Re: Speaking of longbows...
Thomd
These days it is really difficult to answer this question. There is at the competitive level a class distinction between longbows and recurves, so there is a motive to stretch the distinction as far as possible so as to win in the longbow category. The same thing applies in hunting where there are fewer class type rules and still a premium payed by some on what constitutes a longbow. In addition this is not something that is agreed upon internationally so you get a different response in the UK where the longbow of English history originated, and there isn't the same hunting or competitive situation as in the US and Canada or elsewhere. At the moment I have about half a dozen longbows and they range from a classic English longbow by Don Adams to a custom aluminum riser model with laminated recurve limbs that is shortish (yeah, it is a "longbow". Some longbows these days are as short as 50 some inches.
The techie definition is that on a longbow the string does not touch the limbs except at the nocks, while on the recurve it follows the limb tips. This has led to a new category of bow which has recurved limbs but not so much as to allow string touch. These have been around for a long time except the new version uses laminated limbs that have a reverse taper built into them and is know as a Hybrid.
- Not all longbows are self-bows, Many modern ones are laminated, either wood or glass.
-The English longbow, notwithstanding it's storied past is not more sophisticated than others out there. Most bows are an adaptation to the available wood, and the field tactics. Yew and Osage are woods that allow the thick/narrow section bow to be made. But equally good bows can be made out of other woods as long as their section is adjusted. One possible reason for the English bow is in order to get as many possible from the available wood, which is rare as a % of overall wood in a given type, and was part of the English tactical advantage.
- Some recurve manufacture is more advanced than self bows, if it uses materials like horn and glue and sinew. These composites are complex, but the real art of archery is in extracting efficiency from culturally available materials and making tactically efficient bows. This is not the province of any one type of bow. The recurve allows the string to maintain an efficient pulling angle on the ends of the limb tips, retarding the onset of "stack", a steepening in the slope of the force draw curve. (how hard to pull at any given length). This allows short bows, but it makes the ends less stable, and there are other ways to get short. It is hard to say what is the fastest bow, but I can tell you that there are straight hickory longbows that have more speed than compound bows (cables and pulleys) had, when I started out 30+ years ago. So who is fastest can depend on who is working on what. Compounds are still faster with their speeds increased by 75% over the same period, and constitute a separate discusion.