Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

Posts

Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#1

Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

wilbur

I have a wooden jointer that I think could use some tweaking of the sole. The front of the plane is not completely in line with the rest of the sole. This picture will hopefully show what the issue is. I have a 24" Starrett straightedge positioned on the sole in back of the mouth, and it is completely in contact with the back part of the sole. I can easily slide a piece of paper (0.003") under the straightedge from the front until it gets to about 3/8" in front of the mouth.


What's the best way to fix this? Should I just take another jointer plane to the sole of this one to straighten the sole out?

Or does this need fixing at all?

Also, correcting the sole will certainly get rid of the patina on that part of the plane, so would that get anyone all upset about that?

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

Stephen Shepherd

Does it work in its present condition? Is that a Western Plane? If it works don't do anything, if it doesn't scrape the heel end of the plane.

Stephen

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#3

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Wilbur,

That is a beautiful plane, and I was struck by it when you introduced it a few weeks ago. If it were mine I would fix the sole, because a big woodie jointer like that is fantastically satisfying (to me, anyway!).

One caveat: I only know about woodies in moderate So. Calif. weather--so don't know whether your plane goes through methodical contortions with seasonal weather changes.

If I had the plane here, this is what I would do. Oh, as a preliminary, you already have diagnosed that you're 3 thou out. That particular sole configuration will not work well, because if you're set for a standard 1-2 thou shaving, then anytime you put weight on the rear of the plane, it will lift the blade out of the cut.

You want to proceed in such a way as to minimize what is removed in the mouth area. So, for example, every shaving taken from the far heel of the plane will require an equal shaving to be taken from the mouth. If it were mine, my first attempt would be to take 3 thou from the rear of the mouth, and try to leave the heel alone. You will end up taking a little from the heel, but give ground grudgingly there. Also, if you go with this sloping transect, you will also need to remove a bit from the toe, but that will become apparent. The idea is a sloping transect that is depth neutral at the front of the mouth.

Insert the blade, and set it to usable tension, though retracted a little. Rather than start removing wood wholesale from behind the mouth, I would take a shoulder plane, or other rebate plane, and run a transect which is 3 thou deep behind the mouth, tapering to zero deep at the heel. Check as you go with your straight edge--you are going to get the straight to lay flat, while removing as little as possible.

Once you get the straight edge to lay flat, then use a heavy scraper to reduce the rest of the sole to conform to the 'accurate transect'. As you proceed with all this, use winding sticks of some type to make sure you are keeping twist out of the sole. If there is twist, then you will need to eliminate that as you proceed.

Do you have a flat place (3/8" glass plate, jointer bed, table saw wing, whatever) that checks flat against your straight edge? If so, you can put pencil on it in order to do the final truing of the sole.

I would shellac and wax the sole, but there may be something better. I would defer to Larry Williams or Don McConnell (in a heartbeat, are you kidding?!) on what to apply.

If you don't have one, this would also be a stellar opportunity to buy an 18 x 24, or 12 x 18 granite plate, toolroom grade, doesn't have to be thick--2" or 3". It would allow you to perform quick checks over time on how the sole is doing. The advantage of the granite plate over a straight edge is that the plate will give you a true impression of the entire sole in one shot, whereas a straight edge requires numerous transects plus winding sticks.

Wiley

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#4

Excellent Wiley ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The only change I would suggest is not to add a finish to the sole of the plane once all is done. I would leave this area to be burnished by the work it slides along. If you do wish to add a finish, I would likely use an oil, in other words something that does not sit on the surface of the wood (as Shellac will do). I do not consider wax to be a finish in this area, but more of a lubricant (which is unnecessary with a wooden sole).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#5

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

Marv

Wilbur,

Purely from a logical standpoint, I would say that it is better to have a small amount of off-set in front of the cutting edge. When using a plane such as that, more pressure behind the cutting edge and not any in front would cause the cutting edge to have more of a tendency to grab the high spots

On a motorized jointer, it works just the opposite.....the back part of the table is even with the cutters while the front part is adjustable to control the depth of cut.

Marv

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#6

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

ThomD

While it sounds bad, the sandpaper method is actually very good at getting your plane dead flat, and beating even the competion, assuming you want a flat sole. If you want a lengthwise curved sole to make it so the plane will come closer to making a flat surface rather than a slightly hollowed one, then use a reliable jointer. I would point out that both the Hurlie and Williams hollows and rounds tapes show some profiling with sandpaper. I know it worked for me for 30 years, but apparently it is done by the experts also, if in a different context. Scraping works for anything you want to do, but to get a great result it is not as fast or easy. Of course, you can also plane first and sand after if the sole is way out.

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#7

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Thom

If you went down the sandpaper route, where would you start with this plane? How would you go about it?

The reason I ask is that I do not think it is straight forward. The problem is that the sole has a high point behind the mouth.

Wylie described the same strategy I would use: seeing that the rear of the plane is higher than that forward of the mouth, I would either scrape or draw file that area first, starting behind the mouth and working rearwards. Sanding would need to avoid compounding the the camber that exists. Can it be done?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#8

Re: Wedge!

bugbear

Check the effect of wedge tension - in most woodies the wedge is capable of bowing the entire plane.

This is in addition to the comments of others, not instead of.

BugBear

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#9

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

ThomD

Where the sole is "perfect" just not a working plane, I would go straight to the paper, some PSA on my General jointer bed, or my granite surface plate. The sheet needs to be about the same size as the plane. As with any sanding job one can decided that it needs a pass with a plane first just to get it done. If it is good fresh paper, and the surface it rests on is good, then the plane will come out in the tens without there needing to be any skill on the operator's part.

While I am making confesions, even though I made a special plane for guitar soundboard joints, I use paper on them also. The proportions of those joints, roughly 22 inches long, 1/8" wide, with each plate about 8-9" wide, meant they were essentially rigid. The joint could not be sprung, which is a problem with a jointer, even one with a blade set to cut in the tens. Like using floor joists that are 8 feet deep by 1.5", no flex in that floor!

Obviously whatever works, but this is the simplest method I know, one will get a surface cut to the error in the height of the particles adhered to the sheet of paper. I don't know what that number is, but it is small. I wouldn't be much fun to level a table top this way, and a granite plate that large is too big for my shop, but when dealing with really small sections it is highly practical. This is why planes work as well as they do, one is leveraging the fact that one can polish a very small piece of metal efficiently, and then use the plane to transfer that surface to a larger object like the table, top. But if one is starting with a small object to sart with like the 6 square inches on the guitar soundboard joint, the advantages of planing or scraping are not as compeling.

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#10

Why not for Stanleys, then?

wilbur

I understand the logic behind what you are saying, but if it was a good thing to have a little offset in front of the cutting edge, then why are all metal planes set up with a flat sole? It would be a trivial machining task to mill down the front of the plane by 0.003" or so.

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#11

Re: Why not for Stanleys, then?

Marv

Good question,

I think it would be a good design feature, especially on the larger jointer planes where it is easy to apply pressure behind the blade.

Marv

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#12

Nother example

Marv

Wilbur,

Another example is how the depth of cut is adjusted on a handheld electric planer, the kind with two or three blades. The front part of the sole can be adjusted up and down. I used to have one until I sold it on eBay. Surf board makers pay big bucks for the older ones. The good ones were made by Skil.

Marv

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#13

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

First, remember that you want a sole that's shaped to your specs, whether flat or wavy; and it doesn't matter all that much whether that sole is more or less parallel to the top of the plane.

Second, in making a dai, the wood has been air dried for years and is stacked for drying in fairly regular, neat rectangular shapes; so when the sole is shaped, first you create/maintain flatness by scratching the sole with graphite (pencil), planing the sole in an attempt to remove the markings regularly.

Third, when shaping the sole for a wave, you use a scraping plane (this is not a huge plane made of metal, but a smallish wooden scraper), checking against a straight edge.

Fourth, I've planed/seen planed western woodies with western metal (LN, LV, Stanley, etc.), all successfully. This is not that difficult a job. No particularly special methodology involved, beyond normal planing techniques.

Pam

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#14

Re: Why not for Stanleys, then?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Wilbur, Marv, and all,

The thang is, a bench plane has a sole that is wider than the blade. So the rear sole (behind the blade) cannot drop down into the blade's path, because it is 1/4" or so too wide on either side. This leads to some really nasty and predictable consequences--see third paragraph below.

Does that mean you could still have a split level rebate plane? Well, even there, the machine method would only work at a single height differential, say 2 thou, and only if the orientation of the plane remained north/south to within 1/4 thou of true so as not to get outside the blade track, and only if the wood were already pretty flat, etc etc. You couldn't skew the plane for any reason whatever.

Bottom line: A plane which has a high place behind the blade will give the most aggravating and confusing results of any plane. First, it will only make sporadic contact with the wood. Then, when you cantilever the blade down to where you do have contact, the blade will engage for a short time, then bend, flex, or otherwise lose contact, and erupt out of the work causing nasty tearout, and so on down the length of the board.

If it's a single bump in the middle of the plane behind the mouth, the plane will cut on either edge, but not in the middle, which can cause one to imagine that the blade preparation is the problem--belly in the blade somewhere. You can get this effect on low-angle woodies from too tight a wedge (including particularly Japanese planes) , which creates pressure below the wedge fulcrum and makes the sole bulge behind the mouth. So the indications you get depend quite a bit on exactly where the high place is. It's a tough problem to diagnose, if you don't already know about it, which is the reason for my present wordiness.

Wiley

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#15

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

ThomD

And as I recall we ran out of time trying to scrape your contest plane and you won with a sanded one.

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#16

Well it's not Stanleys but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I can't remember who's patent this was, but it intrigued me.


Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#17

From what I`ve seen...

Bob Hackett

The prep and methodology of a plane where the focus is on the chip varies somewhat from a plane where the concern is the work and especially the finish left in the plane`s wake.

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#18

Daum, someone beat me to it!   

Marv

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#19

Re: Why not for Stanleys, then?

Marv

Wilbur,

Ok, I see what you mean about the blade being narrower than the sole. That makes sense. With a motorized hand planer, the blades are as wide as the sole.

Marv

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#20

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden joint

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't think so, although I claim no perfect memory. What did hold me up even more than the pencil/planing process, it did take quite a while, was the blade prep. It had a major detention/pit in it near the edge; so after I'd diddled about trying to remove 1/4" by hand, Inomoto-san tapped it out in just a few minutes. I was amazed, and it still works perfectly.

I do remember winning the planing contest. :)

Pam

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#21

Re: From what I`ve seen...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

True, sort of, but I think the intent of both concerns is to allow the plane to allow the planer to leave an appropriate finish with ease and confidence.

Pam

Re: Best way to correct the sole of a wooden jointer?

#22

So, do you know whose patent it is, then?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA