Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Bevel terminology--question

Posts

Bevel terminology--question

#1

Bevel terminology--question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Knowledgeable ones,

I have a question, based on some discussion in Wilbur Pan's thread below, where he presents the results of a mortising test. My question concerns the definition of 'secondary bevel'.

I hollow grind many types of blades. On a Tormek usually. And when they are reground, they are reground right to a primary burr. Once the blade is ground, I then need to hone a cutting edge to get back in business. I can put almost any angle I want on the tip of the blade, equal or greater than the overall hollow grind (or even a couple degrees less).

Are we calling whatever edge I put on the hollow ground blade a 'secondary bevel'? For most purposes--though not Wilbur's mortising example!--the honed portion of a hollow ground blade is the only part

of the blade making effective contact with the wood. It's the only bevel that matters, on a paring chisel for example, or a plane blade, or a chisel chopping dovetail waste. In these examples, what is it secondary to?

Wiley

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#2

Re: Bevel terminology--question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

The definition of a secondary bevel is not created in stone. Some agree and others not. Its importance lies in aiding our thinking about a sharpening philosophy. This is more about re-sharpening than just sharpening. More later.

My definition is that a secondary bevel is a bevel (regardless of size) that lies on a different plain to the primary bevel. In other words, a secondary bevel will always be at a high angle to the primary bevel. Below is a diagram ...


In my book there is a difference between a secondary bevel and a microbevel. I am aware that some use these terms interchangeably. A "microbevel" (should be "micro bevel") is a reference to the size of the bevel, in other words, is a very small bevel. It is not a reference to the angle of the bevel. In other words, it is not a secondary bevel. On the other hand, one might have a "micro secondary bevel", which would be a very small secondary bevel.

When we create a hollow grind, there is a choice of grinding a secondary bevel (e.g. at 30 degrees to a primary bevel of 25 degrees), or one might instead hone directly on the hollow primary bevel and create a "coplanar micro bevel" (my term). See below ...


Personally, I like coplanar micro bevels and studiously avoid secondary bevels, especially on chisels. I find that a secondary bevel on a chisel affects the registration when using a chisel bevel down. It is also more difficult to strop a bevel down plane blade that has a secondary micro bevel. The only time I willingly use a secondary bevel is on a blade for a bevel up plane, where the cutting angle is determined by the angle of the secondary bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#3

Re: Bevel terminology--question

wilbur

With my Tormek, I've found that the large diameter of the wheel leaves a very shallow hollow on the tool, which doesn't last very long as I proceed with my sharpening routine.

So the obvious answer is to grind away the hollow, and then you don't have to think about the question any more. ;)

Seriously, for me the primary bevel is the main bevel for the tool as a whole. A secondary bevel is one that is added for a particular purpose, such as adding a 62� microbevel to a LAJ plane blade to take care of curly cherry. This has to be higher than the primary bevel. The hollow left on a tool by the grinder doesn't really count, as you probably set up the tool rest on the grinder to achieve a desired primary bevel angle, and the hollow is just the byproduct of the shape of the grinder wheel.

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#4

Different perspective

Bob Hackett

Coming from a metalworking background the primary bevel is the one that does the work(the cutting).On that mortice chisel pic Derek posted that would be the small bevel that is actually doing the cutting.

That long lower angle on the chisel in the pic would be what I would consider a secondary or clearance bevel and would be ground to allow an edge clearance to work and yet leave enough metal to support the cutting edge.

Metalworkers and most turners(you rub the bevel not the secondary bevel) I know talk about and view an edge from a working standpoint.Hand tools like chisels,cutters and plane irons seem to be viewed from how they are honed rather than how the edge works.

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#5

Re: Bevel terminology--question

Terry in Ottawa

I'm following this thread with interest. I'm never sure what turners mean when they want bevel to ride on the wood. How does that get the cutting edge in to the wood?

From my relatively uninformed position, the metalworker position seems to be the more intuitive explanation.

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#6

Re: Bevel terminology--question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm following this thread with interest. I'm never sure what turners mean when they want bevel to ride on the wood. How does that get the cutting edge in to the wood?

Hi Terry

You are assuming that the lathe chisel has a secondary bevel. I do not hone secondary bevels or use hollow grinds on my lathe tools. I grind a (flat) primary bevel and that is also my cutting edge. (Incidentally, I grind/hone lathe chisels freehand on a disk sander - hence the flat bevel. Generally use 120-240 grit. Since the steel is HSS it will not burn).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#7

Re: Bevel terminology--question

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Weren't there a few woodworkers who were always careful to talk about bezels (1. A slope, a sloping edge or face: esp. that of a chisel or other cutting tool.) rather than bevels (1. verb trans. To cut away or otherwise bring to a slope; to reduce (a square edge) to a more obtuse angle; often with away, off, etc.). So if we're going to establish a naming system for these things, I think we ought to start with bezel for bevel.

I also think that whatever defines the cutting angle should be called the bezel. Any other bezel further from the edge is meaningless.

Pam

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#8

Re: Bevel terminology--question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Terry, this stuff is extremely hard to explain. Frank Pain (Practical Woodturner), writing about 50 years ago, does a good job. Probably best to watch someone and then have them watch you.

Here are some attempts at explanation for a skew chisel. For a fine surface, you want to cut at as low an angle to the work as possible. You lay the bevel on the work so that it does not cut and then slowly raise the handle so that the tool just starts cutting. If you are moving from left to right the bevel rubs on the portion you have just cut (left part of blade), while the center portion of the edge cuts the new material. Besides leaving a clean surface, having the bevel ride the clean work steadies the tool and makes a more uniform surface. If you want a silky surface, hone as fine an edge as you can produce on the tool.

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#9

And don't forget the tertiary bevel

Frank D. in Montreal

My plane blades have 3 bevels: a hollow ground primary bevel, a secondary bevel, and a third, tertiary micro bevel. Charlesworth wrote about sharpening like this, and I'm pretty sure he used these terms. Sharpening with 3 bevels saves a lot of time on the stones.

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#10

Maintaining bevels over time

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Frank,

I admire those who can use multiple bevels and keep track of them. Are you able to manage the third bevel so that it gets 'erased' at every sharpening? Do you camber plane blades, and how then is the third bevel managed? And when do you regrind the hollow--when the secondary is about 1/16", 1/8"...? Plane blades and chisels the same way? Or different?

What I find is that getting the blade sharp right now is not the issue. The issue is managing the edge efficiently over time and over many sharpenings. And maintaining camber.

I can only get into a work rhythm if my methods are simple. It helps me to keep in touch with things if I use a hollow, and hone one bevel, which is self-jigging with the hollow, at an eyeballed 25-27 degrees (chisels and plane blades), and regrind when the honed bevel exceeds about 1/8" wide.** With the one bevel, I can manage camber on try planes and smoothers by hand pressure on the edge; on fore plane or jack it's a more complex rolling motion, but the single honed bevel keeps it as simple as possible.

Something I have done in the past is have the overall hollow at less than 25 degrees, and then hone to whatever matches the work best--25 degrees, 27 degrees, 30 degrees, whatever, none of these angles measured, but approximated by eye. In other words, uncouple the hollowing from the honing angle. But when I do this, I tend to lose track of the last angle I put on the tool. So it just amounts to a rounded-over bevel for practical purposes, when I go to resharpen. So I've left myself a problem. This is why I just do the simplest thing, even though I'm pretty sure it's not technically optimum on any given sharpening.

Could you say a few words about how you manage bevels over time? This is not meant to be challenging--I know you are a thoughtful worker, and have developed methods that will be useful to others.

Thanks! Sorry to be so long-winded.

Wiley

**There are a few Japanese chisels I can't bear to hollow, but these blades are easy to maintain with one simple primary bevel. And many Japanese chisels I do take to the Tormek, because it won't draw the temper, nor make a deep hollow.

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#11

Total agreement

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well described Wiley - a lot more concisely than I.

This is the issue I mention earlier, but did not elaborate on. "Re-sharpening" is much more important than "sharpening". Re-sharpening requires a plan ... a shapening philosophy. This sounds grand but it is just a little forward planning - how one anticipates proceeding when the blade is dull ... will the new edge require a lot or a little work?

Hollow grinding makes freehand honing a doddle, especially when one avoids secondary and multiple bevels. As you do, I hollow grind everything - plane and chisel blades, even Japanese chisel blades (also using a Tormek). The only time I use a honing guide and a secondary bevel is with bevel up plane blades.

I did outline this is an article on my website, for reading if you are struggling with sleep, and preferably with a good schnaps in your free hand ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/BeyondSharpASharpeningStrategy.html

However one chooses to hone their blades is up to the individual. I do not proclaim a Right Way - just the way that suits me. In the beginning it is hard enough just toget a sharp edge, and this alone becomes the goal of the novice. Later we come to find the way that is most efficient, and how to keep working longer with fewer and shorter interruptions.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#12

Re: Maintaining bevels over time

Steve Elliott

Wiley,

This is regarding your comment, "I uncouple the hollowing from the honing angle. But when I do this, I tend to lose track of the last angle I put on the tool."

I've started using a very simple way of keeping track of the main bevel and microbevel angles on plane blades: after sharpening I write both angles on the underside of the blade using a felt-tip marker. My system would be B28/32deg w 1/2u for a blade hollow ground at 28 degrees and honed with 1/2 micron diamond at 32 degrees. The markings don't show when the blade is in the plane and they can be removed using denatured alcohol.

Steve

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#13

Some of my hodgepodge techniques (long)

Frank D. in Montreal

Hi Wiley,

Actually I use slightly different methods for different planes but I'll give a quick summary here.

I use a 6" grinder for just about all of my planes (primary bevel, around 23-25 degrees).

For my jointers (try) and smoothers, I use a very slight camber, almost none, meaning a little less than a thou. I use finger pressure (over the middle of the edge, and each side) and a precise number of strokes to obtain the right camber, and I do it on the secondary bevel each time I sharpen. I just sharpen on a 1000/India and erase the third micro bevel, not paying attention to camber, then in about 15 strokes (depending on the size of the bevel...more for a wide bevel, fewer for a newer, narrower bevel) I put the camber back on to the edge. Then I move to the third bevel on a polishing stone, still using finger pressure, but the stone is too fine to really shape the blade (it just puts a little bevel on the cambered edge that I got on the second bevel). Oh yeah, most of the time I use a Veritas MKI jig.

I regrind the primary bevel when the secondary bevel gets to around half the bevel width, or when erasing the tertiary bevel takes more time than I'd like.

For jack (fore) and scrub (I rarely use a scrub other than for carpentry), I do things a little differently. I grind the primary bevel with the desired camber, then I sharpen by hand, either only a secondary bevel, or if I don't want to go to the grinder, going with 3 bevels. Things get messier more quickly, so I tend not to wait until the secondary bevel gets too big. I don't waste any steel when I grind (true for all my blades), unless I want to rework the camber, because I stop grinding about .01" from the edge (grinding with a tool rest, no jig). If I'm careful when I freehand (rolling as you do), the camber stays pretty much the same, so grinding close to (but stopping before) the edge preserves it. I also don't sharpen my jack or scrub that much...compared to the jointers and smoothers (or jacks that I use as panel planes and not jacks).

For bench chisels up till now I mostly use 3 bevels (except skews and specialty chisels). I don't want to sharpen with one bevel (waste of time and stone, polishing the whole bevel), so if I'm going to lose registration while cutting on the bevel with a micro-bevel, I might as well have 3 bevels instead of 2. an advantage of 3 bevels is that the chisel doesn't dive into the cut as much as with one bevel (again, while cutting upside-down, riding the bevel), and it's easier to lift out of a cut without stopping. In any case, I personally don't get much control at all when a 7" chisel is upside-down resting on one half-inch bevel instead of two or three bevels; I still have to support the chisel at the right cutting angle. The only chisels that I have one bevel on are my Japanese chisels (don't ask me why...I just can't get myself to use my hodge-podge sharpening techniques on such tools). I use a belt sander to grind them when the bevel gets ugly, so no hollow or overheating either.

So that was my turn to be long-winded... I also still have sharpening issues that I need to work on, but that's where I am right now. I'd love to use abrasive grinders instead of my stone grinding wheels, but the cost isn't justified at the moment.


img

Re: Bevel terminology--question

#14

Re: Bevel terminology--question

ThomD

I agree with Derek, I just take the grinding angle of the hollow ground as the primary angle, the angle the rest was set to the tangent point that is parallel to the two highest points of the grind, or something...