Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Question for Pam

Posts

Question for Pam

#1

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Question for Pam

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Sinc you have a fair amount of experience with Japanese tools, I need some advice or assistance.

I've had most of my Japanese chisels (6mm ~ 36mm) for about thirty years. I bought them back in the 1970s and 80s when I was stationed in Okinawa, and they've seen a lot of use, and thus a lot of sharpening.

Several of them are now worn/sharpened almost to the edge of the hollow(s) on their backs.

I seem to remember seeing somewhere that the backs can be peened or reworked to move more metal forward to the cutting edge. Can you tell me anything about this procedure?

Jim D.

Re: Question for Pam

#2

I'm not Pam

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and what I know about Japanese tools could be put on a grain of rice in 12-point type, but I recall Toshio Odate discussing this in either one of his books or an article in Fine Woodworking some years back. As I recall, it involved carefully hammering on the bevel while supporting the back of the blade against the corner of an anvil. But don't trust my memory on that - I can't tell you with much certainty what I had for dinner last night.

Re: Question for Pam

#3

Re: Question for Pam

wilbur

For chisels, a more straightforward way of dealing with this situation is to flatten the whole back. As you wear away the metal on the back side, the flat area right in front of the hollow will widen. Since most of the area on the back is a hollow, you really won't have that much metal to contend with.

The tapping out procedure is usually done on plane blades. You could do this on a wider chisel (and I have done that in the past) but there's more than a trivial learning curve for that procedure.

One of the reasons that tapping out is done on a plane blade is that the hollow on the plane blade is pretty much at an even depth. If you ground the entire back of a plane blade, you could grind away the hollow completely. The hollow on a chisel is deeper towards the handle than it is near the cutting edge, so there will always be some hollow left on the chisel as you work your way back, so it's less of an issue to flatten the entire chisel back.

Re: Question for Pam

#4

Re: Question for Pam

ThomD

The difference in tap out procedure on the hand planes also has to do with altering the taper in the blade which could affect the seat in the plane. This is not an issue with the chisels.

The purpose of the hollow is to allow somewhat similar numbers of strokes, or the same pressure, or the same grit of stone to bring up the back, as the bevel. Back in the 70s sharpening instructions often suggested that working the back of a western chisel was mostly for set-up, not every sharpening. But Japanese chisels are designed to sharpen roughly equaly front and back for the best polish. If you rub on the rear, and towards the edge you should be able to keep chisels sharp and the hollow centered.

Re: Question for Pam

#5

Re: Question for Pam *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

First, if you know the vendor and ever go to Japan, be sure and take a couple of the used up chisels to show him, he'll be excited that some of his chisels have been used thoroughly. :)

Second, as Wilbur and Thom have said, typically only very large chisels are ever tapped out; but to be honest, I don't completely understand why it would ever be necessary because of use, maybe a damaged/chipped edge could require such treatment. Until someone convinces me otherwise, I will continue to consider the chisel hollow as relatively unimportant. A chisel doesn't stop being sharrpenable because there's no hollow in the back; nor does it stop cutting as long as there's hard steel present. Chisels perhaps require a bit more effort when sharpening without the hollow, but so what.

Thirdly, this is why I'm never seduced by those who suggest that I grind small bevels on the backs of any edges, it's just so much easier to keep them flat and conserves the hard steel for when I really need it

Fourthly, I hope this is responsive to your question. I thought it might be interesting to review So's instructions for setting up a new chisel, link below.

Pam


Soatoz's setup procedure