some new work
Catharine Kennedy

fun stuff! Certainly value added!
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
some new work
Catharine Kennedy

fun stuff! Certainly value added!
Re: some new work
Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio
Truly gorgeous!!!
Gorgeous work, Catherine!
Marv
Stunning!
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Holy mackeral, those are great!
Bruce, a MN Galoot
Re: some new work
Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level
Perhaps these weren't "sow's ears" to start with but you sure made silk purses of them anyway! Beautiful.
Tom
Re: some new work
Stephen Shepherd
Nice work, are those old tools?
Stephen
Re: some new work
Catharine Kennedy
Yes, they are- and not mine!
Very nice work!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I like the brace. If I was the owner of those tools I would have never done this too them. I sure like looking at them though.
Re: Very nice work!
Catharine Kennedy
Thanks- but not much different than any other embellishment- to a firearm, a knife or a Zippo lighter!
Scott, I have to agree with you.
Stephen Shepherd
WHAT!?!...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Sorry to disagree with you...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
Like I said, you do wonderful work Catharine. No disputing that.
All I'm saying engraving that brace and the miter plane is just wrong IMHO.
I know your doing what you get paid for. It's the owner I'm wondering about.
That brace is probable only single digits in existence. To do that to a tool like that one is like shaving one of the last mammoths and tattooing it.
Rather hasty judgment
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
This line of comment places Catharine in an impossible position, because it would exceed her remit to comment on the owners' decisions. So I find the attack to be unfair in the first place, even qualifying it to the owner.
On the merits, one needs to know more about the provenance of the tools to judge the owner. I certainly don't know, but would be prepared to make a small bet that the brace pad and fill is at least restored, and possibly replaced. Similarly, the diamond strike on that miter plane doesn't look like vintage factory issue to me--perhaps someone who knows could comment. My point: We don't know enough to judge the brace and miter to be rare, vintage, and original collectibles.
To my eye, Catharine's engraving fits perfectly with the genre of the old shoulder planes, especially. They are ornamental in their own right, and the ornament Catharine has chosen fits them like a glove. Just like I think Marv's wheat-carving looks geat
We are not used to seeing graphic ornament on tools, but take a look at high-end shotguns. One could argue that the only ornament on a Purdey shotgun should be from the Purdey factory; on the other hand, someone else could argue that a Purdey gun engraved by a world-class engraver is still value-added. Depends on the reputation of the engraver.
We may see the day when Catharine's engraving is itself collectible. I would certainly want her initials on anything she engraved for me.
Wiley
Hey! Their not my tools...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
I see your point Wiley. Anybody can do what ever they want with them. A hasty judgment? Not for me I thought about this for a while before posting. It's just not my cup of tea the do that to old and rare tools.
Nuff said.
All in all, my posts have nothing to do with Catharine her self. She does great work. 
Re: Rather hasty judgment
wilbur
"To my eye, Catharine's engraving fits perfectly with the genre of the old shoulder planes, especially. They are ornamental in their own right, and the ornament Catharine has chosen fits them like a glove. Just like I think Marv's wheat-carving looks great."
I think that this is a key point. Not only is the workmanship of the engravings impeccable, but the design of the engravings are extremely well suited to the tools themselves. If someone had shown me a picture of any of these tools and told me that they were a special fancy high end run from the original toolmakers, I would have completely believed them.
Same goes for Marv's wheat carvings.
Re: Scott, I have to agree with you.
Dean Lapinel
Nothing against you Catharine. I enjoy seeing your work but I get a uneasy feeling seeing old tools modified. Just a personal thing.
When I see you work I hope that I am looking at a new tool rather than an antique.
I like the look though, especially the subtle touch on the brace.
Somewhat aside and sliding OT
Bruce, a MN Galoot
I used to work with a guy whose sister was extremely attractive and had majored in art in college. The rest of her family was very results oriented and rode her pretty hard about getting a degree that was more "useful." Well, it turned out she was also a pretty decent hunter and somehow came to the attention of one of the national hunting magazines. She ended up on the cover of one of those mags, don't remember which one.
Well, she had a talent for gun stock engraving and checkering, and as a result of that exposure now has more work than she can fulfill in a lifetime. She's rolling in the dough, doing what she loves.
Re: Sorry to disagree with you...
Moses Yoder
I hate to see tools laying outside on a table, totally exposed to the elements and rusting away till they are useless. I like the thought of someone taking some pride in their tools and taking care of them.
There are two different types of beauty; one is embelished beauty as we see in the work here, and the other is the beauty of simplicity. I like the Shaker style because it has such clean lines and is superbly functional, and I prefer a simple life. On the other hand, I am thinking that if I get some extra money I will send my Lie-Nielson #101 plane to Catherine.
Scott and Stephen, I have to dis-agree with you.
Bob Hackett
I suppose it all springs from your core feelings about the function or place of tools in life.If,like me,you look at tools as simply tools and do not hesitate to use them as a starting point to be tuned and modified to improve their form and function.I do as I have seen done in the past,I fit the tools to my hand as though I were going to make my living with them and have them there for long hours and many days.I make the tools mine and there is no mistaking who owns them if they are borrowed.
For me the engraving is a value added thing.I look at it as adding a bit of art that elevates the spirit of both the tool and the owner.I find the first pic of the scroll work on the shoulder plane to be especially artful and the shading gives the scrolls an almost 3D effect.That particular bit of work stands above the rest of the engraving I`ve seen.It`s like the difference between looking at a painting and then looking at a low relief carving of the same scene.Exceptional work,IMO.
Other people look at tools as something collectible and as such want it in as original condition as possible.In the box,with original wrapping,untouched since it left the factory is the high point for them.Any deviation from the manufacturer is a blemish in their eyes.If looked at as a snapshot of history it is the history of tools and their makers only.
I also have a sense of history in regard for tools.The point of departure seems to be mine includes all the previous owners in it.Those small modifications that added to the comfort of the user or eased the adjustment or improved the function are what gave the tools life.One of the first things a man who made his living with his tools and worked in the company of his peers would do is to mark his tools somehow so they could be identified quickly as his.The signature carving or especially this engraving would more elegantly serve this function than say,a series of notches carved or filed into the base of the tool or initials stamped there.
Funny how the collectors or purists can overlook stamped initials or names but seem to be upset with artwork(like that done by Catherine or Marv) that sets tools apart.The truth is that before factory made stamps became available artwork and the artful use of other common tools like chisels or punches was how the better craftsman set his tools apart from the rest.For those cultures with limited language or literacy skills carving and embellishment are still the historically correct and preferred way to mark your tools and determine ownership.
MB.
Great discussion- all valid points!
Catharine Kennedy
yet another point of view
Bruce, a MN Galoot
Normally I live my life simply, plain without ornamentation. I like Shaker, not Federal or Queen Anne; Mission, but not French Provincial.
However, these works of Catharine's are stunning. What's the difference between the ornamentation that is original to the work, e.g., a Miller's Patent Plough, vs the ornamentation that is added as in Catharine's work? To me none. It looks like it coulda shoulda been there from the start and only a lazy designer didn't put it there.
So there.
I'm with you Wiley...
John in NM
On all points. I think the crucial thing is that the engraving is well chosen to compliment the tools and just looks right. The wrong pattern would stick out like a sore thumb, and choosing motifs that will look right is part of the artistry of engraving.
The trap I think many collectors and historians fall into is that we're seeing only a piece of a tool's long history, and the history does not necessarily end with us. To some extent I agree with the concept of preserving an antique's past, but only in the economic sense, preserving a resale value. I've never liked museums much - it always strikes me as a shame that these things are not being used! Art museums are of course the exception - in being displayed at a museum the art is being used essentially as the artist intended.
With tools especially, the only thing that I find interesting about their history is how they are used. User modifications are fine, IMHO, because you can look at the modifications and maybe learn something about changing methods of work. Similarly, embelishment of high end tools by engraving or the like reflects something about the society in which they were owned and embelished. As long as the engraving will not deceive a future buyer in any way, I see no problem with it, and I think it could be of great interest to a future historian.
A good point you make, Bruce.....
Marv
I have used that very point on occasion to attempt an explanation as to why I do what I do to an old hand saw.
In my opinion, there's nothing wrong with doing to a tool that might or should or could have been done by the original maker.
Below are a couple pictures of before and after of a 1950,s era Disston No.4 backsaw that I just finished. By the 1950,s Disston had junked up their saws to the extent that they were diffcult to look at, let alone use. I realize that this example of adding value might be extreme if compared to what Catherine does. However, the point to be made is, how far do we go when we embellish or change an old tool? Another question is, why do we do it? The answers seem to be elusive. During any discussion on the subject, we always get comparisons to old paintings, such as the MonaLisa or the Last Supper for example. That's a whole different catagory and shouldn't be included in a discussion of carving hand tools. Because we remove famous paintings, etc. from our discussion, value must be part of the equation. Value and appreciation is in the eyes of the beholder, hence the elusivness of answers to the above questions.
We can debate and discuss this issue until we pass out from boredom and still not reach a conclusion. All we get are opinions.
When Catherine shares her expertise and skills as a metal carver, we should be, in my opinion, only judging those aspects of her work. It's not for us to question why she does it, or why she shouldn't do it. She has a skill that produces something that is very pleasent to the eye. To my eye, it is something to behold.
Keep up the great work, Catherine. I'm sure your customers are quite pleased.
Marv

Excellent example,thanks,Marv.
Bob Hackett
This is a perfect example of the start(or departure) point I was talking about.Compare this later model hand grip to an early one(where they cared about appearance and user comfort) and,if you are intending to use the saw,tell me you are not in the least tempted to modify the grip as Marv did.
If you`re not then you`re a collector,buy it and stack it on the shelf among the boxes of other tools.
That grip doesn`t say anything but ease of manufacture to me and what it tells me of is the decline of a once great saw company who is now cutting corners to cut the competition.I understand that decades from now these tools will be sought after just like we seek the early "golden age of hand tools" saws.
That doesn`t make the before pic any less ugly or the factory grip any less painful to use.
Easy to see the value added one more than one level,IMO.
MB