So you want to make a dovetail chisel?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
A new article on my website: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Soyouwanttomakeadovetailchisel.html
Regards from Perth
Derek
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
So you want to make a dovetail chisel?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
A new article on my website: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Soyouwanttomakeadovetailchisel.html
Regards from Perth
Derek
Great article Derek, thanks for sharing!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Nice tutorial, Derek, plus a comment and question
Ellis Walentine
I was interested to see your method for dimensioning the tenon. Sometime, try this: Get some modeling clay and pack it into the socket of the chisel, then pull it out and take your dimensions directly from the clay plug. Works for me.
Also, I'd like to hear another discussion of suitable chisel handle woods for striking and paring. I guess any will do for paring, but striking handles should be of something not prone to splitting. Of course, a Schlagring is helpful in preventing splitting. But, what do you folks consider the important properties of chisel handles? Hardness? Interlocking? Toughness? I've made 'em of lilac, dogwood, hickory, mulberry, oak, ebony and others, but I never settled on the ideal wood.
Ellis
I like Mesquite
Phil Joines
Haven't had any problem with splitting but I don't wale away at them either.
Re: Nice tutorial, Derek, plus a comment and quest
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I was interested to see your method for dimensioning the tenon. Sometime, try this: Get some modeling clay and pack it into the socket of the chisel, then pull it out and take your dimensions directly from the clay plug. Works for me.
Hi Ellis
The issue I have with the modelling clay method (and another version of this is to force in aluminium foil) is that you still need to measure the dimensions so that you can transfer them to the wood when turning. All I have done is go directly to the dimensions.
For striking I avoid using very hard and dry wood - Jarrah has great strength but tends to be too brittle when struck. Great as a paring handle though. Fruitwoods seem to absorb blows pretty well in my experience. Then again, I tend to avoid using hard (e.g. steel) hammers on softer wood as the handles come off the losers. I'd rather use a softer mallet and replace that. Having said this, I have the Blue Spruce resin-impregnated mallet (gad, that is gorgeous!) and use it on my Ray Iles mortice chisels, the handles of which are Hornbeam/Ironwood. These are really tough.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Silly puddy!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Sounds silly but it works. Then you can fake funny faces from the comics with it 
Re: I like Mesquite
Bob Hackett
Mesquite was also the favored wood for the heads of caulking mallets.
I had the hardest time chasing it down as the old timers up here were calling it"black screw beam".
Wayne Knuedson who owned One Good Turn before his passing was the one who finally pinned it down for me.Wayne was an encyclopedia of wood related knowledge.He even sent me a billet to make a mallet head and refused payment,he only asked for pics of the finished mallet.
He also recommended it for chisel handles,especially socket chisels.Said it was a more stable wood than hornbeam and would swell less in humid conditions,something for consideration up here where shops are heated and dry in winter yet the summers drive most woods up to 11%+ moisture content during July and August.
MB
Thanks for the timely article
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I am just starting to do exactly this with a couple socket chisels my friend Bill sent me (thanks, Bill!). They are going to become skews just for cleaning out half-blind sockets.
As an aside, why is it that some people (not Bill) can't resist the temptation to beat on defenseless socket chisels and mash the dickens out of those poor sockets? Whoever had these things originally couldn't be bothered to make a replacement handle and just decided to abuse the tool. Uffda!
Re: So you want to make a dovetail chisel?
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I have a hard time understanding why people put such an extreme relief on a "dovetail chisel" when most dovetail angles are 10 degrees or less. For a bevel edged chisel only a very small modification is needed for clearance in a dovetail, a very minor amount of grinding or work on a bench stone.
For socket chisels, I turn the tapered portion of the handle by eye. It is much easier to make a slight adjustment to the taper when fitting the handle than to try and fiddle with measurements which are at best rather imprecise.
I have used a number of woods for chisel handles. Although some talk like handles are vulnerable to spitting, I have never had one split. I would not pick ash as a premium handle wood (ash spits pretty easily as firewood), but I have two ash handled chisels which I have used hard for 40 years without worrying about splitting. If you look at Moxon (late 17th century), or Roubo (18th century), or Nicholson (early 19th century), they show chisels with no socket, no ferrule, and no schlagring.
Handles are expendable
Paul Dzioba
and easy to make. I pretty much use what I have on hand. I like dogwood and hornbeam for socket chisels because they turn so nice on the lathe, apple is really nice too. For tang type chisels I mostly use beech since I make them with a drawknife and not on the lathe. Beech is nice to work with edge tools and has a long history of being used for handles.
Paul Dzioba
Re: I like Mesquite
Phil Joines
Just some trivia, There's two verities that grow in the US Black Bean and Screw Bean. The Black has a grayish red color, the Screw Bean is redder and is what most people want for wood working. The bigger logs come from northern Mexico. It's supposed to be one of the most stable woods and shrinks 1% both radially and tangentially. If you turn a bowl from green it will stay round when it dries.
I've found it to be fairly brittle...
John in NM
But that may also be in the drying - stuff I've used most was sometimes dried overly fast trying to meet shop deadlines.
I have a mallet I made years ago with a mesquite head, it hasn't faired as well as I'd expected, chipping easily around the edges. Still and all, mallets tend to lead a very hard life.
I also once had a small tenon fail on a large mesquite cabinet. The grain orientation was about as bad as it could be, and the tenon failed across the grain under moderate (hand applied) tension - dragging the cabinet over a few inches rather than finding helpers to lift it.
On the other hand, what made the tenon fail - grain will change direction drastically in just a few inches, also could make a very tough handle, more like a burl. I should try finding a piece like that and make another mallet 
Re: So you want to make a dovetail chisel?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I have a hard time understanding why people put such an extreme relief on a "dovetail chisel" when most dovetail angles are 10 degrees or less. For a bevel edged chisel only a very small modification is needed for clearance in a dovetail, a very minor amount of grinding or work on a bench stone.
Hi Warren
I agree with you that most relief angles are overkill. The shoulder of a bevel edge chisel only needs to fit within the angle used on a 1:6 ratio. The amount of relief on the LN is (I assume) because it reproduces the design of the Stanley 750. So the question is why did Stanley design such a large relief? To reduce the mass of the chisel blade? A sort of cross between the rigidity of a firmer and the lower mass of a parer, all in the packaging of a shorter chisel than the true parer?
Most bevel edged chisels tend to have a larger shoulder than desired. While one can chop/pare out dovetails with a firmer chisel, I think that we all agree that it is easier with a chisel that has very narrow shoulders.
Removing even small shoulders is difficult to do freehand. I am not saying that you cannot do this, just that there is benefit in a controlled removal. I have freehand ground the shoulders of several chisels and I know how hard this is - the issue is that one might inadvertantly grind over the shoulder and remove some of the back (or face) of the chisel.
Regards from Perth
Derek