!

Hank Knight

I know a little about a few things and absolutely nothing about everything else. ;)