Re: In defense of peg board
ThomD
With no disrespect to other choices...
"Peg board is seriously ugly, but eminently practical."
That can be said about anything. For instance, some people, like me, prefer to have wooden planes (got both but prefer wood), many of which are for an individual purpose. Other people like to have one plane with a million adjustments. So the question is which approach should your furniture support? What's the messaging you want to create. How would a customer feel if he was in a maker of say Brian Bogg's stature and all the chairs in use were metal and fiberglass? I mean it isn't a contradiction really there could be reasons why he uses those and his clients buy the wooden ones he makes (not a true story of course).
Now if you take it a step further than that, which person is one? Is one the person who likes solid simple, organic stuff, developed to a very high level. Is one hurting the fabric of one's personality by allowing stuff like pegboard in? Is it a contradiction one simply hasn't dealt with, because it was unnoticed. Of course people can like all kinds of stuff tearing off in all kinds of directions. An example of this kind of thing is in that thread where Wiley is tossing the power tools. Should see my shop. Appointments are available when I get it cleaned up in say 2030.
Other than that. The method I use is not fixed, it would be relatively easy to reposition things, since I can just unscrew the racks or split them off and go again. On the other hand. Since making these racks for chisels and saws, I haven't wanted to change them. I put enough effort into them that I actually like them. In fact, really, if we hadn't started out with pegboard, I think I could be suffering similar criticisms relative to those who make massive cabinets for their tools, though it just so happens I prefer the aesthetics of my current choice. But I could see why others would disagree.
Another thing is that while I have fixed racks I also have some peg racks, not pegboard. I got these from pics of Odates shop. They are rows of horizontal dowels onto which one can lay tools and yet dust doesn't accumulate. They look fairly nice, and can accommodate a huge variety of stuff from hacksaws to chisels to block planes. And they work well for floating tools in and out the space without having to designate them a fixed space.