Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Bun Bluing on Planes?

Posts

Bun Bluing on Planes?

#1

Bun Bluing on Planes?

Matthew

Has anyone here applied gun bluing to the sole and sides of your planes? Even with camelia oil, my planes are in constant need of de-rusting in my basement shop. A quick fix with the rust eraser blocks, but I get nervous about creating hollows from repeated use - I know that bluing would help quell the rust, but how would it hold up in use? I was curious if this would have a positive or negative effect in performance...

There must be a quick reason why this is a stupid idea, because I haven't seen it done before, but...

Anyone here try it?

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

#2

Re: Gun Bluing on Planes?

Matthew

Sorry - typo - meant *Gun bluing not *Bun bluing

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

#3

Definitely not on the sole....

John in NM

It would quickly wear off the sole, probably within just a couple sessions of heavy use, just look at holster wear to see how fragile bluing can be. The sides and top would last a lot longer, though I would expect to see wear at frequent grab points within a year or two under heavy use.

As to the rest, as far as I know, cold bluing solutions are still mostly cosmetic, providing very little rust protection. Hot salt bluing is better, though not something you can generally do at home. Rust bluing provides the best protection, and can be done at home, but will have a steep learning curve. I've never seen cast or ductile iron blued either, just steel. I don't imagine it would be impossible, but some experimentation would definitely be in order. You might also be able to parkerize the non-wear parts. Not as pretty as bluing, but should give you better rust resistance.

Most of my planes are old enough to have "browned" some on their own - a process similar to rust bluing. It doesn't affect their use at all, even on the sole. I don't recall ever getting a rust streak, but if I did it'd be easy enough to remove with a card scraper.

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

#4

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

Sgian Dubh

Matthew, maybe you could try something similar to this set up: in this case it's one of my tool cabinets that has a 7 watt low energy bulb running in it permanently. My workshop is also fairly damp, and I never have any rust problems as long as I put the tools away in their place at the end of the day. The heat source is just enough to raise the temperature inside the cabinet to prevent moisture in the air condensing on the tools which could lead to rust.

There are other ways to add a bit of heat using (I think) some kind of heater designed to go inside gun cabinets or something like that. Assuming you are American I imagine you'll pretty quickly work out what those devices are, but here in the UK I've never seen a gun cabinet heater, ha, ha. Slainte.

Photobucket

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

#5

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Like Richard says, putting metal inside wooden boxes works great for rust prevention. The wood seems to usually take up enough of the moisture that it never gets through to the tools; but I don't know about basements, could be the moisture would be more constant so the wood never dries out.

Pam

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

#6

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

Old Baleine

A thin film of this stuff works great:

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=50252&cat=1,43415,43440&ap=1

The one ounce squeeze bottles are especially handy.

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

#7

Re: Bun Bluing on Planes?

ThomD

I have done it. Mostly on chisels though. Something I used to do in the 80s, I guess my current shop isn't too terrible. Works fine. As you may know, gun bluing is not supposed to be all that great. But I was just tying some flies on my Original Bill Hunter HMH vice from the 70s, and I noticed that I had blued all the interchangeable jaws. They have never shown rust, and have not worn off. Where possible wax the bluing.

I haven't done soles, but more so the parts that come in contact with the hands. I don't see a problem if you wax your soles, but it might be even less slippery than the raw material.

Chemical bluing is very similar to the bluing that results from simply heating metal as occurs during hardening, or forging. I assume the skate on the C&W plow plane was "blued", since they take care to blue their irons with heat preparatory to hardening them. Of course you probably shouldn't super heat your cast iron plane. but just as a functional example of what can be done.

Another example would be classic fish hooks.

All of this leads to my preference which is bronze planes (LN, LV, LMII, and St James Bay, to name a few), Or better still, wood.