Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Off topic - water heater and math questions

Posts

Off topic - water heater and math questions

#1

Off topic - water heater and math questions

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

These are related questions.

We're planning to replace our water heater and are dithering between a tankless heater and a moderate to high efficiency tank-type heater. Condensing tank-type heaters, for instance, although they're more expensive than the tankless, seem to have the same annual efficiency. Experiences and opinions welcomed.

On to the math: one of the issues with the tankless heater is the minimum water flow requirements. For instance, one Rinnai model I looked at requires 0.4 gallons per minute (presumably in the hot water circuit, not total flow) to light off the burner. We try to conserve water - our experience of the last 20 years has convinced us that California will have periodic droughts - and it's possible that some of our hot water uses are too low-flow. One example is showering: once I get wet, I turn the water down fairly low for soaping up, before bringing it back up somewhat for rinsing off. I can measure the total water flow in each state, but it's not all hot water, and I am flummoxed how I would calculate what percentage of the flow is hot water. Available tools are a one-gallon bucket, a clock with a second hand, and a kitchen thermometer. Any help will be appreciated.

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

#2

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

Dave Thompson

Hey Bill, I bought a Rinnai tankless last fall. Good news is that a third of the entire purchase and installation cost is an energy tax credit (not merely a deductable). Installation is not trivial since exhaust constraints are quite different than a tank heater. We have unlimited hot water now, though if you're really as conservative with your water as you say, this won't be much benefit. Can't tell any other differences from a tank heater, and of course, no fuel is consumed when hot water is not running.

0.4 gal/minute is really a trickle. I was concerned our high efficiency dishwasher would be an issue...though it isn't. Haven't noticed any low flow issues, though we're not overly conservative, being on our own well pump in an area with no water shortage issues. We have a visitor who will frequently turn off and on a slow flow of hot water as he is washing dishes, and will occasionally set off a short (~5 sec) cold flow. I suspect this has more to do with the way he abruptly shuts off the water. I'm not sure, as my wife and I have never triggered it.

Regarding calculating usage, measure temperature of 100% cold, and 100% hot. Now set and measure your shower temp. You have the info to calculate percentage of hot water. Example cold is 60, and hot is 120, and shower is 100. %hot water used is (100-60)/(120-60) = 67% hot water.

Next set your trickle and measure how much water comes out in a minute. Multiply that by 67%, and you know how much hot water you're using per minute. e.g. 1 gal/min * 67% = 0.67gal/min of hot water.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

#3

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

You need to know the temperature of the hot water and the cold water separately, right? This is assuming the future hot water temp will be the same as at present, but I digress....

How about this. Go to the shower, and turn the cold on, and take its temperature. Write that down. Then run the hot til it's max. hot, and take its temperature. Now blend the shower til it feels right, and measure the blended temperature. You now know all the temps. Now, reduce the flow to the cruise amount you mentioned, then hold the 1 gal. bucket under the shower head for a minute or until the bucket is full, whichever comes first.

Now do the arithmetic. The cruising shower flow is calculated from the bucket-filling experiment. If the 1 gallon bucket fills in 40 seconds, that is 1 gallon divided by 2/3 minute, or 1.5 gpm.

The percentage of hot water in the blended shower flow is calculated from equation:

(H) ( hot temperature) + (1 - H) (cold temperature) = blended temp.

where H is the percentage of hot water, and (1-H) is the percentage of cold water.

Example: Suppose the hot temp. is measured at 140F, the cold temp. is 55F, and the blended temp is 105F. Just making this stuff up. Suppose the cruising flow amount is enough to fill the one gallon bucket in 30 seconds, for 2 gpm.

The equation yields,

(H) (140) + (1-H) (55) = 105

or rearranging,

140H - 55H = 105 - 55

85H = 50

H = 50/85 = 59%.

Recall the cruising (low flow) rate was 2 gpm. So the flow of hot water at the reduced flow is 0.59 x 2 gpm = 1.2 gpm approx. And the flow of cold water is 0.8 gpm.

As a first approximation, that should get you close. There are some quibbles about whether the future hot temp will be same as now, and whether on August 15, it won't take less cold to bring you to desired temp. But this should be close enough.

By the way, I seem to recall that it takes a hell of a power service amperage, and a special electrical setup, to drive the tankless system. Have you figured out what you'd need? I'm curious.

Wiley

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

#4

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

Dave Thompson

Actually, you don't care about the hot water temperature of your old heater if you're trying to figure out if you have a enough flow rate on the new system. For the 100% hot temperature in the above example, you're actually plugging in the temperature setting of your new water heater.

I assume you're looking at a Rinnai R50 or R75. They have a set range of 98-120, or with a special jumper pin pulled, you can go up to 140.

With that in mind, if you're near the bare minimum flow rate, you have some fudge room by adjusting the set temperature. In the above example, if you changed the set temperature from 120 to 110, that would change your hot water percentage to 83%, bumping a 1gal/min shower stream from .67 to .83 gal/min.

good luck,

Dave

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

#5

Re: Off topic - water heater and math questions

R.J. Whelan

Bill,

I have a Rinnai and I'm very pleased with the performance.

The company from whom it was purchased did a flow test before settling on the right model for us: they installed a flow meter on the output of the heater and turned on each load (one at a time): shower, bathtub, dishwasher, cloths washer, kitchen and bathroom sinks. Each of our loads had sufficient flow to light the burner.

We've found that we can use any two loads with no loss of temperature. Adding a third load (ie: shower, shower, dishwasher) did overload the heater, but the boss and I rarely shower at the same time (when we do, we're in the water saving mode anyway :)) .

Good luck with your decision and don't forget to take your tax credit ... rj