Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

Posts

Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#1

Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I don't know if you get Foine Woodworking, but, if you do, cover your eyes when you get to page 16 of the current issue: there's a handplane rack that uses a magnetic toolbar to hold the planes in place.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#2

Boy O Boy Bill, I'm glad you warned me...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I'm glad also I let my subscription to "Foine Woodworking" run out :D

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#3

Re: Boy O Boy Bill, I'm glad you warned me...

Dominic in Buck's County PA

You and me both brother!

That "sanding versus scraping competition" article did it for me.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#4

Out of the loop

Dean Lapinel

I missed some apparently interesting threads. Scott...I take it you don't like magnet holders? Is it because of failure to hold or sole damage?

Also this scrape versus sanding thing has played out in the publications before. I found it interesting that the results (as viewed by the folks involved) found no difference in the final finish. I thought this was counter-intuitive and I don't know if I agree but It was of interest to me.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#5

Not replicable results, apparently

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Previously, FWW articles have said there's no difference twixt sanding and planing in the final finish. This time, the FWW judges found the finish on the planed/scraped piece superior, and planing was faster than sanding. Either the variables were controlled differently, or something; scientifically, this means the question is still open.

Yes, Scott Burr has a thing about magnets. I don't think it's quite as strong as his phobia about John Deere Green, though.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#6

Re: Out of the loop

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I can understand the business about planing providing a smoother, finished surface, but my experience with scraping hasn't been the same. Maybe my scraping technique needs some "polishing" or the scraper needs to be sharper, but while a scraper in my hands can tame wild grain the surface isn't as smooth.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#7

John Deere

Dean Lapinel

Thanks Bill,

I guess I can ask Scott privately about the John Deere thing. Seems like I missed a lot of things here. Scott and I share some similar interests but apparently one of those isn't the green. I restored a 1928 JD unstyled B tractor.

Dean

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#8

Re: John Deere

Marv

Dean,

I think Scott might be making reference to my posting down below of a saw I reconditioned and painted the handle John Deere green. I think he likes it and will secretly refinish his LN dovetail saw the same way.

Marv

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#9

Why?

Dean Lapinel

I had a feeling that I shouldn't look but Marv....I had to. I saw the saw, the vision I can't withdraw, seen I the green saw, a sight that should be outlawed.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#10

Guess I was right...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

The 2009 Dec issue killed it for me. After the demise of Woodwork there's nothing left :( .

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#11

Not realy Dean...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I thought I slipped into on of Dante's rings. No posts here for 2 days. That was weird :O

No, I do not like magnets on or near anything I have to sharpen. The swarth stickish to everything and makes sullry of a mess >(

Now John Deere green... :\

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#12

Actually I was fond of these...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I drove a Stiger for a few summers (and over winter) back when I was around 18.

Still I like the old Allis Chalmers and Cat's too.

Red, Yellow and Lime greene for Marv? Naaaaa...

:D

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#14

Hey can we make something positive out of this?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

I haven't had Bruce's problems with scrapers. Mostly because I never use them and when I do their bound in a cast iron body.

I as Bruce have had to other resorts than planing or scraping for that matter.

I'll start a survey here. To get us out of this magnetic green magnetism.

So how many of you actually get away with a scraped surface (hand or held by iron)?

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#15

having never scraped green paint from anything

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't know that I'm qualified to take the survey :D

However, I do scrape occasionally, gnarly grain that resists planing efforts, e.g., a really crappy piece of locust that became the lid for a tool box for my BIL. But I find that it still needs sanding for a truly smooth surface. So either I'm doing something wrong or it really needs sanding for that final effect.

I do love a sharp scraper for taking off the nibs between coats of varnish or shellac. Works absolute wonders.

Can't help with the magnets. I got a rare earth one from Rob Lee to hold the allen wrench to my bandsaw that works exceedingly well.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#16

Re: Actually I was fond of these...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Didn't know they used those in CA. A neighbor of mine back in ND had a couple. I never drove it - the biggest I ever operated was a puny 4020.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#17

Re: Not realy Dean...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

No posts here for 2 days. That was weird

Yeah, maybe all the air was sucked out by Neanderthal Heaven's thread. I keep telling these moderators that conflict creates excitement; but nnnnnnnoooooooo, got a play nicey-nice. :)

Pam

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#18

Yep, We used them tileing and lazer planing...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Lazer planing, kinda sounds funny on this forum ;)

It was very cool to watch the scan of the lazer around midnight on a moonless night with only the tractors lights to guide you.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#20

Re: Well, I guess I missed something...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It appears the thread in question was deleted last night. I'd describe it, but really don't want to restart it here.

Pam

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#21

Re: Well, I guess I missed something...

Marv

Oh come on Pam, give us a hint.....inquiring minds want to know...

Marv

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#22

I`m surprised Marv...

Bob Hackett

You should know better than to try to get Pam involved in controversy!

Strictly by the book,cards close to the vest,tightly buttoned stiff upper lip,that`s our Pam. :D

Don`t you have some handles you need to paint? 8)

MB-Who is feeling the effects of the 2 day vacuum despite all the early gardening activities.

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#23

Re: I`m surprised Marv...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Not a chance, Marv. I really dislike the effect of the person who started it all; so acting on the theory that all press is good press, I'll not mention a name. I will say that we on WC just barely avoided a similar event.

And, Bob, I really don't enter controversy for the sake of controversy; but I do tend to say what I mean, can often be convinced by the other side in any discussion/argument, and think that there's nothing wrong with controversy when it naturally results from said discussion and, in the case of WC, it's woodworking related. If we don't discuss these things, we all tend to curl up in our corners nursing our beliefs, talking only to those who already believe as we do, and render ourselves nugatory.

Pam

Re: Scott Burr: Magnet Alert!

#24

Nugatory?

Bob Hackett

Does that have anything to do with the Mars candy company?

Sorry but my version of Webster`s American Dictionary(for the home,school and office)jumps from nudism to nugget so I`m lost(again).

PS-You seemed to be in a good mood lately so I thought it was OK to throw a little humor in.Hope you didn`t think it was over the top.

I did include the smiley face so people knew I was kidding.

Just me being me.

MB