Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Posts

Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#1

Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Charles Jackson III

I will be sharpening all my plane irons and chisel, but I have a question about my current progress! I am wondering how much do I have to do on this chisel pictures below! I started with 1200 grit waterstone but have not when higher yet. Also got something to clean my bench grinder wheels so I can work on the bevels.


img

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Where do you want to get to

Jim in Burlington On

Personally I would give that the 400 grit wet dry paper first. If you want to get to the ultra high end of sharpening you will need to devise a system that will work for you. Personally I take all my chisels up to 8000 grit waterstone.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#3

Re: Where do you want to get to

Charles Jackson III

I think this system works it has in the past.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#4

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Dan Donaldson

If the chisel was in fairly bad shape, then 1200 is a bit fine as a starting point.Four hundred or 800 might be a better start. If you have to go for a long time trying to get it flat, then it is too fine.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#5

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Charles,

What you're looking for: You want to see the same scratch pattern around the periphery of the chisel back--next to the cutting edge and up the sides--for as high up as you want to go. If it's a chopping chisel, I think you're high enough right now; if it's a paring chisel, I would flatten the whole back. [NOTE: If you do flatten up the back, do NOT let the neck get onto the stone and lift the chisel as you're flattening, because that will bevel the back edge near the mouth, and you'll have to grind all that off.]

I can't tell from the photo if the whole periphery is showing the same scratches from the 1200g stone. It looks like it's a little hollow in the middle, which if so is just fine--but you want the edges to be co-planar, i.e., showing the same scratches. If the edges are showing the same scratch pattern, then you're there. If you start with a convex back, then the middle will have to be taken down to bring the edges coplanar. If you feel like you're not getting there with the 1200g, drop down to 320g to 400g w/d, like Jim said. Or coarser, if it's really out of shape. But it looks pretty close to me, right now.

When you start in on the bevel, take a square and mark a bright line across the blade back (looks like it's a bit skewed at present). When you grind, grind just short of that bright line. If the edge is in fact skewed, you can just blunt it off on the grinder til it's square--again, to a point just short of the bright line--and begin the honing sequence, e.g., 1200g, middle stone (if you use one), 6000g or 8000g.

Different people use different honing techniques: I like to hone the bevel all the way to the finish stone, or til the final pass with the middle stone, before backing off and removing the burr. The reason for this is that if you go through all the grits on the bevel to start with, that will thin out the 'hinge' on the primary burr, so it'll just flake off on the finish stone, and leave you very near the desired end point of two planes meeting.

Wiley

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#6

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Charles Jackson III

Thanks guys, I may have to get a lower girt stone.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#7

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Hard to see (at least for me) at what stage you're at. As the others said, a lower grit stone (or sandpaper on a flat substrate) might be indicated.

I would suggest to mark the back of the chisel with red, orange or green marker (something that will remain visible). Then try the chisel on your stone, and if most of the marker is ground off, keep going until all of the marker is erased from the edge. If there's a lot of marker left, it would be wise to go to a coarser grit first, much less work.

Keep in mind that stones need to be flattened periodically. I do it every time I use mine.

Good luck,

DC

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#8

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

Sgian Dubh

Denis, I advise people new to this chisel and plane iron flattening not to be afraid of being aggressive if there's a need. In this case I can't tell for sure from the original image, but if the back is really badly out of whack it won't hurt to stick a bit of 80 grit, or even 60 grit aluminium oxide paper down onto a flat surface and have at it for a minute or two. You can quickly move up the grades to finer and finer once you get the initial flattening done.

I give much the same advice to people new to flattening plane soles: if they're badly dished, stick a bit of 60 grit or 40 grit paper down on a flat surface, eg, a planer (jointer) bed. Here in the UK we can buy rolls of aggressive abrasives like this for floor sanders and the like, and I know you can buy similar stuff in the US and Canada. It may surprise one or two here to know that I've flattened the sole of many a plane to nothing finer than 80 grit or 120 grit to make the plane usefully functional. Granted, chisel backs and plane iron backs need a better polishing up than this, but for plane soles this level of flatness is often good enough, although further refinement will improve things again.

I don't think I've ever spent more than about 15 or 20 minutes flattening a plane iron, chisel back, or plane sole to make the tool functional, although, as I've mentioned, additional refinement could take a little longer. For me these flattening jobs are too tedious to spend much time on as they interfere with making time, and sometimes real aggression at the beginning of the job saves a lot of time. Slainte.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#9

Moses Yoder

Use Sandpaper

Moses Yoder

In my opinion a water stone dishes too rapidly to be of any use for flattening chisel backs and plane irons. What happens is the water stone simply conforms to the shape of the back, and does not flatten the steel. I suggest using 60 or 80 grit sandpaper stuck to 1/2" glass (you can probably get a large scrap of 1/2" glass at a glass shop for about $10) and flattening the back. Then polish with 120 and 220 grit before moving to the 1000 grit water stone. Another thing, if you have only used 1000 grit stones for sharpening then an 8000 grit polishing stone would be an eye opener for you. A sharp chisel feels like it really enjoys cutting wood, whereas a dull chisel always needs to be whipped before it will go to work.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#10

I agree...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Start with sandpaper I usually start at 100 grit. Sometimes 80 grit depending on the shape of the blade.

Re: Flatten my chisels and plane irons

#11

me, too,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

it would be nice to have a stone coarse enough just to flatten the backs of chisels, plane blades, etc, but it's just not feasible for me. Sandpaper, for the little you're going to do this, is the best bet.

Besides, I get 3M wet-or-dry in most grits for $.01 per sheet ;)